search
for
 About Bioline  All Journals  Testimonials  Membership  News


African Crop Science Journal
African Crop Science Society
ISSN: 1021-9730 EISSN: 2072-6589
Vol. 7, Num. 3, 1999, pp. 244-298
POTATO.RF (Word4)

African Crop Science Journal September 1999 Vol. 7 No. 3 pp. 223- 298

Special Issue: Monograph on Geographic shifts in highland cooking banana (Musa, group AAA-EA) production in Uganda

Code Number: CS99017

Editors: C.S. Gold, E.B. Karamura, A. Kiggundu, F. Bagamba and A.M.K. Abera

Editorial Secretariat, Faculty of Agriculture and Forestry, Makerere University, Uganda

PART 3: SITE SUMMARIES

A. Central Uganda. Highland cooking and beer bananas have been grown in Uganda from antiquity from the north-central shore of Lake Victoria to the west bank of the Nile, in an area encompassed by Iganga, Kamuli, Jinja, Mukono, Luwero and Mpigi districts. This central region is situated between 1000 and 1300 m.a.s.l. Near the lake, the land is largely defined by rolling hills, although it becomes progressively flat as one moves north. The vegetation includes tall grasslands with patches of tropical forest, scrub and, in the north, short grasslands and savannah. The soils are ferralitic with fertile clays.

Near the lake, rainfall of 1500-2000 mm is optimal for growing banana, while lower rainfall in the north (500-1500 mm) makes banana production more difficult.

The area has been densely populated and is characterised by small farm agriculture and intensive production. Until the 1970s, banana was the dominant staple (often grown in banana/coffee systems) and Mukono and Mpigi districts jointly comprised the most important banana producing area in the country. Market access is considerably better for the southern sites as they are closer to the major commercial centres of Kampala and Jinja.

Banana production deterioration was first reported in the 1940s (Tothill, 1940) with accelerated decline beginning in the 1960s and 1970s. To study banana production decline in the central region, 9 sites were selected in Iganga, Kamuli, Mukono and Luwero districts, using a stratified grid map (Jagtap, 1993).

Figure 2. Time line demonstrating production leveles of cooking bananas in Busembatya.

SITE 1: BUSEMBATYA (IGANGA DISTRICT)

Location: 25 km N of Iganga

Village size: 850 households

Topography: Flat

Access: Well maintained murram roads to Iganga

Ethnic groups: Basoga with Bagwere, Banyole and Badama minorities

Land tenure: Freehold

Land pressure: High; most land under continuous cultivation

Average Farm size: 0.8 ha

Dominant farming systems: Monoculture, maize and finger millet

Banana production: Very low, dominated by exotic beer types

Banana dynamics. Cooking banana traditional staple food; replacement by drought tolerant crops: cassava, maize and millet. Later disappearance of cassava due to mosaic. Staples (i.e. maize, millet, groundnut) became cash crops following collapse of the cotton industry and unstable coffee markets.

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (30 May 1995) in Busembatya

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

 

 

 

 

 

1

Cassava

13

1

Maize

21

2

Maize

11

2

Finger millet

17

3

Finger millet

10

3

Sweet potato

11

4

Groundnut

10

3

Groundnut

11

5

Yam

10

5

Sorghum

8

6

Sweet potato

9

6

Pumpkin

8

7

Pumpkin

8

7

Sesame

5

8

Peas

7

7

Rice

5

9

Sesame

6

9

Beans

4

9

Banana (matooke)

6

10

Banana (matooke)

2

11

Sorghum

3

11

Pineapple

2

12

Bambara nut

2

11

Cassava

2

13

Beans

2

11

Soybean

2

14

Rice

2

11

Peas

2

15

Pineapple

1

15

Yam

1

15

Soybean

0

15

Bambara nut

1

B. Cash crops

 

 

 

 

 

1

Cotton

27

1

Maize

32

2

Coffee

17

2

Finger millet

18

3

Groundnut

16

3

Groundnut

16

4

Maize

12

4

Banana (beer)

9

5

Finger millet

10

5

Sorghum

7

6

Sorghum

6

6

Coffee

7

7

Sesame

5

7

Rice

6

8

Banana (matooke)

4

8

Sesame

4

9

Banana (beer)

3

 

Banana (matooke)

0

 

Rice

0

 

Cotton

0

Beer bananas = Kisubi (AB)

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Busembatya in 1990s

Maintained = 9

Disappearing = 2

Disappeared = 5

Bikono

Malira omutono

Kiguti*

Katetema

Sagasaga

Lusi*

Malira omomyufu

 

Luvuta*

Malira omunene

 

Nmadhi*

Maminwe

 

Wete*

Mbululu

 

 

Muture

 

 

Nsugunu

 

 

Ntinti

 

 

 

Notes: Five AAA-EA brewing clones replaced by Kisubi (AB) which is grown in pure stands, more tolerant of pests, infertile soils, required less management, produced higher quality juice

TABLE 3. Banana yields and stand characteristics on selected study farms in Busembatya

Farm

Hectares

Major

Production

Stand

Bunch

 

1970s

1990s

 

 

 

 

1

0.1

0.1

None

Decline

10

4-5

2

1.6

0.4

Coffee

Decline

54

6-8

3

4.5

1.6

None

Decline

70

4-5

4

2.0

0.3

None

Decline

60

6-8

5

4.0

0.6

None

Decline

5

3-4

6

3.2

0.8

None

Decline

60

6-8

Village average yield: 5-7 kg

Table 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Busembatya

Rank

Cause

1

Increased pest pressure

2

Degraded soils (fertility)

3

Unfavourable climatic changes (drought)

4

Changes in management

5

Shifted attention to other crops

1 = most important

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Busembatya

Farm

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

 

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

%

1

3

5

4

27

0.5

5.6

12.4

28

2

7

11

9

26

1.3

7.4

11

18

3

17

8

12

19

0.5

7.8

8.3

38

4

6

8

7

4

0

5.1

8.7

18

5

9

8

9

3

0.4

2.4

9.6

22

6

1

4

2

12

0.2

12.3

9.3

13

Site mean

8

8

8

15

0.5

6.5

 

 

Key
XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis
HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: Banana weevil first became a serious pest in early 1960s. Moles and black ant (Odontomachus trogolodytes) (= kaasa) also considered serious pests. Moles more important on other crops. Toppling attributed to ants. Nematodes not recognised

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Busembatya

1950s to 1970s

1990s

Soil conservation: grass bands and trenches to prevent

Soil conservation: not practised erosion

Soil amendments: external inputs(e.g. organic manure or mulch) needed but too expensive due to high cost of transport

Soil amendments: external inputs(manure,fertilizer) unnecessary

Mulching: with thick banana trash and split pseudostem

Mulching: with sparse banana trash

Weeds: reduced by heavy mulching and/or by hand

Weeds: weeding with hand hoe

Weevil control: uprooting, chopping of residues; covering old corms with soil

Weevil control: destruction of residues rarely done due to lack of labour

Pesticides: not required

Pesticides: used by richer farmers only against weevils

Agroforestry: trees (especially Ficus spp.), planted for shading

Agroforestry: planting of trees seen as absolute requisite to provide shade for future banana production

Notes: Management of banana stands was the responsibility of both men and women. Initial declines in banana management were attributed to a narrowing labour base such that labour intensive methods could no longer be employed. Further declines reflected dissatisfaction with the poorer crop performance

Soils

Foliar analysis: N and Mg deficient; P, K and Ca adequate

Notes: Soil fertility decline believed caused by land pressure and resulting changes in agronomic practices. Traditionally, farmers practised shifting cultivation with 25% of the land laying in fallow for 2 or more years. Now, continuous cropping with short or no fallow periods. Annual crops continued to perform relatively well with only moderate yield reductions

SITE 2: NAMUGONGO (KAMULI DISTRICT)

Location: 10 km W of Kaliro; 40 km N of Iganga

Village size: 600 households; sparsely populated

Topography: Flat

Access: Distant from markets; connected to Iganga and Luwero by fair condition murram roads.

Ethnic groups: Basoga with Iteso minority

Land tenure: Freehold

Land pressure: Light; extensive bush fallow

Farm size: 3.5 ha

Dominant farming systems: Mixed annual crops

Banana production: Very low, in small plots or kitchen gardens

Banana dynamics: Cooking banana was traditional staple, but already minor crop by 1970s. First replaced by millet, sweet potato and cassava. Maize and rice later gained favour. Cassava disappeared due to African Cassava Mosaic Disease. Maize and rice became cash crops following collapse of the cotton industry and unstable coffee markets.

Figure 3. Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking bananas in Namugongo

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (26 May 1995) in Namugongo

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

 

 

 

 

 

1

Finger millet

21

1

Maize

18

2

Sweet potato

16

2

Finger millet

16

3

Groundnut

15

3

Rice

15

4

Cassava

11

4

Sweet potato

12

5

Pumpkin

9

5

Groundnuts

10

6

Banana (matooke)

8

6

Soybean

9

7

Maize

5

7

Cassava

5

8

Peas

3

8

Sorghum

4

8

Beans

3

9

Pumpkin

3

10

Sesame

2

10

Beans

2

10

Soybean

2

11

Peas

2

12

Yam

2

11

Banana (matooke)

2

13

Sorghum

1

13

Yams

1

13

Bambara nut

1

13

Sesame

1

15

Rice

1

15

Bambara nut

0

B. Cash crop

 

 

 

 

 

1

Cotton

34

1

Maize

25

2

Finger millet

22

2

Rice

17

3

Coffee

19

3

Finger millet

14

4

Groundnut

15

4

Groundnut

13

5

Banana (matooke)

5

5

Banana (beer)

9

6

Sesame

3

6

Sugar cane

5

6

Maize

3

6

Cotton

5

 

Sorghum

0

8

Soybean

4

 

Sugar cane

0

9

Sorghum

3

 

Cassava

0

10

Coffee

2

 

Peas

0

11

Beans

2

 

Rice

0

12

Sesame

1

 

Banana (beer)

0

13

Peas

1

 

Beans

0

 

Banana (matooke)

0

 

Soybean

0

 

Cassava

0

Beer bananas = Kisubi (AB)

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Namugongo in the 1990s

Maintained = 8

Disappearing = 7

Disappeared = 0

Katetema

Bikowekowe

None

Kisugunu

Malira omunene

 

Malira nalwera

Malira omutono

 

Malira

Nakasabira

 

Omumyufu

Nalugiri

 

Mbululu

Nfuuka

 

Namaligida

Sagasaga

 

Nkago

 

 

Ntuju*

 

 

Notes: Moderate amounts of Kisubi (AB) and some Kayinja (ABB) were grown for local beverage production, while Ndiizi was produced for home consumption. These are replacing cooking banana due to greater tolerance of pests, drought and low soil fertility, and their low management demands

Table 3. Banana yields and stand characteristics on selected study farms in Namugongo

Farm

Hectares

Major intercrop

Production trend

Stand age

Bunch weight (kg)

 

1970s

1990s

 

 

 

 

1

1.2

0.2

None

Decline

55

6-7

2

0.8

0.1

None

Decline

30

4-5

3

0.8

0.1

None

Decline

10

4-5

4

0.8

0.1

None

Decline

21

5-6

5

0.6

0.1

None

Decline

 

 

6

1.0

0.1

None

Decline

 

 

Village average yield: 4-6 kg

Notes: Transect drives revealed most banana stands contained < 50 mats compared to stands of > 0.8 ha in the 1950s and 1960s. Stand life reduced from decades to < 5 years

TABLE 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Namugongo

Rank

Cause

1.

