|
Annals of African Medicine, Vol. 7, No. 1, 2008, pp. 29-34 Audit of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgical Conditions Seen At Port Harcourt, Nigeria E. T.Adebayo1 , S. O.Ajike2 and M. G.Abite3 1 Department of Dental Surgery, Military Hospital, Aba Road, Port Harcourt, Nigeria This paper was presented at the 46th Annual Conference of the West African College of Surgeons, Accra, Ghana, February 4-11, 2006. Code Number: am08006 Abstract Background: The
worldwide pattern of oral and maxillofacial surgical conditions has been rarely
reported despite its significance in head and neck medicine. The Niger Delta
region comprises 9 of the 36 states in the Federal Republic of Nigeria. There
are scanty reports on oral and maxillofacial surgical diseases from the region
despite its 95% contribution to Nigerias oil-revenue. Keywords: oral, maxillofacial, diseases, trauma, tumors, cysts, cancer Résumé Introduction:
La tendance mondiale de la situation de la chirurgie buccale et maxillo a été
rarement signalée en dépit de son importance dans le domaine de médecine de la
tête et du cou. La région du Niger Delta comprend 9 des 36 Etats de la
République Fédérale du Nigéria. Il y peu de rapports sur la maladie de la
chirurgie buccale et maxillo dans la région en dépit de sa 95% contribution au
revenu pétrolier du Nigéria. Mot clés: Buccal, maxillo, les maladies, les traumatismes, les tumeurs, les kystes, le cancer Introduction The scope of oral and maxillofacial surgery includes the management of traumatic conditions of the face, jaws and teeth, cysts, tumors and allied lesions. Other conditions encountered are congenital malformations of the head and neck and infections.1 Despite its importance in health planning, few reports on the worldwide pattern of oral and maxillofacial surgical diseases are available. In Nigeria, there are considerable data on specific surgical conditions such as facial fractures,2-4 tumors5-7 and other maxillofacial conditions.8-10 However, reports of the overall pattern of presentation to oral and maxillofacial surgical treatment centers in Nigeria are quite few. To date, only one1 exists to our knowledge. Due to paucity of specialized oral/maxillofacial surgical manpower, the few reports,11-13 from the Niger delta region of Nigeria were on violence and vehicular causes of trauma. The pattern and distribution of other conditions such as maxillofacial tumors, cyst and allied lesions have not been previously published to our knowledge. In the geopolitics of Nigeria, the Niger Delta region comprises 9 (Akwa Ibom, Abia, Bayelsa, Cross Rivers, Edo, Delta, Imo, Rivers and Ondo States) of Nigerias 36 states. The estimated population of the region is 20 million with an annual growth rate of 2.8%.14 It provides about 95% of the nations oil-revenue. However, in this paper, patients were received only from 5 States (Akwa Ibom, Bayelsa, Cross Rivers, Delta and Rivers States). The aim of this paper is to present the pattern of oral and maxillofacial surgical conditions such as fractures, tumors, cysts and allied lesions seen between 2000 and 2004 at Port Harcourt in the Niger Delta region of Nigeria. Materials and Methods Materials for this study were obtained from a retrospective search of medical records of all patients seen at the Department of Dental Surgery, Military Hospital, Port Harcourt, Nigeria between 2000 and 2004. During the study period, the hospital was the referral center for patients with oral and maxillofacial surgical conditions in Akwa Ibom, Delta, Rivers, Bayelsa and Cross Rivers States of Nigerias Niger Delta region. From the entire cases seen, records of patients with oral and maxillofacial surgical conditions were selected out for analysis of cases notes, operation notes, histopathology results for tumors and cysts and hospital follow-up records. Odontogenic tumors were classified as in Kramer et al.15 Data collected was analyzed using Microsoft Excel. Results During the study period, 86 patients were seen who needed oral and maxillofacial surgical treatment. This represented 20% of total patients seen in the department within the period. Table 1 shows there were 110 oral/maxillofacial surgical conditions with trauma making up 46.4% followed by tumors and allied lesions (39.0%). Fifty-four patients (63%) were males while 32 (37%) were females giving a male to female ratio of 1.7:1. Table 1. Oral and maxillofacial surgical conditions seen in Port Harcourt, Nigeria
