search
for
 About Bioline  All Journals  Testimonials  Membership  News


Journal of Applied Sciences and Environmental Management
World Bank assisted National Agricultural Research Project (NARP) - University of Port Harcourt
ISSN: 1119-8362
Vol. 10, Num. 1, 2006, pp. 15-23

Journal of Applied Sciences & Environmental Management, Vol. 10, No. 1, March, 2006, pp. 15-23

The effect of environmental parameters on contaminant uptake By a passive sampler device

1WANDAN,  E N.; 2KOPOIN ADOUBY; 1AKISSI CHANTAL

1Departement des Eaux, Forêts et Environnement, INP-HB BP 1313 Yamoussoukro
2Departement Génie Chimique et Agro-Alimentaire, INP-HB BP 1313 Yamoussoulro

Code Number: ja06003

ABSTRACT: A passive sampling device previously developed was used to assess environmental contamination. It consists of a polymeric bag filled with an organic solvent in which contaminants are preconcentrated after passively diffusing from the water column. The contents of the device were subjected to analysis without further cleanup. The effect of temperature, turbulence, ionic strength, pH, and the presence of dissolved organic material on the partioning process were examined. The results showed that increase in temperature supply the molecules with greater energy and enables them to pass through the membrane and into the solvent. Turbulence was found to disrupt the boundary layer formed around the device as a result of concentration polarization causing irregular fluctuations in the concentration of contaminants in equilibrium with the membrane. There was no discernable correlation between the concentration of contaminants accumulated by the devices and the ionic strength of the incubation solution. There was also no discernable relationship between pH and contaminants uptake by the sampling devices as was expected with non polar, non-ioniseable solutes. The uptake of compounds with lower molar volumes was most susceptible to the presence oh humic materials. @JASEM

Much surface water has been contaminated with organic pollutants. In Côte d’Ivoire, organochlorine pesticides including DDT, dieldrin, and lindane have been found in lagoons, rivers and lakes (Wandan and Zabik, 1996). The causes of these contaminations may include point sources, leachate from agricultural applications or industrial activities. Traditionally, the level of contamination have been assessed using fish, birds (Bedford and Zabik, 1973), benthic species (Bedford et Zabik, 1973), or zooplankton (Leversee, 1983) as biomonitors. These species accumulate contaminants to a concentration many thousand times greater than that found in the environment, thus enhancing detection (Corner, 1984). The analysis of mobile organisms such as fish and birds may provide an integrated sample of the quality of the entire ecosystem. The use of sessile species such as clams and mussels provides a time-integrated sample at one location. Still, several problems are associated with the use of these organisms as environmental monitors. Considerable time, expense and effort are spent collecting the organisms. The analysis of many individuals is essential due to the large degree of variation within the population. The interferences from endogenous biological material require that extensive cleanup techniques be used (Veith et al., 1975). To avoid the problems associated with biomonitors, direct water sampling has been employed to assess water quality. Substantial logistical and analytical problems are associated with obtaining representative water samples. The low concentration of the analyte often necessitates using preconcentration procedures or batch sampling to surpass detection limits. Data derived from batch sampling procedures may be of limited value because they represent the instantaneous concentration of the analyte at a single location (Hertz and Suffet, 1980). Thus, conventional water sampling techniques may have limited use in contaminant surveillance. On-site continuous extractors that provide time-integrated samples of large volumes of water have been used but background contamination of the adsorbent, system clogging, and limited application at remote sites due to the necessity of a power source to drive the sample and reagent pumps remain a problem.