Increased pest pressure

2.

Unfavourable climatic changes (drought)

3.

Changes in management

4.

Land pressure

5.

Degraded soils (fertility)

6.

Shifted attention to other crops

7.

Reduced labour availability

1 = most important

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Namugongo

Farm

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

 

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

%Dead

1

21

20

20

6

0

2.1

11.0

13

2

23

25

24

27

1.9

5.6

9.8

18

3

8

13

11

15

0.2

2.8

15.2

33

4

3

7

5

24

6.6

6.6

9.0

18

5

15

14

14

11

0.1

2.4

9.2

18

6

5

10

7

29

0.2

4.9

13.1

15

Site mean

13

15

14

19

1.6

4.1

11.3

20

Key
XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis
HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: Banana weevil first became a problem in the 1970s. Moles and black ant (Odontomachus trogolodytes) (= kaasa) also considered serious pests. Nematodes not recognised

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Namugongo

1950s to 1970s

1990s

Soil conservation: grass bands and trenches to control erosion

Soil conservation: not practised

Soil amendments: application of farm yard manure, as available

Soil amendments: household refuse manure seldom applied due to high cost of transport and labour

Mulching: thick mulch of banana leaves, split stems; other crop residues

Mulching: light banana trash mulching.

De-leafing: systematic

De-leafing: infrequent and not regarded as a priority.

Desuckering: systematic

Desuckering: infrequent (only for planting material)

Weeds: controlled by mulching

Weeds: weeding twice per year by hand hoe.

Weevil control: corms cut at ground level and covered with soil. Ash used to control weevils

Weevil control: infrequent; on most farms corms left standing and pseudostems not split due to labour demand. Some farmers applied ash.

Pesticides: not used.

Pesticides: not used.

Notes: Men and women were previously jointly responsible for managing cooking banana. Now, women are responsible for cooking banana, while men manage cash crops, including beer banana, and work off-farm. Occasional hired labour allocated to field preparation and weeding of annual cash and staple crops which are more productive, quicker maturing and more profitable. Priority was given to: 1) maize; 2) soybean; 3) groundnut; 4) sweet potato. Regional by-laws originally mandated soil conservation (e.g. trenches), de-suckering, mulching, sanitation

Soils

Foliar analyses: Mg low; adequate levels of N, P, K and Ca

Notes: Until 1980s, virgin land was present and fallow periods of 3-5 years was common. Soil management (i.e., manure, mulches) has been largely discontinued, leading to soil nutrient decline. Banana now restricted to best soils. Farmers also planted beans, sweet potato and maize on relatively fertile soils, and finger millet, cassava, sorghum and soybeans on poorer soils

SITE 3: BULYANGADA (IGANGA DISTRICT)

Location: 30 km S of Iganga along the shore of Lake Victoria

Village size: N/A

Topography: Flat

Access: Poorly maintained murram roads, gutted during the rainy season, connected to tarmac road between Iganga and Tororo.

Ethnic groups: Basoga with Banyankole, Japadola, Bagwere and Bagisu minorities

Land tenure: Customary and freehold

Land pressure: High; intensive cultivation on most land.

Farm size: 1 ha

Dominant farming systems: Mixed annual crops, coffee, banana

Banana production: Low to moderate; dominated by exotic beer and dessert clones.

Banana dynamics: Banana is traditional staple. Yield decline began in mid 1970s. Yields stable since mid-1980s. Largely replaced by cassava and maize. Murram road to Iganga constructed in 1970s allowed banana to be important cash crop. However, road deteriorated reducing trader visits. Kisubi (AB) and Kayinja (ABB), introduced in 1980s, replaced cooking banana and became important cash crops. Cotton market collapsed but coffee remained leading cash crop despite low, fluctuating prices.

Figure 4: Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking banana in Bulyangada

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (31 May 1995) in Bulyangada

1970s

1990

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

 

A. Food crops

1

Banana (matooke)

18

1

Cassava

18

1

Finger millet

18

2

Maize

15

3

Groundnut

14

3

Finger millet

13

4

Sweet potato

9

4

Sweet potato

11

5

Beans

8

5

Banana (matooke)

8

6

Maize

7

6

Beans

8

7

Yam

7

7

Rice

7

8

Cassava

6

8

Soybean

6

9

Pumpkin

3

8

Groundnut

6

10

Peas

3

10

Sesame

5

11

Sesame

3

11

Peas

1

12

Soybean

2

12

Pumpkin

1

13

Bambara nut

1

13

Yam

1

 

Rice

0

 

Bambara nut

0

B. Cash crops

1

Cotton

15

1

Coffee

19

2

Banana (matooke)

14

2

Cassava

16

3

Coffee

13

3

Banana (beer)

12

4

Sugar cane

11

4

Maize

10

5

Groundnut

10

5

Beans

10

5

Maize

10

6

Finger millet

9

7

Finger millet

8

7

Tomato

7

7

Beans

8

8

Soybean

5

9

Sesame

7

9

Rice

4

10

Cocoa

2

10

Groundnut

2

11

Rice

1

11

Sesame

1

12

Soybean

1

11

Banana (matooke)

1

 

Cassava

0

 

Cotton

0

 

Banana (beer)

0

 

Cocoa

0

 

Tomato

0

 

Sugar cane

0

Beer bananas = Kisubi (AB), Kayinja (ABB)

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Bulyangada in 1990s

Maintained = 9

Disappearing = 4

Disappeared = 2

Katetema

Bikowekowe

Malira nalwera

Malira omunene

Ensugunu

Mukaire alikisa

Malira omutono

Entinti

 

Mbululu

Nante

 

Mutule

 

 

Namaligida

 

 

Naminwe

 

 

Nfuuka

 

 

Siira

 

 

 

Notes: Kayinja (ABB) and Kisubi (AB) important. Kidozi (AB) and Namadi (AB) important dessert bananas, while Niwete (AB), once important, had disappeared

TABLE 3. Banana stand characteristics on selected study farms in Bulyangada

Farm

Hectares

Major intercrop

Production trend

Stand age

Bunch weight (kg)

1970s

1990s

1

0.5

0.2

Cassava

Decline

6

3-5

2

1.5

0.3

Cassava

Decline

3

2-5

3

1.5

0.3

Coffee

Decline

6

6-8

4

1.5

1.0

None

Decline

27

5-7

5

2.0

0.3

Cassava

Decline

10

5-7

6

3.0

2.0

None

Decline

8

6-8

Village average yield: 4-7 kg

Table 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Bulyangada

Rank

Cause

1

Increased pest pressure

2

Shifted attention to other crops

3

Change in management

4

Unfavorable climatic changes (drought)

5

Degraded soils (fertility)

6

Land pressure

7

Demographic factors (ethnic shifts)

1 = most important

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Bulyangada

Farm

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

 

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

% dead

1

5

9

7

21

0.3

4.8

8.1

0

2

25

16

20

12

0.1

11.5

9.3

22

3

24

14

19

6

2.0

16.3

11.3

25

4

4

9

7

7

1.8

12.0

9.7

19

5

8

8

8

7

1.9

6.5

8.8

24

6

5

10

7

13

0.2

13.5

13.0

28

Site mean

12

11

11

11

1.1

11.0

10.1

21

Key

XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis
HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: Important pests are banana weevil, black ant (Ondontomachus troglodytes) and termites. All present in 1960s but at low, manageable levels. Weevil problems worse on degraded soils and during droughts. Increasing importance of Kayinja (ABB) and Kisubi (AB), in part, a response to weevil problems. Some farmers do not mulch due to rapid removal by termites

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Bulyangada

1950s - 1970s

1990s

Soil conservation: trenches made and grass bands: planted to prevent erosion none

Soil conserva tion

Soil amendments: not required because of adequate fertility

Soil amendments: necessary but limited due to costs; Household refuse applied in the backyard.

Mulching: most plantations mulched with banana leaves and elephant grass

Mulching: only done in large stands; Mulching: only done in large stands where banana trash abundant.

De-leafing: frequent with materials used for mulching

De-leafing: done on an irregular basis.

Weeds: controlled by mulches and hand weeding

Weeds: poor-fair management, sporadic with late weeding common.

De-suckering: done routinely

De-suckering: sporadic with high plant density (5-10/mat).

Weevil control: corms uprooted or cut at base and covered with soil; thorough splitting of pseudostems

Weevil control: uncommon with residues when labour is available.

Notes: Management levels were high during 1940s and 1950s when banana was high yielding, labour plentiful and migrant labourers often permanently employed. Since 1970s, banana producers have faced worsening land pressure, increasing production constraints (i.e., pest pressure, soil nutrient imbalances), less available and more costly labour. Land pressure led to more inter-cropping with beans, coffee, cassava, maize, finger millet. As yields declined, farmers began to shift their attention (land, labour, capital) to other crops including cassava, maize, beer bananas

Soils

Foliar analyses: Mg deficiencies limited banana growth; N and P low; K and Ca adequate

Notes: With existing land pressure, fallowing uncommon. Costs of mulching and manuring prohibitive. Soil exhaustion, attributed to continuous cropping without restoring soil nutrients, was reflected in diminished yields for all crops. Banana and groundnut planted on best soils; maize and cassava on less fertile soils

SITE 4: NAMINAGE (KAMULI DISTRICT)

Location: 10 km S of Kamuli

Village size: 741 households

Topography: Flat

Access: Well maintained murram road to Kamuli, from which tarmac road extends to Jinja and Kampala.

Ethnic groups: Basoga

Land tenure: Predominantly freehold; some farmers rented land

Land pressure: High; intensive cultivation on most land.

Average farm size: 1.6 ha; down from 8 ha in 1970s

Dominant farming systems: Mixed annual crops, coffee, banana

Banana production: Sparse and limited to kitchen gardens

Other activities: Some people involved in livestock/poultry production, brick making, and off-farm employment.

Banana dynamics: Cooking banana traditional staple. Yield decline began in 1960s causing shift to maize and beans. Modest banana sales disappeared by 1980s. Kisubi (AB), introduced in the 1980s, of moderate importance. Cassava wiped out by Cassava Mosaic Disease in early 1990s. Cotton, maize, coffee and groundnut were leading cash crops, with maize and beans gaining importance with collapse of cotton.

Figure 5. Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking banana in Naminga.