TMJ: Tempromandibular joint Ages of patients ranged from 9 to 85 years (mean 31.4 years ±15.4). Out of 86 cases, more (31, 36%) were in the third decade of life than in the fourth decade (20%). In all age groups except the very elderly (above 70 years), there were more males than females. Between age group 20-29years, the male to female ratio was 3:1. Surgical procedures were performed on 63 cases (73%), a few defaulted (16, 19%) while the rest (8%) were referred. Table 2 shows details of 69 primary procedures performed as treatment. The main modality (22, 31.9%) was maxillo-mandibular fixation (MMF) followed by enucleation of cyst/tumor (12, 17.4%) and excision of lesion (15.9%). Twenty-one complications (Table 3) resulted from primary treatment Limitation of mouth opening was the most common complication (24%). Table 4 shows 10 secondary procedures performed to manage these complications. Table 2. Primary oral and maxillofacial surgical procedures performed
Table 3. Post-operative complications after primary surgical procedures in 22 patients
Table 4. Secondary surgical procedures in 10 patients
Discussion Generally, the literature on the pattern of oral and maxillofacial surgical diseases is scanty despite its importance in health planning and the study of disease conditions in the head and neck region. In Nigeria, considerable accounts of specific surgical conditions have been published2,5,7,9,16 with only one publication1 on the overall pattern of presentation at oral/maxillofacial surgical clinics. The Niger Delta region comprises 9 oil-producing states out of Nigerias 36 federating states. These states with an estimated population of 20 million people in 2000 had only one tertiary oral/maxillofacial care center (at Benin City, Edo State) before our center opened in 2000. Available reports on maxillofacial surgical conditions in the region are few11-13 probably due to paucity of oral and maxillofacial care services in most parts of the region. To our knowledge, a report on the overall pattern of hospital presentation for oral and maxillofacial surgical conditions in the Niger delta region of Nigeria has not been previously presented. The previous reports form the Niger Delta,11-13 were on trauma to the maxillofacial region According to Ajike et al,1 78% of the total patients seen at the Aminu Kano University Teaching Hospital, Kano in Northwestern Nigeria had maxillofacial surgical diseases. The Kano center serves at least five states in Nigerias northwestern geopolitical zone. This is considerably higher than our rate (20%) from another hospital at Port Harcourt located in Nigerias South South geopolitical zone. This difference may not necessarily be an indication of differing disease patterns. While the Kano center is a tertiary health care center receiving many referrals, our center in Port Harcourt had a considerable number of general dental cases as it is a secondary care facility. Referral to our center was from dental and general surgical clinics in the five states (Delta, Rivers, Bayelsa, Akwa Ibom and Cross River States) without specialist oral and maxillofacial surgical services within the study period. In Nigeria, management of maxillofacial trauma2-4,16,17 and neoplasms5-7,18 appear to constitute the bulk of maxillofacial surgical practice from reports on these conditions. However, the absence of studies on the overall pattern from various treatment centers in Nigeria make it difficult to determine the relative contributions of each surgical condition to the average workload of the oral and maxillofacial surgeon. In the report from Kano,1 trauma accounts for most (55%) maxillofacial surgical conditions seen with less than a quarter (21%) being cases of tumors and allied lesions. Our results based on a Niger delta population within 5 states also show more cases of trauma (46.4%) than tumors and allied lesions (39.0%). The prevalence of maxillofacial tumors and cysts is difficult to compute from this study as the relatively few cases (n = 86) likely represent a tip of the iceberg. A wider population based study is necessary to ascertain the prevalence of jaw tumors and cysts in the Niger Delta region. During the period of this study (2000-2004), our center in Port Harcourt, Rivers State was the only hospital providing specialized maxillofacial surgical care within the 5 states covered. This shows that the estimated entire population of about 10 million people in these 5 states had scanty oral and maxillofacial surgical care facilities. Hence, there is need for more trained personnel to be recruited coupled with investment in provision of infrastructure