Passive water sampling devices provide a more reliable alternative to the determination of water quality. These devices are easily deployed at remote sites as a power source is not required. Their lack of moving parts improves reliability. This technique is attractive because of its extreme simplicity; however, biofouling and a slow equilibrium rate between the polymer film and the water column limit its application as a long-term integrated sampler (Black et al., 1982). Analysis of the contents of the bags was simpler and the devices could be used where conventional biomonitors could not. Thus, passive water sampling devices display great potential as environmental monitors. This study is a series of experiments that was conducted to ascertain the effects of external parameters on the uptake efficiency of several contaminants into the polypropylene/2,2,4-trimethylpentane sampling devices. The parameters investigated included temperature, turbulence, ionic strength, pH and the presence of humic materials in the incubation system.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Materials

Glass miniature sampling devices have dimensions of 5.9 cm by 2.0 cm as illustrated by fig 1. Polymeric membranes (polypropylene) were fastened to the bottom of the miniature sampling devices with silicone glue. Ten ml of solvent (trimethylpentane) were added to the interior compartment. An 8 mm internal diameter septum sealed the top of the tube and allowed easy withdrawal of samples. The area of the membrane affixed to the bottom of the device was 0.603 cm2. The samplers were suspended from a polycarbonate lid using stoppers and were allowed to equilibrate for 13 days in the exposure systems (Fig 2). The flowing exposure system used for the exposure of the sampling device (Fig 2) consisted of 10-L glass tank. The system was stirred with a Tallboy’s stirrer. Two Beckman pumps, pumping at 1.5 ml/min., were used to pump the water solution into the incubation tank. A forma Scientifique model 2132 water bath was used to maintain constant temperature when needed.

Temperature: The temperature of the circulating water bath was varied from 15 to 25°C in increments of 5°. This range represented reasonable environmental temperatures. To establish the maximum time required to reach equilibrium at 15°C, contaminant concentrations in the polypropylene/2,2,4-trimethylpentane sampling devices were monitored at various time increments including 0.25, 0.5, l, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 days. For the studies at 20 and 25°C, the samplers were allowed to equilibrate with their surroundings for four days before their contents were analyzed. Quadruplet samples were analyzed as described below. Whenever the temperature of the circulating water bath was altered, the system was allowed to equilibrate at the increased temperature for 24 hours before the miniature sampling devices were added.

Turbulence: The turbulence was varied by altering the number of revolutions per minute (rpm) of a Talboy's model 101 stirrer from 0, 30, 45, to 60 rpm. The temperature was maintained at 20°C for all turbulence studies. Sampling devices were allowed to equilibrate for four days before the samples were taken.

Ionic strength: A 3.765 M solution of sodium chloride was prepared and added to the pesticide incubation mixtures in the following quantities: 10 ml, 100 ml, and 1,000 ml. Distilled water was added to maintain a constant volume of 37 L. The calculated ionic strengths were 1.017 x 10-1, 1.017 x 10-2 and 1.017 x 10-3, respectively. The solutions were allowed to attain 20°C before being added to the incubation chamber. The stirring rate was maintained at 30 rpm. The sampling devices were allowed to equilibrate for four days before the samples were taken.

pH: Solutions of HCl, NaCl and NaOH were made in a concentration of 0.1 M. The pH of the incubation solutions was adjusted to 6.37, 7.26, and 8.48 by the addition of either HCl or NaOH. NaCl was added to maintain constant ionic strength. The solution was filtered through a glass microfiber membrane, bottled and stored at 5°C. The remainder of the procedure was performed as previously described. The pH after the experiment was 5.80, 6.66, and 7.58.

Humic materials: Water containing humic materials was collected from the lakes of Kossou and Ayamé and the Comoé River near the city of Ono (Côte d’Ivoire). All the water was stored at 5°C. Three batches of solution were prepared, each with a total volume of 27L. Each contained water from three water bodies. Ten litre of distilled water were added to achieve sufficient volume in the incubation system. The water was spiked with the organochlorine compounds and the pH was adjusted to 6.25, 7.80 and 8.48. Sodium chloride was added to maintain a constant ionic strength. The water was filtered to remove any precipitating humic materials, bottled and stored at 5°C. The remainder of the procedure was performed as previously outlined.