TABLE 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (24 May 1995) in Naminage

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Banana (matooke)

20

1

Maize

23

2

Irish potato

14

2

Irish potato

17

3

Maize

10

3

Beans

13

4

Groundnut

9

4

Groundnut

12

5

Beans

8

5

Cassava

11

6

Yam

6

6

Soybean

9

7

Cassava

5

7

Banana (matooke)

4

7

Peas

5

8

Rice

3

7

Sesame

5

9

Pumpkin

3

10

Bambara nut

5

10

Sesame

2

11

Pumpkin

4

11

Peas

2

11

Soybean

4

12

Finger millet

1

13

Finger millet

3

13

Sorghum

1

14

Sorghum

1

13

Yam

1

 

Rice

0

 

Bambara nut

0

B. Cash crops

1

Cotton

21

1

Maize

21

2

Maize

18

2

Beans

14

3

Coffee

16

3

Coffee

11

4

Groundnut

15

4

Groundnut

11

5

Sugar cane

12

5

Soybean

10

6

Beans

9

5

Sugar cane

10

7

Banana (matooke)

8

7

Banana (beer)

10

 

Cassava

0

8

Rice

7

 

Soybean

0

9

Cassava

4

 

Rice

0

9

Banana (matooke)

1

 

Banana (beer)

0

10

Cotton

1

Beer bananas = Kisubi

TABLE 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Naminage in 1990s

Maintained = 10

Disappearing = 5

Disappeared = 0

Kasese

Bukumpu

None

Katetema

Nakitembe

 

Kidhozi

Namayovu

 

Malira omunene

Ntinti

 

Malira omutono

Sagasaga

 

Mbululu

 

 

Mbwazirume

 

 

Mukaire alikisa

 

 

Mutule

 

 

Ntundu*

 

 

* Beer clone

Notes: Kisubi (AB) widely grown

Table 3. Banana stand characteristics on selected study farms in Naminage

Farm

Hectares

Major intercrop

Production trend

Stand age

Plant girth

Bunch weight (kg)

 

1970s

1990s

 

 

 

 

 

1

2.5

0.3

None

Decline

10

59

5-7

2

1.5

0.5

None

Decline

20

49

5-8

3

1

0.3

None

Decline

8

62

10-12

4

3

0.3

Cassava

Decline

80

52

6-8

5

0.5

0.5

None

Decline

4

64

8-10

6

2

1

None

Decline

5

54

5-7

Village average yield: 5-8 kg

Notes: Banana production scarce; mostly kitchen gardens with few stands > 0.2 ha, compared to 1960s when stands > 2 ha common. Although some older stands present, average stand longevity has declined from > 20 years to 3-6 years

Table 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Naminage

Rank

Cause

1

Increased pest pressure

2

Unfavourable climatic changes (drought)

3

Degraded soils (fertility)

4

Land pressure

5

Shifted attention to other crops

6

Lack of market

7

Change in management

1 = most important

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Naminage

 

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

Farm

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

% Dead

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1

11

9

10

6

0.7

5.7

8.4

21

2

3

3

3

22

0.3

7.8

9

21

3

7

13

10

6

6.4

10.5

8

13

4

9

14

11

6

0

7.8

10.1

23

5

14

7

11

4

0

13.4

8.4

18

6

7

6

7

23

3.3

10.9

8.8

31

Site mean

8

10

9

11

1.6

9.3

8.8

22

Key

XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis
HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: Farmers considered banana weevil as the leading cause of banana decline. Black ant (Ondontomachus troglodytes) and moles also important

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Naminage

1950s - 1970s

1990s

Soil conservation: fallowing and mulching done to improve soil

Soil conservation: fallowing uncommon due to population pressure

Soil amendments: not essential because of adequate soil fertility

Soil amendments: necessary but limited due to costs. Household refuse applied in the backyard

Mulching: plantations well mulched with banana trash and pseudostems

Mulching: light mulches of scattered banana trash

De-leafing: systematic with materials used for mulching

De-leafing: uncommon

Weeds: controlled by mulches and hand weeding

Weeds: infrequent weeding by hand hoe

De-leafing: done routinely

De-leafing: sporadic

De-suckering: done routinely

De-suckering: sporadic

Weevil control: most farmers uprooted corms and split pseudostems.

Weevil control: uprooting corms and splitting pseudostems not done due to lack of labour

Notes: Until 1970s, banana was well managed with a high standard of agronomic practices (de-suckering, mulching, sanitation, weevil trapping, weeding) enforced by regional laws. Farmers often exchanged labour within the community of employed migrant labour. Reduced management reflected loss of interest in banana in face of declining productivity, rather than being leading cause of decline. Participation in a cash sconomy had become more important than in the past. As a result, profitability became an important concern. As banana yields declined, priority was shifted to annual crops which provided quicker and more secure returns.

Soils:

Foliar analysis: Some farms were deficient in N and Mg, others lacked K anad Mg.

Notes: Soil exhaustion brought on by intensive cultivation, while only 25% could fallow (1-3 years). Banana grown on the best soils although yields were poor. Maize, beans, groundnut, soybean and sweet potatoe performed well

SITE 5: KABANDA (MUKONO DISTRICT)

Location: 15 km SE of Lugazi and 20 km E of Lake Victoria; bordered by Mabira Forest

Village size: 120 households in a 3 km2 area

Topography: Gently sloping terrain; shrubby grasslands

Access: Well maintained murram road to Lugazi which connects to Kampala-Jinja tarmac road

Ethnic groups: Baganda predominant, with Basoga, Banyarwanda, Badama, Banyankole, Banyoro, Banubi and Batoro present. The Baganda and Basoga were traditional banana growers while the others preferred cassava, sweet potatoes or maize.

Land tenure: Freehold

Land pressure: High; agricultural intensity moderate.

Average farm size: < 0.8 ha

Dominant farming systems: Mixed annual crops, coffee, banana

Banana production: Light to moderate

Other activities: Majority of people depended more on off-farm employment than agriculture. Many of the men owned businesses in Lugazi or Mukono, as artisans or traders, worked on the sugarcane estate in Lugazi, or fished in Lake Victoria.

Banana dynamics: Banana was traditional staple. Declines were already in evidence in 1970s, which encouraged encroachment in the Mabira Forest where virgin soils supported excellent production. Squatters were evicted from forest in mid 1980s. By 1990s, banana largely replaced by cassava, beans and sweet potatoes. Cooking banana was of minor importance as a cash crop (sold in Lugazi). Kayinja (ABB), introduced in the 1980s, became important cash crop; bunches sold to local beer brewers and distillers of local gin (waragi).

Figure 6: Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking banana in Kubanda

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (10 May 1995) in Kabanda

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Banana (Matooke)

21

1

Cassava

23

2

Ground nuts

19

2

Beans

21

3

Yams

17

3

Sweet potato

20

4

Cassava

9

4

Vegetables

17

5

Sweet potato

9

5

Maize

9

6

Maize

7

6

Banana (Matooke)

4

7

Vegetables

5

7

Yams

2

8

Beans

5

8

Ground nuts

1

9

Pineapple

3

9

Finger millet

1

9

Pumpkin

3

9

Pumpkin

1

11

Finger millet

2

 

Pineapple

0

12

Irish potato

1

 

Irish potato

0

B. Cash crops

1

Coffee

66

1

Coffee

24

2

Cotton

21

2

Banana (beer)

14

3

Sugar cane

5

3

Vegetables

13

4

Beans

3

4

Beans

13

4

Banana (matooke)

3

5

Cassava

13

4

Cocoa

3

6

Fruit

7

 

Fruit

0

7

Banana (matooke)

5

 

Vegetables

0

7

Sugar cane

5

 

Yams

0

9

Yams

1

 

Cassava

0

9

Vanilla

1

 

Bogoya

0

11

Bogoya

1

 

Banana (beer)

0

12

Cocoa

1

 

Vanilla

0

Cotton

0

 

Beer bananas = Kayinja (ABB)

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Kabanda in 1990s

Maintained = 4

Disappearing = 1

Disappeared = 0

Muvubo

Musakala

None

Nakabululu

 

 

Nakitembe

 

 

Nfuuka

 

 

Notes: Kayinja (ABB) common; Bogoya (= Gros Michel AAA) in small amounts

Table 3. Banana stand characteristics on selected study farms in Kabanda

Farm

Hectares

Major intercrop

Production trend

Stand age

Bunch weight (kg)

 

1970s

1990s

 

 

 

 

1

-

1.5

Beans

Decline

2

7-10

2

-

0.8

None

Decline

6

5-7

3

-

0.5

Coffee

Decline

4

6-8

4

-

0.8

Coffee

Decline

15

7-9

5

-

1.0

None

Decline

8

7-12

6

-

1.0

None

Decline

9

7-12

Village average yield: 8-10 kg

Notes: Farmers were unclear on hectares in 1970s. The 6 farms visited had all been recently bought or inherited so initial hectares could not be established

Table 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Kabanda

Rank

Cause

1

Change in management

2

Degraded soils (erosion)

3

Increased pest pressure

4

Shifted attention to other crops

5

Reduced labour availability

6

Land pressure

7

Demographic factors (ethnic shifts)

8

Competing activities

9

Lack of clean planting material

1 = most important

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Kabanda

Farm

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

 

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

% Dead

1

3

6

5

7

0.6

4.3

10.4

11

2

10

7

9

8

0.4

3.2

8.7

8

3

7

8

8

7

1.1

2.9

10.1

12

4

8

13

10

8

0.9

4.6

13.6

7

5

18

13

16

11

0.0

4.8

11.5

16

6

13

16

15

14

0.7

5.0

9.3

20

Site mean

10

11

10

9

0.6

4.3

10.6

13

Key

XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis
HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: Banana weevil and black ant (Ondontomachus troglodytes) important. Increasing weevil pressure attributed to reduced management

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Kabanda

1950's - 1960s

1990's

Soil management: long fallows

Soil management: nutrient loss from inter-cropping cited as a major source of decline

Soil conservation: trenches common for erosion control

Soil conservation: erosion controls abandoned due to lack of labour; erosion has increased

Mulching: common with banana trash and split pseudostems

Mulching: spreading banana leaves - but sparser quantity due to inter-cropping; destruction of mulch by termites.

Weeds: controlled by mulching and hand weeding

Weeds: weeding by hand hoe said to be a major cause of decline.

Weevil control: uprooting corms and splitting of pseudostems common

Weevil control: residues not treated due to lack of labour.

Pesticides: not used.

Pesticides: not used.

Notes: Most farmers agreed that reduced management was the leading cause of banana production decline. Reduced management attention resulted from diminishing labour base, loss of interest, lost knowledge from preceding generations, land pressure, and competing off-farm activities. Labour was most limiting resource (reduced labour base and inability to compete with nearby sugar industry), followed by capital and land. In the past, women tended food crops while men managed cash crops. Men became more involved in off-farm employment, leaving women to work both. As banana declined, younger generations lost interest and refused to assume labour intensive methods

Soils

Foliar analysis: N was important limiting factor, while Mg sometimes low. Other nutrients appeared adequate

Notes: Both soil erosion and exhaustion reported. Land pressure resulted in reduction/elimination of fallowing, greater frequency of inter-cropping with annual crops or coffee. Cooking banana planted on most fertile soils; brewing bananas, sweet potatoes and cassava on more infertile soils

SITE 6: BUSAGAZI (MUKONO DISTRICT)

Location: 10 km E from Kayunga and 60 km NNE from Mukono

Village size: 1500 households

Topography: Rolling hills

Access: Tarmac road to Mukono

Ethnic groups: Baganda predominant, with Basoga, Bagwere and Luo also present. Baganda were traditional banana cultivators, while other groups primarily grew annual crops (e.g. maize, cassava, sweet potatoes).

Land tenure: Mailo, but farmers can decide what they wish to do with land

Land pressure: High, with intensive cultivation

Average farm size: 0.8-1.2 ha

Dominant farming systems: Mixed annual crops, coffee, banana

Banana production: Moderate

Banana dynamics: Cooking banana traditional staple. Following decline, beginning in 1970s, replaced by cassava and beans. Until 1960s, cooking banana grown entirely for home consumption. In 1960s and 1970s, banana (moved by lorries to Kampala) was equal in importance to coffee. With decline of banana, in many instances, coffee has been planted in place of banana or banana has become the second crop in mixtures with coffee or pineapple. Kayinja (ABB) also rose in importance.