to meet the health care needs of the population in this part of Nigeria. Unlike the report from Kano, Nigeria, we could not compare the distribution of conditions to socio-economic status. However, cases of defaults by patients (16%) were reportedly due to inability to pay for treatment and preference for traditional (unorthodox) treatment. This is reflective of the widespread poverty and ignorance on the benefit of modern surgical treatment methods. About 1% of all oral specimens in North America are odontogenic tumors.19,20 In sub-Saharan Africa however, odontogenic tumors account for between 8%-31% of all oral and peri-oral surgical specimens.16,21 Fifteen odontogenic tumors (Table 1) were seen accounting for 26% of all the tumors, cysts and allied lesions seen in this Niger Delta population in Nigeria. This is within the range of other Nigerian studies.6,7,16 In a previous work, Adebayo12 showed that a disproportionate (40%) number of facial fractures in the Niger delta area were due to violence. This is unlike the general pattern from other parts of Nigeria where facial fractures are due to road crashes (56%-83%), falls (11%-24%) and violence (8%-14%). Reasons for the difference in etiological pattern include youth restiveness, influence of alcohol and excessive use of firearms. The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) found that life expectancy of the Nigerian population decreased from 53years in 1999 to 47 years in 2004. This shows that improvement in state revenue mostly from oil exports in Nigeria has not improved the quality of life of her citizens. This is more obvious in the Niger Delta region where five of the six states within the period 2000-2004 lacked adequate skilled oral and maxillofacial care. Figure 1 showed that 36% of our patients were in the third decade while 16% were in the second decade. This may be explained by the youthful nature of Nigerias population as 45% of the population is below 15years of age.14,22 Also, restiveness in the region has been mostly among the young people. It is necessary to urgently tackle the various causes of low life expectancy in Nigeria as shown in the Vision 2010 document and Nigerian Demographic and Health Survey of 2003.14,23 It is suggested that health promotion and poverty alleviation be stepped up throughout Nigeria especially in the Niger Delta region. Treatments for the various surgical conditions encountered in this report are as in other Nigerian studies. Among 69 procedures performed, MMF with either open or closed reduction of fractures was the most common (31.9%). Others were enucleation of tumors/cysts (17.4%), excision (15.9%) and jaw bone resection (8.7%). MMF was the most common surgical procedure in the Kano report.1 Reasons why MMF is favored over open reduction with use of hardware have been discussed in earlier studies on fracture treatment among Nigerians.3,4 Post-operative morbidity is important as it influences patients perception of available surgical care. According to Adekeye and Apapa,22 facial deformity and drooling of saliva are significant complications of jaw and soft tissue resection in the maxillofacial region. In a later report on maxillofacial surgical procedures of different types, Ajike et al,1 found that malocclusion (30%) and facial deformity (26%) were the more important. Our patients reported limited mouth opening (24%), stitch abscess (14%) and recurrence of lesion (14%) as significant complications. Differences in types and rates of complications reflect the stage at which surgical lesions are treated and surgical expertise available. Conclusion This hospital based study represents a tip of the iceberg considering the likely scale of oral and maxillofacial surgical conditions in the Niger Delta region of Nigeria. There is relative paucity of surgical care centers, ignorance of early symptoms of maxillofacial surgical disease and prevalent poverty prevent many patients from reporting with disease conditions. Some who reportedly default also complain of inability to pay. Previous Nigerian studies show that traumatic conditions and tumors constitute the bulk of presentation for specialized oral and maxillofacial surgical care. There is need for greater investment in health and other human services in Nigeria generally to improve life-expectancy and foster socio-economic development. There is also need for more public enlightenment of the populace to create awareness on benefits of early diagnosis of these conditions. References
Copyright 2008 - Annals of African Medicine |
|