|
Australasian Biotechnology (backfiles)
AusBiotech
ISSN: 1036-7128
Vol. 12, Num. 2, 2002, pp. 40-41
|
Australasian Biotechnology, Vol. 12 No. 2,
2002, pp. 40-41
STEM CELL RESEARCH
STEM CELL RESEARCH MUST CONTINUE: AN OVERVIEW
Prepared by AusBiotech Ltd in conjunction with SDA Biotechnology, April 2002
Code Number: au02016
Australia has taken the first step toward a long-term commitment to maintain
its pre-eminent international status in embryonic stem cell research and to
contribute to the future of medical science. This critical research has recently
received support from the Australian Federal Government.
The Australian biotechnology industry strongly affirmed its support for continuing
stem cell research in Australia during a consultative process undertaken by
AusBiotech, which is Australia's peak biotechnology industry organisation. The
industry's call was supported at the April 5 meeting of the Council
of Australian Governments (COAG), at which the issue was discussed, opening
the door for a unified, cooperative national approach that facilitates ongoing
stem cell research within clear and enforceable guidelines.
The Federal Government has designated biotechnology as a priority area for development,
based on a clear recognition of Australia's established world reputation in
this field and its future potential. The Government has introduced a number
of major initiatives that underline its commitment to this policy principle.
It has defined a national biotechnology strategy, set up a national lead body,
Biotechnology Australia, to drive the strategy and advance the nation s biotech
effort and provided substantial funding for biotech projects. Not least among
its funding allocations is the AUD$11 million National Centre for Advanced Cell
Engineering being developed at Monash University, and which was heralded at
the announcement of the Government's funding support as a facility designed
to secure Melbourne's position as an international leader in stem cell research.
The Government has also aggregated the major public research organisations within
the new Department of Education, Science and Training and assigned responsibility
for them to the Minister for Science - a move aimed to provide clearer focus,
impetus and leadership for Australian scientific innovation.
The three eastern states of Victoria, New South Wales and Queensland, along
with South Australia and the Australian Capital Territory, have implemented
biotech strategies and committed significant amounts of capital for research
and commercialisation facilities and projects. Their actions demonstrate firm
support for the national vision of Australia as one of the world's major biotechnology
precincts. The support by the Federal Government in respect of the key area
of stem cell research will significantly enhance the national scientific endeavour.
Australia's Prime Minister undertook in February to consult scientists on the
future of stem cell research prior to the April 5 COAG meeting. The key Australian
stem cell research activities are underpinned by the three main Australian companies
engaged in research in this field, Bresagen Ltd, ES Cell International Pte Ltd
and Stem Cell Sciences Ltd. The trio holds rights to more than 10 of the world's
very limited bank of stem cell lines, variously estimated to total no more than
20 to 60 developed cell lines. As such, the Australian companies are in a rare
and elite position in global terms. Their advice, along with that of the leading
world scientists such as Professor Alan Trounson, Director of the Centre for
Early Human Development at the Monash Institute of Reproduction and Development
was sought, and taken seriously.
There are compelling arguments raised in support of stem cell research by
the Australian industry. These positions include:
- Regenerative medicine, using stem cells, offers
potential for major advances in human health through the treatment and prevention
of debilitating and terminal diseases, including cancers, diabetes, Parkinson's
disease and heart disease.
- Discoveries emerging from stem cell research
will result in the development of new treatments and drugs for global markets,
which will yield substantial direct economic benefits for Australia, attract
international investment and build the nation's pool of scientific skills.
- Australia's scientific base, with its long
tradition of internationally significant discoveries, gives this country a
unique, ready-made advantage and potentially unparalleled opportunities in
this emerging and highly promising frontier of medical science.
- The framework exists for the Government to
commit to a long-term guarantee for the future of stem cell research within
an ethical and regulatory regime that imposes stringent guidelines on the
research and presents a transparent approach to meet any public concerns about
the nature and direction of research in this field.
The result of the COAG Meeting is largely in line with the recommendations
of the House of Representatives Legal and Constitutional Report on Cloning (known
as the Andrews report) of September, 2001. The report resulted from an open
public process that spanned more than two years, and drew on the views put forward
in a very large number of public submissions. The recommendations of the Andrews
report attracted significant industry support. The key points of the report
provided for a ban on reproductive cloning, but allowed research using surplus
human embryo stem cells from IVF programs and adult stem cells. Of particular
importance was the need to derive new cell lines from a wider range of genetic
backgrounds than those currently available in order to reflect the broader population
and enable the development and approval of new drugs into the market.
The nation's peak scientific bodies largely supported continuation of this
research. The Australian Research Council, the Government's key advisory body
on higher education research and distributor of Commonwealth research funding,
made a rare intervention into public policy debate to announce a vigorous campaign
to prevent the Government banning research into human embryo stem cells. Liberal
approaches to stem cell research have also been recommended by the Australian
Academy of Science and the Federation of Australian Scientific Technological
Societies. The view of the industry and research sector was also borne out by
public opinion. Research by Roy Morgan International in July, 2001, found 72%
of Australians support stem cell research and 69% support the use of spare IVF
embryos in scientific research. These findings have been confirmed by the results
of a survey conducted late in 2001 by the Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic
and Social Research.
The United States currently stands virtually alone in refusing to fund research
for other than the small number of stem cell lines already in existence. The
negative response to the US position was evident at the February BIO CEO and
Investors' Conference in New York, at which a third of the conference agenda
was devoted to stem cells. Countries in Asia, notably Singapore, are supporting
new stem cell research, and late in February Britain legislated to allow strictly
licensed work to generate human embryonic stem cells and therapeutic cloning.
Venture capital is shifting its focus towards those jurisdictions, such as the
UK, that offer a stable, long-term policy and regulatory environment in which
biotech companies can be certain of seeing their projects through.
Last November, the European Parliament overwhelmingly rejected a move to ban
human cloning. The European Union, in fact, has signalled a higher priority
for stem cell research. Its Commissioner for Research, Philippe Busquin, said
in a statement issued September 16, 2001: "Stem cell research is among the proposed
research priorities under the next framework program for research 2003 to 2006.
Stem cell-based therapies hold great potential for curing diseases and injuries.
I believe we can gain a lot from a stronger exchange of information and coordination
across Europe of stem cell research."
Life science has as its foundation the advancement of human health and lifestyle
enjoyment and Australia now has the ability to participate in this advancement
though its commanding global position in stem cell research.
Fortunately, through the foresight of the Australian political leaders, Australia
is not locked out of any opportunities for collaborative research on a global
scale, and out of the major international capital markets. The COAG decisions
are a step in the right direction with additional discussion still required
in the areas of 'therapeutic cloning' and appropriate regulatory regimes.
Australia can now continue its long tradition of scientific leadership and
world-class scientific discovery, and to strive towards the dream for Australia's
future as a 'smart nation'.
Copyright 2002 - AusBiotech
|