Figure 7: Time line demonstration of production levels of cooking bananas in Busagazi

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (5 June 1995) in Busagazi

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Banana (matooke)

30

1

Cassava

28

2

Maize

19

2

Beans

26

3

Beans

14

3

Maize

13

4

Sweet potato

12

4

Sweet potato

12

5

Groundnut

7

5

Groundnut

5

6

Cassava

7

6

Banana (matooke)

4

7

Yam

5

7

Finger millet

3

8

Soybean

4

7

Yam

3

9

Finger millet

1

9

Sorghum

3

10

Sorghum

1

10

Soybean

2

B. Cash crops

1

Coffee

25

1

Coffee

37

2

Banana (matooke)

24

2

Beans

15

3

Maize

9

3

Banana (beer)

8

4

Sorghum

9

4

Maize

6

5

Tomato

6

5

Cassava

5

6

Greens

5

5

Pineapple

5

7

Beans

4

7

Pawpaw

3

8

Sugar cane

3

8

Passion fruit

3

8

Banana (beer)

3

9

Banana (matooke)

3

8

Ndiizi

3

9

Mango

3

11

Cassava

3

11

Greens

2

12

Cabbage

2

11

Ndiizi

2

13

Mango

2

11

Sorghum

2

 

Pineapple

0

14

Sugar cane

1

 

Passion fruit

0

14

Tomato

1

 

Pawpaw

0

14

Cabbage

1

Beer bananas - Kayinja (ABB)

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Busagazi in 1990s

Maintained = 7

Disappearing = 4

Disappeared = 0

Kibuzi

Musakala

None

Masaaba

Nakabululu

 

Mbwazirume

Namunwe

 

Nakitembe

Namwezi

 

Nfuuka

 

 

Ntika

 

 

Siira

 

 

Notes: Kayinja (AAB) widespread and important; believed to be resistant to weevils and ants

Table 3. Banana stand characteristics on selected study farms in Busagazi

Farm

Hectares

Major inter-crop

Production trend

Stand age

Bunch weight (kg)

 

1970s

1990s

 

 

 

 

1

-

2

Pineapple

Decline

4

5-8

2

-

1

Beans

Decline

3

7-10

3

-

1

Coffee

Decline

5

10-12

4

5

10

Coffee

Decline

4

7-10

5

-

2

Coffee

Decline

20

8-10

6

1.3

1

Coffee

Decline

4

7-10

Village average yield: 7-10 kg

Notes: Many stands > 0.4 ha, including a number or relatively young plantations. Inter-cropping banana with coffee and pineapple common

Table 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Busagazi

Rank

Cause

1

Increased pest pressure

2

Degraded soils (fertility)

3

Unfavourable climatic changes (drought)

4

Diseases

5

Reduced labour availability

6

Land pressure

7

Change in management

1 = most important

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Busagazi

Farm

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

 

 

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

% dead

1

15

13

14

5

0

12.1

13.0

12

2

10

10

10

3

0

29.1

11.2

9

3

6

6

6

1

0

10.3

12.1

5

4

7

11

9

2

0.1

9.6

9.8

2

5

17

14

16

0

0

10.3

10.7

11

6

8

6

7

17

0

14.7

12.2

19

Site mean

11

10

11

5

0

14.3

11.5

10

Key

XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis
HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: Farmers reported banana weevil as leading cause of decline. First observed snapping in 1970s. Some farmers inspected planting material, trapped and/or applied pesticides. Black ant (Ondontomachus troglodytes) almost as important as weevil. Black sigatoka, known through local extension staff, reported as a recent and important disease problem. Farmers recognised damage symptoms of Fusarium wilt on Kayinja (ABB) (extent in village not assessed)

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Busagazi

1950s - 1960s

1990s

Soil amendments: application of cattle manure where available

Soil amendments: limited. Farm yard manure scarce. Coffee husks added to banana/pineapple intercrops

Soil conservation: trenches and grass bands routinely used for erosion control

Soil conservation: none

Mulching: routine spreading of banana leaves and elephant grass.

Mulching: rare; leaf trash but quantity is very low.

Weeds: good weed suppression through mulching and hand weeding

Weeds: weeding by hand hoe

Pesticides: not required as weevil population low

Pesticides: wealthiest apply Furadan and Dursban. Most cannot afford

De-leafing: thoroughly done 3 times a season

De-leafing: consistently done

Weevil control: 1) trapping with split pseudostems; 2) uprooting and chopping of corms; 3) ash applied at base of mats.

Weevil control: 1) trapping discontinued; 2) uprootingcorms sporadic due to lack of labour.

Notes: Banana was traditional staple food and important cash crop in 1970s. Management levels were high with enforcement of local by-laws (de-suckering, mulching, soil conservation, sanitation). As yields declined, limited resources shifted to more productive crops. Labour availability fell sharply between 1970s and 1980s, but was regarded as secondary cause of banana decline

Soils

Foliar analyses: Mg deficient; other nutrients adequate

Notes: High land pressure resulted in continuous cultivation, extensive inter-cropping and reduced fallow periods resulted in exhausted soils. Mulches and soil amendments uncommon. Farmers planted banana on their best soils or on remaining virgin lands

SITE 7: MPOMA (MUKONO DISTRICT)

Location: 3 adjacent villages 15 km N of Mukono

Village size: 1356 households in a 16 km2 area

Topography: Flat with gently sloping hills

Access: Poorly maintained murram road from parish connected to tarmac road to Mukono

Ethnic groups: Predominantly Baganda with Badama, Banyarwanda and Iteso

Land tenure: Mailo and Customary. Prior to civil unrest of 1970s/1980s, banana could be grown on rented land. Following resettlement, the dominant land owner in one village evicted tenants and squatters who had been growing banana and other crops. In the 1990s, many farmers lived on borrowed or rented land on which they were no longer allowed to grow perennial crops such as banana.

Land pressure: Uneven: High for small holders with intensive cultivation; low for large holders with extensive tracts of uncultivated land.

Farm size: 0.8-2.0 ha

Dominant farming systems: Mixed annual crops, coffee, banana

Banana production: Light to moderate

Other activities: A minority of men engaged in off-farm employment, including charcoal burning, brick making, owning shops in Kampala or Mukono, or holding civil service jobs.

Banana dynamics: Banana was the traditional staple, with maize second in importance. Cassava and sweet potato replaced banana and maize as the leading staples. In 1970s, coffee and cotton were the only cash crops but disappeared due to low fluctuating coffee prices and collapse of the cotton industry. Cooking banana enjoyed a brief market in the late 1970s and 1980s but could not be sustained due to poor yields. Kayinja (ABB), introduced in 1980s, became the leading cash crop with bunches sold to local distillers.

Figure 8: Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking banana in Mpoma.

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (9 May 1995) in Mpoma

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Banana (matooke)

21

1

Cassava

25

2

Greens

15

2

Sweet potato

19

3

Maize

13

3

Beans

11

4

Yam

12

4

Greens

8

5

Groundnut

9

5

Cabbage

7

6

Onion

7

6

Groundnut

6

7

Beans

5

7

Maize

5

8

Sweet potato

5

8

Banana (matooke)

4

9

Cassava

4

8

Onion

4

10

Cabbage

4

10

Yam

3

11

Soybean

3

11

Soybean

3

12

Irish potato

2

11

Irish potato

3

B. Cash crops

1

Coffee

55

1

Banana (beer)

21

2

Cotton

45

2

Sweet potato

18

 

Sugar cane

0

3

Cassava

17

 

Passion fruit

0

4

Passion fruit

17

 

Tomato

0

5

Sugar cane

11

 

Cassava

0

5

Tomato

11

 

Sweet potato

0

7

Coffee

4

 

Banana (beer)

0

 

Cotton

0

Beer bananas = Kayinja (ABB)

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in 1990s in Mpoma

Maintained = 7

Disappearing = 4

Disappeared = 0

Kisansa

Mukubyakonde

None

Kibuzi

Muvubo

 

Mbwazirume

Nakabululu

 

Mugisu

Namwezi

 

Nakitembe

 

 

Nakyetengu

 

 

Nabusa

 

 

Notes: Highland beer banana never grown. Kayinja (ABB) widespread; gained importance in 1980s due to tolerance of pests and low management. Ndiizi (AB) of minor importance

Table 3. Banana stand characteristics on selected study farms in Mpoma

Farm

Hectares

Major intercrop

Production trend

Stand age

Bunch weight (kg)

 

1970s

1990s

 

 

 

 

1

-

0.5

None

Decline

3

7-10

2

-

0.5

Cassava

Decline

4

3-4

3

-

0.5

Cassava

Decline

4

5-7

4

-

0.5

None

Decline

3

5-8

5

2.0

2.0

None

Decline

6

5-7

6

0.5

1.0

None

No change

4

10-20

Village average yield: 4-7 kg

Notes: Banana stand sizes in 1970 not clear. Currently, most stands < 0.4 ha. Average stand life was reported to have declined from decades to 3-6 yr, resulting in gradual abandonment of the crop

Table 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Mpoma

Rank

Cause

1

Competing activities

2

Increased pest pressure

3

Land pressure

4

Degraded soils (fertility)

5

Change in management

6

Reduced labour availability

7

Shifted attention to other crops

8

Introduction of unsuitable varieties

9

Unfavourable climatic changes (drought)

1 = most important

Notes: Many farmers preferred to grow cassava and sweet potatoes for local markets, while increasing numbers of men held off-farm employment

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Mpoma

Farm

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

 

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

% Dead

1

4

6

5

19

5.9

12.9

9.3

38

2

11

9

10

13

2.8

2.5

8.8

20

3

6

8

7

2

0.0

5.6

13.2

6

4

4

7

6

13

3.6

9.3

8.6

22

5

19

14

16

15

0.1

13.1

10.5

13

6

3

6

5

5

0.0

9.1

11.7

15

Site mean

8

8

8

10

1.7

9

10.5

17

Key

XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis
HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: Banana weevil first observed in 1935 and became a significant problem in the 1970s. Inter-cropping and weeding (i.e., digging in banana stands) reported to exacerbate weevil problems by exposing the corms to attack and increasing toppling. Farmers described Fusarium wilt symptoms on Kayinja (ABB) and Ndiizi (AB)

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Mpoma

1950's - 1960s

1990's

Soil conservation: trenches common for erosion control

Soil conservation: not practised

Soil amendments: none

Soil amendments: none

Mulching: spreading thick mulch of banana leaves between lines of mats

Mulching: sparse mulch of banana leaves often removed by termites.

Weeds: controlled by mulching and regular hand weeding

Weeds: weeding 1-2 times per year by hand hoe; constrained by labour availability

Weevil control: crop residues uprooted and destroyed. Ash applied around banana stools.

Weevil control: only larger farmers dug up and destroyed crop residues. Ash applied but not found effective

Pesticides: not used.

Pesticides: not used.

Notes: In 1970s, men and women were jointly responsible for banana management. Migrant labour used for bush clearing, ploughing and work in cotton and coffee, but never used in food crops. By 1990s, migrant labour was scarce and many men held off-farm employment, while women were unwilling to do labour-intensive management. However, change in management standards was more a result rather than a cause of banana decline. Low yields and short plantation life discouraged investment in banana production

Soils

Foliar analyses: N and Mg deficient; other nutrients adequate

Notes: Land pressure precluded fallowing and crop rotation, leading to over cultivation and soil exhaustion. Most crops showed decline on better soils, while cassava and sweet potato performed best on exhausted soils and had become leading staple and cash crops. Farmers recognised need for inputs to improve soil nutrient status, but this was beyond the means of most. If soils could be restored, farmers would rate banana as a high priority crop

SITE 8: NAKAWOMERO (LUWERO DISTRICT)

Location: 40 km E of Luwero, 80 km N of Kampala, adjacent to Lake Kiyoga

Village size: 127 households

Topography: Flat; shrubby grasslands and forest patches

Access: Remote with poorly maintained murram road, gutted with gulleys and barely passable in the rainy season.

