|
Journal of Indian Association of Pediatric Surgeons
Medknow Publications on behalf of the Indian Association of Pediatric Surgeons
ISSN: 0971-9261 EISSN: 1998-3891
Vol. 10, Num. 3, 2005, pp. 198-198
|
Journal of Indian Association of Pediatric Surgeons, Vol. 10, No. 3, July-September, 2005, pp. 198
Book Review
Surgery of pediatric anorectal malformations
V. Bhatnagar
Department of Paediatric Surgery, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029. India
Code Number: ip05051
This new book published in 2005 is essentially an updated edition of
the previous book by the same author entitled ′Anorectal Malformations,′Oxford
University Press, 1993. Professor Subir Chatterjee is a pioneer of pediatric
surgery in India and a very well-known figure in the world of Pediatric
Surgeons both in India and abroad. This book is not only a record of
his personal experience but is also a reflection of his original thinking.
The initial chapters of this book are very well written. Chapter 1
deals with the evolution of the present day understanding of anorectal
malformations
in all its aspects. This chapter is a ′must read′for all
those practicing or wanting to practice this form of pediatric surgery.
The second chapter deals with the structure and function of the regional
structures. The controversy about the presence/absence of the puborectalis ′sling′has
still not been resolved, although the author does refer to fetal dissections.
However, the arguments are not very convincing in the absence of good photomicrographs;
line diagrams come across as very poor substitutes to support a controversial
subject.
Chapter 3 describes the classification, diagnosis, and imaging very
comprehensively. However, because the author has been part of a global
group on consensus
on anorectal malformations, it is surprising that instead of working within
the established classification and trying to put the regional (geographical)
peculiarities in appropriate places or as separate groups within it, the
author tries to be different. This may be perfectly correct, but it causes
confusion particularly in the minds of the less initiated.
The embryology has been described very clearly in chapter 4 and should
be used as a reference for the proper understanding of the etiopathogenesis
of these malformations.
Chapter 5 deals with the general principles of treatment (presumably
the author′s). The importance of colostomy in the treatment of anorectal
malformations justifies chapter 6 being exclusively devoted to it. The
finer points in the construction and management of colostomy and the spectrum
of complications should be a reference point for the learner and the learned
alike.
Chapters 7-15 record in detail the author′s experience and his personal
views on the nomenclature and approach to the diagnosis and treatment of
specific anorectal malformations referring simultaneously to similar/related
experience of others.
Chapter 16, which deals with results, is too brief and this is disappointing
in an era when there is greater emphasis on quality rather than the quantity
of life. More details on clinical scoring systems, anorectal manometry,
and urodynamics for the evaluation of associated neurovesical dysfunction
would have been very welcome. In a single author′s book, one would
have also expected to read a comprehensive postoperative evaluation of
the many hundreds of patients who have been the inspiration for this book.
On the whole, a book worth reading and possessing.
Bhatnagar V
Department of Paediatric Surgery, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi - 110 029, India
Correspondence Address:Department of Paediatric Surgery, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi - 110029, India
Copyright 2005 - Journal of Indian Association of Pediatric Surgeons
|