ANALYSIS: Pesticides accumulated by the passive sampling devices were analyzed using a Perkin-Elmer 8500 gas chromatograph containing an open tubular column (0.25 mm i.d., 60 m length) with DB-1 stationary phase (J & W  Scientific, Folsom, CA) and an electron capture detector. No clean up or preconcentration techniques were performed on any of the samples.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Temperature: Increases in temperature enhance contaminant uptake by the sampler. As illustrated in fig 3, there is a linear relationship between the equilibrium concentration in the sampling devices and temperature. Table 10 summarizes linear regression of these data. The correlation coefficient (r) is greater than 0.99 for all the compounds studied except DDE.

Table 1: Linear Regression Data for the Relationship the Equilibrium Concentrations of Organochlorine Compounds and Temperature

Composé

b

m

r

Lindane

41,70

2,0

0,9983

Aldrine

57,70

2,9

0,9904

Dieldrine

-57,0

6,1

0,9901

DDE

29,0

0,8

0,7559

Methoxychlor

1,30

6,8

0,9930

When we compare the slopes of these lines with the inverse of the LeBas molar volume as shown in fig 4, it is apparent that as temperature is increased, larger molecules exhibit a greater change in mobility. Larger molecules may face greater restrictions negotiating passage through the membrane material. The added energy allows them to initiate greater flexibility in the membrane. Lindane is the only molecule not following this trend and is also the only monocyclic compound in this study. Increases in temperature supply the molecules with greater energy and enables them to pass through the membrane and into the solvent..

Turbulence: Fig 5 illustrates the rise in the contaminant concentration as the stirring rate is increased. The marked upswing in contaminant accumulation after approximately 45 rpm suggests that there is sufficient turbulence to disrupt the boundary layer formed as a result of concentration polarization. This could pose a problem in environmental studies; wave action may cause irregular fluctuations in the concentration of contaminants in equilibrium with the membrane.

Ionic strength: Fig 6 shows that there was no discernible correlation between the concentration of organochlorine compounds accumulated by the devices and the ionic strength of the incubation solution. Increases in the ionic strength in the aqueous phase should enhance contaminant uptake because of the increased chemical potential in the water. An increased transfer of tetrachlorobiphenyl from the aqueous to vapor phase was observed as salinity was increased (Jota, 1984). Similarly it was found that the addition of electrolytes to an aqueous solution decreased the solubility of nonpolar compounds (Tulp et al., 1978). However, when a polycarbonate film was used, no differences between solute transfer in the control sample and one with an elevated ionic strength (8 x 10-3.M NaCl) were noted. Therefore, the sampling devices may prove useful in geochemical applications, especially those that involve monitoring hydrocarbon residues in brine solutions.

Figure 6 show that there was no discernible correlation between the concentration of organochlorine compounds accumulated by the devices and the ionic strength of the incubation solution. Increases in the ionic strength in the aqueous phase should enhance contaminant uptake because of the increased chemical potential in the water. An increased transfer of tetrachlorobiphenyl from the aqueous to vapor phase was observed as salinity was increased (Jota, 1984). Similarly it was found that the addition of electrolytes to an aqueous solution decreased the solubility of nonpolar compounds (Tulp et al., 1978). However, when a  polycarbonate film was used, no differences between solute transfer in the control sample and one with an elevated ionic strength (8 x 10-3.M NaCl) were noted. Therefore, the sampling devices may prove useful in geochemical applications, especially those that involve monitoring hydrocarbon residues in brine solutions.

pH. There is no discernible relationship, but this is to be expected with non polar, non- ionizeable solutes.  Blanchard and Hardy also performed experiments to examine the effect altering the pH from 3.0 to 8.0 has on the membrane penetration by solutes, and found no relationship. This study was necessary to provide blank samples for the humics experiment.