Ethnic groups: The Baganda were predominant, with Bagwere, Bakiga, Banyakole (Bahima), Barundi, Basoga, Lugbar and Luo present.

Land tenure: Traditionally mailo but many were buying land following resettlement

Land pressure: Light

In the 1960s, this area was heavily populated and land pressure was a problem. During the 1970s and 1980s, the region suffered from political unrest and most residents abandoned their farms. Eventually some, but not all, of the village's residents returned to their homes. As a result, the village has remained sparsely populated with well spaced homesteads. Much land was in bush fallow or uncultivated.

Farm size: 2 ha

Dominant farming systems: Mixed annual crops, coffee, banana

Banana production: Light, except one area with virgin soils.

Other activities: Charcoal production from local forests

Banana dynamics: Cooking banana was the traditional staple. Yield decline under way by 1970s, continued through 1980s and led to marginal status of the crop in 1990s. Cassava was the first replacement crop, became an important cash crop, but was abandoned due to Cassava Mosaic Disease. Because of its remoteness, traders seldom visited this site and agriculture has been largely subsistence. Small amounts of cooking banana sold locally. Kayinja (ABB), introduced in the 1970s, became the second most important source of agricultural income.

Figure 9: time line demonstratin levels of cooking banana in Nakawomero.

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (17 May 1995) in Nakawomero

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Cassava

19

1

Sweet potato

27

2

Groundnut

17

2

Maize

24

3

Fruits

12

3

Groundnut

17

4

Beans

12

4

Yam

10

5

Banana (matooke)

11

5

Pumpkin

7

6

Sweet potato

6

6

Finger millet

4

7

Sesame

5

6

Fruits

4

8

Maize

4

8

Banana (matooke)

2

9

Yam

4

8

Sorghum

2

10

Pumpkin

3

10

Sesame

1

11

Soybean

3

10

Beans

1

11

Finger millet

3

12

Cassava

1

13

Sorghum

1

 

Soybean

0

B. Cash crops

1

Coffee

23

1

Coffee

27

2

Cotton

15

2

Banana (beer)

19

2

Cassava

15

3

Maize

16

4

Groundnut

11

4

Sweet potato

13

5

Fruits

8

5

Groundnut

10

5

Finger millet

8

6

Banana (matooke)

5

7

Maize

7

7

Yam

3

8

Banana(matooke)

5

8

Finger millet

3

9

Beans

3

9

Ndiizi

2

10

Yam

2

10

Fruits

2

11

Banana (beer)

2

11

Cassava

1

12

Ndiizi

2

 

Cotton

0

 

Sweet potato

0

 

Beans

0

Beer bananas = Kayinja (ABB)

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Nakawomero in1990s

Maintained = 16

Disappearing = 6

Disappeared = 1

Katwalo

Mbwazirume

Kabula*

Kibuzi

Mukubakonde

 

Musakala

Musakala

 

Muvubo

Namunwe

 

Muzinyama

Naserugiri

 

Nabusa

Siira

 

Nakabinyi

 

 

Nakabululu

 

 

Nakamali

 

 

Nakawere

 

 

Namunwe

 

 

Namwezi

 

 

Nandigobe

 

 

Ntika

 

 

Salalugazi

 

 

Sitakange

 

 

* = beer clone

Notes: Kayinja (ABB) widespread and marketed. Ndiizi (AB) in low amounts. Bogoya (= Gros Michel) (AAA) and Gonja (= plantain) (AAB) once grown but abandoned

Table 3. Banana stand characteristics on selected study farms in Nakawomero

Farm

Hectares

Major inter-crop

Production trend

Stand age

Bunch weight (kg)

 

1970s

1990s

 

 

 

 

 

5

3

Coffee

Decline

7

6-8

1

0.5

0.5

Coffee

Decline

3

5-8

2

7

5

Coffee

Decline

7

5-8

3

1

1

None

Decline

10

7-10

4

0.8

0.8

None

Decline

4

5-6

5

1

0.5

Coffee

Decline

3

8-10

6

 

 

 

 

 

 

Village average yield: 5-8 kg

Notes: One area with recently opened virgin soils had banana stands > 0.4 ha. Banana production in remainder of village ranged from kitchen garden to 0.2 ha. Many stands inter-cropped with coffee, beans or maize

Table 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Nakawomero

Rank

Cause

1

Increased pest pressure

2

Unfavourable climatic changes (drought)

3

Degraded soils (fertility)

4

Change in management

1 = most important

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Nakawomero

Farm

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

 

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

%Dead

1

17

19

18

4

0

8.9

11

16

2

7

11

9

7

0

19.1

10.7

14

3

11

15

13

8

0

17.6

10.5

6

4

6

6

6

6

0.7

10.4

11.5

11

5

5

7

6

2

0

24.7

13.9

10

6

2

5

4

11

0.8

19.9

12.7

8

Site mean

8

10

9

6

0.2

16.7

11.7

11

Key

XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis

HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: The banana weevil attained pest status in 1980s and was considered leading production constraint. Drought was reported to exacerbate weevil damage. Black ant (Odontomachus trogolodytes) also considered serious. Some farmers responded to pest problems by opening new pieces of land

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Nakawomeka

1950s to 1970s

1990s

Soil management: crop rotation and fallowing to soils; manure added

Soil management: crop rotation and restore fallowing still done.

Weeds: controlled by mulching and hand weeding

Weeds: infrequent weeding major factor in serious plantation decline

Mulching: common with elephant grass and banana trash

Mulching: considered futile due to rapid removal by termites and black ants.

Weevil control: crop residues destroyed to remove pest breeding sites

Weevil control: crop residues not destroyed due to labour shortage; use of new plots to reduce initial infestation

Pesticides: not used

Pesticides: not used

Notes: Although banana was the preferred staple food, it did not receive high management priority. Land pressure was high through the 1970s such that soils became exhausted and banana productivity went into decline. Thus, cassava replaced banana as the leading food crop until it, in turn, was replaced by sweet potato and maize. It appeared that farmers had not attempted to restore banana production in light of reduced land pressure and possible soil rejuvenation in the 1990s

While in most sites banana was planted on the most fertile soils, in Nakowomeka annual food crops (especially sweet potato) were placed on newly opened fallow land. Labour availability was more restrictive after the 1980s war, and farmers gave higher priority to making charcoal and managing coffee and maize crops than banana. Although land was no longer limiting, many farmers established banana/coffee systems in which coffee was favoured because of its greater commercial value. Banana, in part, was seen as a shade crop for coffee and received limited management attention, especially after the coffee became well established

Reduced management attention to banana was reflected in sporadic de-suckering of banana mats resulting in high plant density. Mulching with banana trash was common but there was little attempt to control pests

Soils

Foliar analyses: Mg, N, and K deficient; other nutrients adequate

Notes: Farmers reported soil exhaustion as an important cause of banana decline. However, causes of soil exhaustion were unclear. Although the land was intensively cropped prior to civil disturbances, land pressure was now low and much of the land was out of cultivation. Crop rotation and fallowing of at least 2 to 3 year was possible for most farmers. As banana stands deteriorated, they were abandoned and replaced by new plantations on fallowed or forested land

SITE 9: NAKASAJJA (MUKONO DISTRICT)

Location: 2 adjacent villages, 15 km E of Gayaza and 40 km NE of Kampala

Village size: 1039 households

Topography: Gently sloping hills, patches of forest

Access: Very good: A well maintained murram road passes from Nakasajja to Gayaza which, in turn, is connected to Kampala by tarmac.

Ethnic groups: Baganda predominant, with Banyarwanda, Barundi, Lugbara and Bagisu present

Land tenure: Mostly freehold with some farms remaining under mailo; only annual crops could be grown on rented land

Land pressure: High; intensive cultivation

Farm size: 0.8 - 1.2 ha

Dominant farming systems: Mixed annual crops

Banana production: Light to moderate

Other activities: Trading: buying staples locally and selling in trading centres of Gayaza and Kalerwe; bringing manufactured goods from Kampala to Gayaza and Nakasajja.

Banana dynamics: Cooking banana was traditional staple. Yield decline first noticed in late 1960s and accelerated in 1980s. Although no longer leading food in 1990s, remained relatively important. Initially, coffee and cotton were predominant cash crops, and maize became important by 1970s. Cotton and coffee disappeared because of the industry's collapse and unstable prices, respectively. Cooking banana sold to Kampala in 1970s but thereafter low yield negated any market potential. Local conversion of cassava into flour provided better means of storage and extended its shelf life, providing additional incentive for its production. Kayinja (ABB), introduced in the 1980s, is now an important cash crop. Traders now deliver cooking banana to the site.

Figure 10: Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking banana in Nagasajja.

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (7 June 1995) in Nakasajja

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Banana (matooke)

27

1

Cassava

21

2

Sweet Potato

20

2

Sweet Potato

19

3

Maize

15

3

Maize

17

4

Beans

12

3

Beans

17

5

Cassava

10

5

Banana (matooke)

9

6

Groundnut

7

6

Tomato

5

7

Peas

3

7

Groundnut

4

8

Tomato

2

8

Yam

3

9

Irish potato

2

9

Soybean

2

10

Yam

2

10

Irish potato

1

11

Soybean

1

10

Peas

1

B. Cash crops

1

Coffee

29

1

Cassava

22

2

Maize

16

2

Beans

16

3

Cotton

15

3

Maize

12

4

Banana (matooke)

11

4

Banana (beer)

10

5

Beans

8

5

Tomato

8

6

Sweet potato

7

6

Cabbage

7

7

Tomato

5

7

Coffee

6

8

Cabbage

4

8

Sweet potato

5

9

Ndiizi

4

9

Sugarcane

4

 

Sugarcane

0

10

Yam

4

 

Cassava

0

11

Banana (matooke)

3

 

Yam

0

12

Ndiizi

2

 

Banana (beer)

0

 

Cotton

0

Beer bananas = Kayinja (ABB)

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Nakasajja in1990s

Maintained = 13

Disappearing = 4

Disappeared = 0

Kibuzi

Mukubakonde

None

Kisansa

Namwezi

 

Mbwazirume

Nandigobe

 

Mugeso

Naselugiri

 

Musakala

 

 

Muvubo

 

 

Nakabululu

 

 

Nakamali

 

 

Nakitembe

 

 

Nakyetengu

 

 

Ndyabalangira

 

 

Nfuuka

 

 

Siira

 

 

Notes: Highland brewing clones never grown. Ndiizi (AB) grown for local consumption and minor cash crop, while Kayinja (ABB) widespread and important

Table 3. Banana stand characteristics on selected study farms in Nakasajja

Farm

Hectares

Major intercrop

Production trend

Stand age

Bunch weight (kg)

 

1970s

1990s

 

 

 

 

1

2

2

None

No change

2

8-10

2

1

0.5

Coffee

Decline

8

6-7

3

1.5

0.5

Cassava

Decline

4

5-7

4

1

0.5

None

Decline

7

5-7

5

0.4

0.8

None

Decline

4

8-12

6

1

0.2

None

Decline

5

4-7

Village average yield: 5-7 kg
Notes: Plantation life reduced from > 20 years to as little as 2 years. Following shoft-term fallows, stands lasted 3 years, while in absence of fallowing some plants failed to fallow and stands often lasted only 2 years

Table 4. Farmer ranking of causes of banana decline in Nakasajja

Rank

Cause

1

Increased pest pressure

2

Change in management

3

Land pressure

4

Unfavourable climatic changes (drought)

5

Competing activities

6

Lack of clean planting material

7

Social unrest

1 = most important

Table 5. Weevil and nematode levels on selected farms in Nakasajja

Farm

Weevils

Nematodes

Roots

 

XI

XO

XT

RI

RS

HM

Total

%Dead

1

1

5

3

17

6.4

5.9

11.4

24

2

17

11

14

9

0

6.4

12.3

15

3

14

10

12

9

1.7

1.5

9

10

4

9

9

9

15

4.7

10.3

10.1

17

5

6

8

7

16

1

7.7

10.8

17

6

8

6

7

5

0

4.8

10.5

26

Site mean

9

8

9

12

2.3

6.1

10.7

18

Key:

XI: Percent damage to central cylinder
XO: Percent damage to outer cortex
XT: Percent damage to corm
RI: Root necrosis index
RS: Numbers of Radopholus similis
HM: Numbers of Helicotylenchus multicinctus

Notes: Banana weevil leading constraint; first obtained pest status in 1950s. Black ant (Odontomachus troglodytes) also serious. Termites remove mulch and are important pest

Table 6. Shifts in agronomic practices and levels of banana management in Naksasajja

1950s to 1970s

1990s

Soil amendments: ash to increase vigour

Soil amendments: few farmers still used ash

Soil management: fallowing; bands for water conservation

Soil conservation: no longer practiced

Mulching: most farmers applied thick mulch from banana trash

Mulching: done by few farmers but most discouraged by rapid removal by termites

Weeds: controlled by mulching and hand weeding

Weeds: weeding by hand hoe

Weevil control: most farmers uprooted and destroyed crop residues. Many used ash to repel weevils

Weevil control: crop residues not destroyed due to lack of labour; farmers try to use clean planting material

Pesticides: not used

Pesticides: not used

Note: Land pressure resulted in increased inter-cropping and reduced crop rotation and fallowing. Women had primary responsibility for managing cooking banana, while men worked cash crops or traded. In past, most family labour was allocated to banana, while hired labour was used in coffee and cotton. With scarcity of hired labour, family labour shifted to cash or more productive food crops. Farmers became discouraged by poor banana yields and believed the crop could not be revived even with improved management

Soils

Foliar analyses: N and Mg limiting; other nutrients adequate

Note: Farmers did not regard degraded soils as a cause of banana production decline. Better soils were considered fertile and potentially productive, and farmers believed that fertility could be restored to degraded soils with better management. Such management was constrained by land pressure and lack of resources for inputs

B. SOUTHWESTERN UGANDA

The southwestern region of Uganda includes important banana growing regions in Masaka, Rakai, Mbarara, Bushenyi, Ntungamo and Kabale districts. Currently, Mbarara and Bushenyi are the most important of these with highest yields and the dominant suppliers for Uganda's urban markets. The region is characterised by extensive short grasslands and low rainfall (500-1500 mm). This region has less densely populated than the central region and supported a mixture of pastoralists and farmers. Traditionally, finger millet was the leading staple, while coffee and cotton were important cash crops. To study banana crop expansion in southwestern Uganda, 6 villages were randomly selected in Mbarara and Bushenyi districts.

SITE 10: BUHWEJU (BUSHENYI DISTRICT)

Location: 70 km NW from Mbarara

Village size: 720 households

Topography: High hills, covered by grassland and deep forested valleys

Access: Poor; poorly maintained murram road (30 km to the Mbarara-Bushenyi tarmac road), and hilly terrain

Ethnic groups: Banyankole, with small minority of Bakiga.

Land tenure: Mailo

Land pressure: Light; sparsely populated

Farm size: Mostly 0.6-0.8 ha although some farms were up to 3.2 ha.

Dominant farming systems: Banana

Banana production: Moderate

Banana dynamics: Traditionally, cooking banana was a minor crop and millet was the primary staple. Since 1970s, cooking banana has gained favour because of reduced risk (millet often failed in dry years), high yields, year-round harvest, and ease of production and preparation. However, with low population levels and little land pressure, intensity of production had not approached levels of other western sites. Marketing of crops has been sporadic due to site remoteness. Peas became leading cash crop, representing a speciality market for traders. Beer banana had become important for production of gin (waragi) for sale to Uganda Distilleries in Luzira but this market was declining. Cooking banana is sold to traders from Kampala although farm-gate prices are very low at this site.

Figure 11 Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking banana in Buhweju

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (12 July 1995) in Buhweju

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

$

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Finger millet

32

1

Banana (matooke)

31

2

Beans

19

2

Finger millet

19

3

Sweet potato

15

3

Beans

19

4

Sorghum

13

4

Peas

16

5

Maize

9

5

Sweet potato

6

6

Peas

8

6

Sorghum

3

7

Banana (matooke)

5

7

Maize

2

 

Groundnut

0

8

Irish potato

2

 

Irish potato

0

9

Groundnut

2

B.Cash cropsa

1

Sorghum

33

1

Peas

30

1

Banana (beer)

33

2

Banana (beer)

21

1

Peas

33

3

Banana (matooke)

19

 

Finger millet

0

4

Finger millet

10

 

Wheat

0

5

Beans

9

 

Banana (matooke)

0

6

Sorghum

7

 

Beans

0

7

Wheat

4

Beer bananas = Mbidde
a Cash crop production very light in 1970s

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Buhweju in 1990s

Maintained = 9

Disappearing = 4

Disappeared = 0

Embululu

Bukunku

None

Enjagata

Embiire*

 

Enkara

Engambani*

 

Entaragaza

Enshenyuka*

 

Entukura

 

 

Enyeru

 

 

Enzirabushera

 

 

Kitika

 

 

Mbwazirume

 

 

* = beer clones

Notes: The 3 brewing clones were being phased out due to reduced purchases of processed waragi by traders

Table 3. Farmer rankings of key factors contributing to banana expansion in Buhweju

Rank

Cause

1

Food security

2

Improved management

3

Increased market demand

4

Increased market for waragi

5

Extension services

1 = most important

Management: Management standards are moderately high. Banana is produced in monoculture to maximize yields. On most farms, spacing maintained at 2-3 plants/mat through regular de-suckering. Half of the farmers removed corms for weevil control. Routine management of banana by family labour. Hired (local) labour uncommon and primarily for land preparation. Men primarily responsible for banana stands

Soils: Farmers considered their soils fertile, and this was reflected in high and increasing banana yields. Banana was rarely planted on lower fertility soils and only with addition of manure. The major problems were leaching of nutrients and soil erosion. Most farmers planted grass bands on slopes for erosion control. However, only 30% of the farmers mulched (because of limited materials) or applied manure

Pests: Banana weevil, considered a minor pest in the 1960s, had recently increased in importance. Wilting of matooke, first observed in 1993, occurred near homesteads or animal kraals. Weeds (especially coach grass) and moles considered important production constraints

Future of banana production

Although cooking banana production expanded in the 1980s in response to market demand, farmers viewed brewing bananas (with longer shelf life) as a more favourable option because of the remoteness of the site. However, management attention continued to be directed towards cooking banana because of its attributes as a food crop (food security, convenience of preparation, taste). The consensus was that banana production would continue to increase

SITE 11: KATOOMA (BUSHENYI DISTRICT)

Location: 45 kms NW of Mbarara

Village size: 680 households in a 6 km2 area

Topography: Plateau

Access: Good; well maintained murram road to the Mbarara-Kabale tarmac road.

Ethnic groups: Banyankole-Bairu with a small minority of Bakiga. Unlike the pastoralist groups which had settled in Mbarara and Bushenyi, the Banyankole-Bairu were traditionally cultivators.

Land tenure: Customary

Land pressure: Heavy

Farm size: 0.8 ha

Dominant farming systems: Banana

Banana production: Heavy

Banana dynamics: One of the first sites in southwest Uganda to grow and market cooking banana. Traditional food crops were finger millet and sweet potato. Cooking banana introduced in 1940s and 1950s by returning migrant labour from central Uganda. Began replacing finger millet in 1990s because of ease of production and food security (i.e., year round harvest and reduced risk).

Banana also important cash crop by 1970s (second behind coffee). Coffee declined in 1980s due to unfavourable prices, and banana became dominant cash crop with high yields and well maintained roads attracting traders from Kampala and Mbarara.

Figure 12 Time Line demonstrating production levels of cooking bananas in Katooma

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (5 July 1995) in Katooma

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Banana (matooke)

23

1

Banana (matooke)

25

2

Beans

16

2

Beans

17

3

Finger millet

13

3

Finger millet

11

4

Sweet potato

11

4

Vegetables

10

5

Cassava

10

5

Cassava

9

6

Groundnut

7

6

Sweet potato

8

7

Fruits

6

7

Maize

6

7

Maize

6

8

Groundnut

5

9

Peas

4

9

Fruits

4

10

Cowpea

3

10

Irish potato

4

11

Soybean

1

11

Peas

1

 

Irish potato

0

12

Soybean

1

 

Vegetable

0

 

Cowpea

0

B. Cash crops

1

Coffee

30

1

Banana (matooke)

34

2

Banana (matooke)

24

2

Coffee

11

3

Banana (beer)

12

3

Beans

11

4

Sorghum

11

4

Finger millet

10

5

Beans

9

5

Banana (beer)

6

6

Groundnut

9

6

Vegetables

6

7

Fruits

4

7

Cassava

6

 

Maize

0

8

Sorghum

4

 

Vegetables

0

9

Groundnut

4

 

Mulberry

0

10

Fruits

3

 

Finger millet

0

11

Maize

1

 

Cassava

0

12

Mulberry

1

Beer bananas = Mbidde

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Katooma in 1990s

Maintained = 9

Disappearing -3

Disappeared = 0

Butobe

Bukumu

None

Enjagata

Embiire*

 

Enkara

Embururu

 

Enshembeshembe

 

 

Entaragaza

 

 

Entukura

 

 

Enyeru

 

 

Enzirabushera

 

 

Kibuzi

 

 

* = beer clone

Notes: Entaragaza, Enkara, Mbwazirume and Enyeru most preferred

Table 3. Farmer rankings of key factors contributing to banana expansion in Katooma

Rank

Cause

1

Decline in coffee

2

Increased market demand

3

Crop convenience

4

Food security

1 = most important

Management: Banana was given high management priority with both men and women working in banana stands. Men also tended livestock, while women cultivated annual crops. Banana management standards were moderate to high. Frequent de-suckering maintainted 3 plants per mat, and fields were regularly weeded. Beans were commonly planted in banana stands every three years to loosen the soil, although farmers noted that intercropping reduced banana yields. Few farmers were able to apply manure or external mulches

Pests: Banana weevil and unidentified corm rots considered important banana production constraints. Wilting of cooking banana observed. Few farmers practiced sanitation or applied pesticides for weevil control

Soils: Recent yield declines, in part, attributed to reduced soil fertility. Farmers felt soil fertility not major constraint if mulch and manure applied. Stands partially mulched, and few farmers planted grass bands or applied manure

5. Future of banana production

In spite of increasing importance, future outlook for banana was unclear. This was the only southwestern study site where farmers (70%) noted decreasing bunch size and expressed concern over the crop's future. Farmers believed that banana production will soon decline, due mainly to increased land pressure, weevil pressure, toppling and disease problems

SITE 12: KASHARI (MBARARA DISTRICT)

Location: 15 km W of Mbarara

Village size: 200 households in a 6 km2 area

Topography: Gently rolling hills and natural grasslands

Access: Excellent; along Mbarara-Bushenyi tarmac road

Ethnic groups: Banyankole-Bahima predominated with a few Banyankole-Bairu, Bakiga and Banyarwanda also present.