Humic Materials:  The pigmentation of natural waters is caused by a class of dissolved substances, called humics, which are by-products of plant decomposition. Their precise chemical structure is unknown, but it has been estimated that 20-30% of the carbon atoms in humic materials are aromatic. The skeleton of humic materials consists largely of hydrocarbon molecules, but carboxyl, phenolic and methoxy functional groups are also present. Nitrogen atoms also may exist in the molecules (1-2%). The molecular weight of humic materials ranges from 800 to 250,000 g/mole (Beckett et al., 1987). Humic substances play a role in the transport and fate of xenobiotics in the environment. These substances also interact with nonpolar organic compounds such as petroleum hydrocarbons, 2,4,5-T, benzo(a)pyrene, phenanthrene, anthracene, DDT, phthalate esters and alkanes decreasing their bioavailability (Beckettet al., 1987 ; Wershaw et al., 1979 ; Hasset and Anderson, 1979 ; Anderson, 1982 ; Leversee et al., 1983).

Fig 8 illustrates the uptake of contaminants by propylene/2,2,4-trimethylpentane miniature sampling devices that were exposed to a humic-laden incubation solution as a function of pH. There is no clear relationship between alterations in pH and contaminant uptake by the sampling devices. These results were compared to the concentration of organochlorine compounds accumulated by the devices when humic materials are absent from the incubating chamber in figures 9, 10, 11,12.

At neutral pH, the uptake of lindane and dieldrin was markedly decreased by the presence of humic materials, while the accumulation of methoxychlor remained the same. The partitioning of remaining compounds, aIdrin and DDE into the miniature sampling devices was slightly decreased. At this pH, some binding to humic acid should be occurring. The marked decrease in uptake of lindane by the sampling devices may be due to a size or shape specific interaction as lindane is the only mono-cyclic compound studied and has lowest molar volume. Dieldrin may be interacting with the humic materials via the epoxy oxygen atom.

At a pH of 8, the elevated levels of humic and fulvic materials decreased contaminant levels in the sampling devices. The most pronounced reduction in solute accumulation was observed for lindane. The binding of this compound to humic and fulvic substances may be enhanced due to its reduced molar volume. Likewise, lindane and methoxychlor exhibited the least marked change in uptake by the devices and have the largest molar volumes. The remaining compounds that have similar molar volumes showed similar changes in uptake.

At a pH of 6, the greatest decreases in uptake occurred for aldrin and dieldrin. This suggests that the shape of these molecules is more compatible with binding to fulvic acid.  Lindane uptake into the devices is also markedly limited and may be due to a size specific interaction with fulvic acids. Blanchard and Hardy (1986) added AldrichR humic acid to their solution at a concentration of 2500 ppm and found no change in membrane passage.

These results may be due to differences between naturally occurring humics and those purchased from Aldrich. Other studies found that as the pH was decreased, humic acids became more hydrophobic and the cationic sites were no longer charged. There was an increase of binding to hydrophobic compounds which resulted in a limiting transfer from the aqueous Phase (Jota, 1984; Carter and Suffet,1982).  The uptake of compounds with the lower molar volumes is most susceptible to the presence of humic materials, this is due to the humic and fulvic micellular site and the contaminants' ability to enter the hydrophobic centre of the micelle.

Conclusion: Uptake of organochlorine compounds by the water sampling devices is influenced by temperature, turbulence, and the presence of humic materials. Ionic strength and pH did not affect this partitioning process.

Larger molecules were most affected by increases in temperature; the added energy enhancing membrane passage. Although increases in temperature promote contaminant accumulation, the temperature in large bodies of water does not change rapidly over the course of a biomonitoring experiment. Therefore, contaminant uptake in field studies should not be greatly affected by temperature changes. Turbulence-limited concentration polarization and enhanced contaminant accumulation. Although, turbulence experienced in natural waters is to have a similar effect on the sampling devices, biomonitors are also susceptible. Exposure to humic materials decreased contaminant uptake in the devices as with biomonitors. Further studies should investigate the impact of these environmental parameters in field applications.