Land tenure: Customary

Land pressure: Moderate; much of land in pasture

Farm size: 3.2 ha

Dominant farming systems: Banana and pasture

The Banyankole-Bahima were traditional pastoralists. Livestock has remained a major activity in the region and much of the land on the periphery of the village was given over to pasture. In general, paddocks are located in the valleys while crops are concentrated on the hill tops.

Banana production: Moderate

Banana dynamics: Cooking banana introduced by returning migrant labour in 1960s and quickly replaced finger millet (the traditional staple) because of its year-round harvest and relative ease of production and preparation. Initially grew mixed cooking and beer (mbidde) bananas as shade for coffee. Cash income was provided from both livestock and sale of crops. Coffee, the first important cash crop, was surpassed in importance by beer banana and sorghum (sold to local beer and gin producers) by the 1970s. During the 1980s, farmers replaced coffee (receiving low prices) with banana monoculture. With increasing urban market demand (Kampala and secondarily Mbarara), cooking banana brought higher prices than beer banana. Farmers saw livestock as providing quick capital when necessary, while banana sustained regular family needs throughout the year.

Figure 13: Time line demonstration of prodiction of cooking bananas in Kashari

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (4 July 1995) in Kashari

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

$

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Banana (matooke)

29

1

Banana (matooke)

35

2

Finger millet

19

2

Beans

16

3

Beans

16

3

Finger millet

14

4

Sweet potato

12

4

Sweet potato

11

5

Maize

7

5

Maize

8

6

Groundnut

6

6

Groundnut

7

7

Cassava

6

7

Cassava

6

8

Peas

4

8

Vegetables

3

9

Vegetables

2

9

Peas

1

B. Cash crops

1

Banana (beer)

37

1

Banana (matooke)

41

2

Sorghum

24

2

Beans

20

3

Groundnut

17

3

Finger millet

14

4

Coffee

16

4

Maize

13

5

Beans

3

5

Sorghum

3

6

Banana (matooke)

2

6

Groundnut

3

 

Cassava

0

7

Cabbage/Tomato

2

 

Cabbage/Tomato

0

7

Banana (beer)

2

 

Maize

0

9

Cassava

1

 

Finger millet

0

10

Coffee

1

Beer bananas = Mbidde

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Kashari in 1990s

Maintained = 4

Disappearing = 4

Disappeared = 0

Entaragaza

Embururu

None

Enyeru

Enjagata

 

Mbwazirume

Mbidde*

 

Kibuzi

Rwamugongo

 

* Beer bananas (clones undifferentiated by farmers)

Table 3. Farmer rankings of key factors contributing to banana expansion

Rank

Cause

1

Increased market demand

2

Improved management practices

3

Introduction of banana culture from Buganda

4

Food security

5

Need for money

6

Favourable climatic changes (prolonged rainy seasons)

1 = most important

Notes: Initial expansion of banana hectarage was to replace finger millet as staple crop. Further expansion in response to urban market demand. As banana gained importance as a cash crop farmers intensified management, resulting in higher yields. Farmers perceived improved management as playing the most important role in increased banana production.

Management: Both men and women are involved in managing banana stands. Men also tended livestock while women produced annual food crops. Management levels were high and considered much better then in the past. Income earned from banana allowed most farmers to work on-farm year-round, rather than serve as seasonal migrant labour. Most farmers relied more on family than on hired labour and many did not allow casual workers in their banana stands. Banana commonly intercropped in plant cycle, then maintained as monoculture. Most farms implemented frequent weeding, good sanitation, regular de-suckering (to maintain plant density at 3-4/mat) and de-leafing. De-leafing was to prevent wind breakage and provide mulch to conserve moisture and control weeds. Half of the farmers intercropped every 3 years with beans to loosen the soil and improve soil fertility.

Pests: Banana weevil perceived as key constraint. Nearly all farmers uprooted corms, split pseudostems and trapped to control weevils. Toppling and wilting of Matooke were also problems.

Soils: Banana plantations were established on the farmers' most fertile soils or on former animal kraals. Well managed stands were reported to last more than 50 years, while plantations could still last 8-20 years with minimal management. More than half of the farmers applied manure, while 30% constructed trenches to prevent water runoff and soil erosion.

Future of banana production

Banana production was still rising through increased land area and improved yields. Greatest concern was about variability in and saturation of markets for banana.

SITE 13: BIHARWE (MBARARA DISTRICT)

Location: 15 km ENE of Mbarara town

Village size: 700 households in an 8 km2 area

Topography: Gently sloping hills and natural grasslands

Access: Excellent; along Masaka-Mbarara tarmac road

Ethnic groups: Banyakole-Bahima (pastoralists) and Banyakole-Bairu (cultivators) majority, with Bakooki, Banyarwanda and a few Baganda

Land tenure: Freehold or customary

Land pressure: Moderate

Farm size: 2.2 ha

Dominant farming systems: Banana and pasture

Banana production: Moderate

Banana dynamics: Mixed crops and livestock area, with much land given over to pasture. Cooking and brewing bananas (mbidde) long present in kitchen gardens, but gained importance during 1940s and 1950s, as migrant labour returned from banana growing areas of central Uganda. Cooking banana rapidly replaced finger millet (traditional staple) because of year-round harvest and greater stability of yield. Farmers still prefer eating millet.

Livestock and coffee were major sources of income until 1970s. Then, road deterioration, sporadic trader visits and an unreliable coffee market led to replacement by beer banana (sold to local producers of gin), groundnuts and onions. During the 1980s, high yields, increasing urban market demand, and improvement of the Kampala-Mbarara road brought traders to the region. Cooking banana, which earlier had no market, brought in 5 to 10 times as much money per bunch as for beer banana, resulting in shifts from beer to cooking types.

Figure 14: Time line demonstrating productivity levels of cooking bananas in Biharwe

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (3 July 1995) in Biharwe

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Finger millet

21

1

Banana (matooke)

23

2

Banana (matooke)

20

2

Beans

18

3

Beans

16

3

Finger millet

13

4

Groundnut

16

4

Cassava

12

5

Maize

12

5

Sweet potato

10

6

Sweet potato

6

6

Vegetables

9

7

Cassava

4

7

Maize

8

8

Pigeonpea

3

8

Irish potato

4

9

Vegetables

1

9

Groundnut

2

9

Peas

1

10

Peas

1

 

Irish potato

0

 

Pigeonpea

0

B. Cash crops

1

Coffee

32

1

Banana (matooke)

28

2

Groundnut

24

2

Beans

19

3

Banana (beer)

20

3

Tomato

16

4

Onion

13

4

Cassava

11

5

Sorghum

10

5

Groundnut

10

 

Vegetables

0

6

Banana (beer)

7

 

Cassava

0

7

Irish potato

4

 

Irish potato

0

7

Onion

4

 

Banana (matooke)

0

9

Vegetables

2

 

Tomato

0

 

Sorghum

0

 

Beans

0

 

Coffee

0

Beer bananas = Mbidde

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Biharwe in 1990s

Maintained = 8

Disappearing = 1

Disappeared = 0

Butobe

Mbidde*

None

Embululu

 

 

Enjagata

 

 

Entaragaza

 

 

Enyeru

 

 

Kibuzi

 

 

Mbwazirume

 

 

Mujuba

 

 

* Beer bananas (clones undifferentiated by farmers)

Notes: Ndizi (AB) Gros Michel being phased out due to Fusarium wilt

Table 3. Farmer rankings of key factors contributing to banana expansion in Biharwe

Rank

Cause

1

Increased market demand

2

Food security

3

Population increase

4

Replacement of unproductive pastures

5

Improved management

1 = most important

Notes: Increased banana production was attributed first to greater food security and then to market demand. Banana land area was also increased to support a growing population and as replacement of marginal pasture land. Yield increases were realised with intensified management

Management: Management levels increased with commercialization of banana. In spite of increasing land pressure, stand longevity was perceived as "permanent" under "good management", with high and relatively sustainable yields. Both men and women were involved in banana management. Migrant labour was restricted to land preparation and care of annual crops. Most banana was grown in monoculture, although beans were intercropped with banana to loosen the soil when it had formed a hard pan and, thus, to allow water to percolate. Nearly all farmers maintained 3 plants per mat through regular de-suckering they also deleafed, mulched with grass and leaves, kept fields weed-free and practiced sanitation

Pests: Though long present, banana weevil problems have worsened in last 5-10 years. Toppling and an unknown corm rot are also constraints. Wilting of matooke observed near homestead and in animal kraals. On some farms, Fusarium wilt present on Ndizi and Gros Michel

Soils: Banana stands commonly located in valley bottoms on most fertile soils. Although farmers reported sustainable systems under good management, yield decline reported in some older plantations (i.e., > 20 years) was attributed to loss of soil fertility. Farmers were reluctant to fallow declining plantations for fear of loss of income

Future of banana production

Most farmers agreed that continued increase in crop land area was unlikely due to land pressure, but that yield per unit area would continue to increase with current and improved management techniques

SITE 14: KAGARAMA (MBARARA DISTRICT)

Location: 30 km S of Mbarara, (far end of Kagarama Valley)

Village size: 450 households in a 7 km2 area

Topography: Kagarama Valley; wide plateau with steep hills; natural grassland.

Access: Fair. A murram road connects the village to Kaberebere, a major banana collection centre 6 kilometres from Mbarara town. However, the distance and high terrain make the site relatively unattractive to traders who more easily obtain banana from the many growers between Mbarara and Kagarama.

Ethnic groups: Mostly Banyankole-Bairu with some Bakiga.

Land tenure: Freehold or customary

Land pressure: Moderate

Farm size: 1.6 ha

Dominant farming systems: Banana and annual crops

Banana production: Heavy

Banana dynamics: Banana introduced in late 1940s by Baganda administrators (sent by central government) who realised that it was more reliable than finger millet (the traditional staple which often failed). Gradually replaced finger millet because of stable yields and ease of preparation. Coffee was traditional cash crop but, by 1980s, unreliable market and falling prices made its production risky. Fortuitously, decline in coffee markets coincided with increasing market demand for banana and repair of road which made the site accessible to traders. Most farmers replaced coffee plantations with banana and onion crops. Large bunch sizes attracted traders from Kampala although farm-gate prices were low due to remoteness of site.

Figure 15: Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking bananas in Kararama

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (13 July 1995) in Kagarama

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Banana (matooke)

34

1

Banana (matooke)

30

2

Beans

24

2

Beans

18

3

Millet

16

3

Irish potato

12

4

Sweet potato

12

4

Maize

12

5

Cassava

10

5

Millet

7

6

Groundnut

9

6

Sweet potato

6

7

Peas

8

7

Cassava

5

8

Sorghum

5

8

Peas

3

9

Maize

4

9

Sorghum

3

 

Irish potato

0

9

Groundnut

3

B. Cash crops

1

Coffee

33

1

Banana (matooke)

27

2

Beans

21

2

Onion

16

3

Peas

14

3

Beans

12

4

Groundnut

12

4

Banana (beer)

10

5

Banana (beer)

8

5

Groundnut

9

6*

Sorghum

7

6*

Sorghum

8

7

Onion

4

7

Irish potato

7

 

Irish potato

0

8*

Peas

6

 

Banana (matooke)

0

9

Fruits

4

 

Fruits

0

10

Coffee

2

Beer bananas = Mbidde

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Kagarama in 1990s in Kagarama

Maintained = 8

Disappearing = 3

Disappeared = 0

Embululu

Butobe

None

Enjagata

Kaitabunyonyi

 

Enjuma

Katwalo

 

Enshakara

 

 

Enshenyi

 

 

Kibuzi

 

 

Mujuba

 

 

Nakinyika

 

 

 

Table 3. Farmer rankings of key factors contributing to banana expansion in Kagarama

Rank

Cause

1

Increased market demand

2

Population increase

3

Infrastructure (Improved road)

4

Extension services

1 = most important

Management: Banana management standards high. Men primarily responsible for banana management, while women weeded banana fields and worked annual crops. Hired labour basically employed in onions production (considered more labour demanding than banana). Nearly all farmers grew banana in monoculture, maintained plant density at 2-3 plants/mat through regular de-suckering, spread banana leaves and/or imported grass as mulch, and maintained clean fields through hand-weeding. Additionally, 40% of interviewed farmers applied cattle manure while 20% constructed bunds for erosion control. Half of the farmers uprooted corms for weevil control.

Pests: Wilting of matooke considered most serious constraint. Banana weevil also considered important.

Soils: Generally stony and shallow. Bananas were planted on the richest and deepest soils. Farmers believed intensified banana production was offset by good soil management practices (mulching, manure, erosion control) and that soil fertility was not a constraint in banana stands. However, soil degradation was reflected in decreased yields in other crops.

5. Future of banana production

The District Agriculture Officer of Mbarara indicated that banana production had increased 4 fold over the last 10 years and was still going up. Mean bunch size in the 1990s continued to be > 40 kg and farmers saw no reason why they could not maintain this level of production.

SITE 15: KABUYANDA (MBARARA DISTRICT)

Location: 4 villages 60 km S of Mbarara, on edge of Kabuyanda Valley

Village size: 1500 households in a 32 km2 area

Topography: Large, flat valley

Access: Fair to Mbarara; fair-good to Kabale. Site remote from trading centres and latter part of murram road from Mbarara crosses small but steep mountain range before descending to the site. This descent was rough, poorly maintained and difficult to pass in the rainy season. A better maintained, flat murram road crossed Kabuyanda Valley to the Mbarara-Bushenyi tarmac road, providing easier access to Kabale than to Mbarara.

Ethnic groups: Bakiga with Banyankole and Bafumbira.

Land tenure: Freehold or customary

Land pressure: Low, although intensive agriculture practiced near trading centres

Farm size: 2 ha

Dominant farming systems: Banana and annual food crops

Banana production: Heavy, dominated by AAA-EA beer clones

Banana dynamics: Area first settled in 1952 and remained sparsely populated until construction of road in 1970s. Immigrants initially favoured annual crops but began switching to cooking banana in 1970s for reasons of food security and an emerging though sporadic markets. A weekly market drew traders from Kabale, Mbarara and Kampala. Cooking banana, juice and gin (waragi) marketed in Mbarara/Kampala; beans and maize in Kabale/Rwanda. Remoteness of site and sporadic visits of banana traders had following ramifications:

1. low farm-gate price

2. casual labour not profitable in banana; directed to annual crops

3. clones for juice and brewing (with longer storage lives) favoured

4. most families owned distilling facility

5. alternate markets for beans and maize (Kabale and Rwanda) attractive

6. less than 50% of cooking banana marketed

7. post-harvest losses high in absence of traders.

Figure 16: Time line demonstrating production levels of cooking bananas in Kabuyanda.

Table 1. Farmers ranking of food and cash crops in the 1970s and 1990s (11 July 1995) in Kabuyanda

1970s

1990s

Rank

Crop

%

Rank

Crop

%

A. Food crops

1

Sorghum

19

1

Banana (matooke)

20

2

Finger millet

16

2

Beans

19

3

Beans

15

3

Maize

15

4

Banana (matooke)

12

4

Cassava

9

5

Sweet potato

10

5

Sorghum

9

6

Peas

9

6

Irish potato

8

7

Maize

8

7

Vegetables

7

8

Groundnut

7

8

Groundnut

4

9

Irish potato

4

9

Sweet potato

3

 

Vegetables

0

10

Finger millet

3

 

Soybean

0

11

Peas

2

 

Cassava

0

12

Soybean

1

B. Cash crops

1

Beans

21

1

Beans

22

2

Finger millet

19

2

Maize

16

3

Banana (beer)

16

3

Banana (beer)

15

4

Tobacco

13

4

Banana (matooke)

12

5

Coffee

11

5

Coffee

12

6

Groundnut

8

6

Sorghum

10

7

Banana (matooke)

7

7

Irish potato

10

8

Sorghum

3

8

Groundnut

3

9

Maize

3

 

Finger millet

0

 

Irish potato

0

 

Tobacco

0

 

 

 

 

 

 

Beer bananas = Mbidde

Table 2. Status of AAA-EA banana clones grown in Kabuyanda in 1990s

Maintained = 13

Disappearing = 7

Disappeared = 0

Endibwa

Engumba*

None

Enjagata

Ensika*

 

Entaragaza

Entukura*

 

Enyabutende

Enyabutembe*

 

Enyabwekonera

Kikirakyantama

 

Enyambululu

Nakyetengwa

 

Enyamiyonga

Shombobureku*

 

Enzirabushera

 

 

Kaitabunyonyi

 

 

Kibuzi

 

 

Mbwazirume

 

 

Mukazi mugumba

 

 

Rwamugongo

 

 

* = beer clones

Notes: Kayinja (ABB), Kisubi (AB) and Ndizi (AB) also grown. Although gin (waragi) important source of income, few brewing clones (5 highland and 2 exotic) due to uncertainty of future market

Table 3. Farmer rankings of key factors contributing to banana expansion in Kabuyanda

Rank

Cause

1

Population increase

2

Food security

3

Increased market demand

4

Crop convenience (production and preparation)

5

Improved management practices

6

Favourable climatic changes (prolonged rainy seasons)

1 = most important

Note: Cooking banana gained importance as food crop due to stable yields, reduced risk and year-round harvest. Population growth and market demand have driven increase in banana hectarage, while latter has also resulted in better management

Management: Both men and women involved in banana production. Men initially produced beer banana for local beer brewing and distilling of gin and later directed increasing attention to cooking banana as its market developed. Migrant labour too costly for banana production, with daily wages exceeding farm-gate prices for a bunch, and are, therefore, most often employed in beans production, beer making and the production of gin. Banana was grown in monoculture for maximal yield, with plant density maintained at 2 to 3 per mat by regular de-suckering. Fields were regularly weeded during the rainy season, while pseudostem splitting, detrashing and de-leafing were done in the dry season. Mulching with banana trash, annual crop residues and grass common

Pests: Banana weevil important, with problems worsening from 1986. Termites major problem in removing mulches. Fusarium wilt was reported on Ndiizi and Kayinja

Soils: Banana planted on deep soils in the valley bottom and on the tops of the hills, but seldom on mountain slopes. Soils relatively fertile, although farmers related high clay content to lower yields and shorter plantation life than obtained elsewhere in Mbarara. As banana stands declined, new plantations were often opened on remaining virgin land

Future of banana production

Cooking banana likely to remain an important food crop and moderately important cash crop. Farmers believe that yields can be sustained with current management practices

PART 4:

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

John Lynam assisted in problem definition and project formation. Paul Smithson provided analysis of soil and of foliar samples. Beverly McIntyre conducted DRIS analysis for foliar nutrient data and offered insights into interpretation of these data. Funding for both the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) and the Ugandan National Banana Program was provided by the Rockefeller Foundation and the Ugandan government. The research team is most grateful to the extension service and local council officials whose assistance in mobilising people for interviews was invaluable. We are grateful to Michael Wejuli and Richard Ssedege for collection of data while John Lynam and Akin Adesina are thanked for their critical comments on an earlier draft of this document.

References

Angeles, D.E., Sumner, M.E. and Lahav, E. 1993. Preliminary DRIS norms for banana. Journal of Plant Nutrition 16:1059-1070.

Gold, C.S., Speijer, P.R., Karamura, E.B., Tushemereirwe, W.K. and Kashaija, I.N. 1994a. Survey methodologies for pest and disease assessment in Uganda. African Crop Science Journal 2:309-321.

Gold, C.S., Karamura, E.B., Kiggundu,A., Bagamba, F. and Abera, A.M.K. 1999. Geographic shifts in highland cooking banana (Musa spp., group AAA-EA) production in Uganda. International Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and World Ecology 6:45-59.

INIBAP. 1986. A Preliminary Study of the Needs for Banana Research in Eastern Africa INIBAP doc. EA-001e. Montpellier. 98 pp + appendices.

Jagtap, S.S. 1993. Site selection using GIS for effective biological and integrated control of highland banana pests. In: Proceedings of a Research Coordination Meeting for Biological and Integrated Control of Highland Banana Pests and Diseases in Africa. Gold, C.S. and Gemmel, B. (Eds.), pp 25-36. Cotonou, 12-14 November, 1993.

Parish, O.H. 1969. Report on a tour of the banana exporting countries of The Caribbean and comments on The relevance of modern methods of banana production and research to the "Matoke" crop in Uganda. Report to the Rockefeller Foundation, Nairobi, Kenya. 17pp.

Sebasigari, K. and Stover, R.H. 1988. Banana Diseases and Pests in East Africa: Report of a survey in November 1987. INIBAP. Montpellier.

Sengooba, T. 1986. Survey of Banana Pest Problem Complex in Rakai and Masaka Districts, August 1986: Preliminary Trip Report. Uganda Ministry of Agriculture. Kawanda Research Station. 10pp.

Tothill, J.D. 1940. Agriculture in Uganda. Oxford University Press, Oxford. 546pp.

Uganda Ministry of Agriculture. 1992. Report on Ugandan National Census of Agriculture and Livestock (1990-1991). Entebbe, Uganda. 82 pp + 40 tables.

Wortmann, C.S., Bosch, C.H. and Mukandala, L. 1994. Foliar nutrient analyses in bananas grown in the Highlands of East Africa. Journal of Agronomy and Crop Science 172:223-226.

Copyright ©1999 The African Crop Science Society


The following images related to this document are available:

Line drawing images

[cs99017l.gif] [cs99017k.gif] [cs99017h.gif] [cs99017a.gif] [cs99017o.gif] [cs99017i.gif] [cs99017j.gif] [cs99017n.gif] [cs99017m.gif] [cs99017f.gif] [cs99017e.gif] [cs99017g.gif] [cs99017c.gif] [cs99017d.gif] [cs99017b.gif]
Home Faq Resources Email Bioline
© Bioline International, 1989 - 2024, Site last up-dated on 01-Sep-2022.
Site created and maintained by the Reference Center on Environmental Information, CRIA, Brazil
System hosted by the Google Cloud Platform, GCP, Brazil