REFERENCES
  • Beckett, R; Jue, Z; Giddings, J.C (1987). Distributions of Fulvic and Humic Acids Using Flow Field-Flow Fractionation. Environ. Sci. Technol., 21, 289-295. 
  • Bedford, J.W; Roelofs, E.W; Zabik, MJ (1968). The freshwater mussel as a biological monitor of pesticide concentration in a lotic environment. Limn. Ocean., v.13 : 118-126.
  • Bedford, J.W; Zabik, M..J (1973). Bioactive compounds in the aquatic environment: uptake and loss of DDT and dieldrin by freshwater mussles. Arch. Environ. Contam. And Toxicol. 1(2), 97-111 
  • Blanchard, R; Hardy, J.K (1986). Automated Permeation Sampler for Volatile Priority Pollutants. Anal. Chem., 58, 1529.
  • Carter, C.W; Suffet, I.H (1982). Binding of DDT to dissolved humic materials. Environ. Sci. Technol., 16, 735-740.
  • Hassett, J.P; Anderson, M.A (1982). Effect of Dissolved Organic Matter on Adsorption of Hydrophobic Organic Cpmpound by River and Sewage Borne Particulate Matter. Water Res., 16, 681-686.
  • Hassett, J.P; Anderson, M.A (1979). Effect of Dissolved Organic Matter on Adsorption of hydrophobic Organic Compound by River and Sewage Borne Particulate Matter. Environ. Sci. Technol., 13, 1526-1529.
  • Hertz, C.D; Suffet, I.H (1980). “Detection of Organic Carcinogen in Drinking Water: A Review of Concentratio/Isolation Methods” in Organic Carcinogens in Drinking Water Detection, Treatment, and Risk Assessment. RAM, Calabrese and Christman eds., Willey and Sons: New York, 95-130
  • Jota, M.A.T (1984). Effects of Environemental Parameters on the binding interaction Between Tetrachlorobiphenyl and dissolved Humic Materials. M.S. Thesis, S.U.NY. College of Environemental Science and Forestry, Syracuse, NY.
  • Leversee, G.J; Landrum, P.F; Giesy, J.P; Fannin, T, (1983). Humic Acids Reduce Bioaccumulation of Some Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci.,  40 (Suppl. 2), 63-69.
  • Tulp, M.Th; Schmitz, M.R; Hutzinger, O (1978). The bacterial metabolism of 4,4'-dichlorobiphenyl, and its suppression by alternative carbon source. Chemosphère, 10, 849-860.
  • Veith, G.D; Kuehl, D.W; Rosenthal, J (1975). Preparative method for gas chromatographic/mass spectral analysis of trace quantities of pesticides in fish tissue. J. Assoc Off Anal Chem. Jan;58(1):1-5
  • Wershaw, R.L; Burcar, P; Goldberg, M.C, (1969). Interaction of Pesticides with Natural Organic Material. Environ. Sci. Technol. 3:271-273.
  • Wandan, E.N; Zabik, M.J (1996). Assessment of the contamination of surface water and fish from Côte d’Ivoire. J. Environ. Sci Health, B31(2), 225-240.

Copyright 2006 - Journal of Applied Sciences & Environmental Management


The following images related to this document are available:

Photo images

[ja06003f5.jpg] [ja06003f11.jpg] [ja06003f9.jpg] [ja06003f6.jpg] [ja06003f3.jpg] [ja06003f10.jpg] [ja06003f7.jpg] [ja06003f1.jpg] [ja06003f2.jpg] [ja06003f4.jpg] [ja06003f8.jpg]
Home Faq Resources Email Bioline
© Bioline International, 1989 - 2024, Site last up-dated on 01-Sep-2022.
Site created and maintained by the Reference Center on Environmental Information, CRIA, Brazil
System hosted by the Google Cloud Platform, GCP, Brazil