|
Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology, Vol. 23, No. 3, July-September, 2005, pp. 182-185 Brief Communications Sunflower seed husk agar: A new medium for the differentiation of Candida dubliniensis from Candida albicans Khan Z.U., Ahmad S., Mokaddas E., Al-Sweih N., Chandy R. Department of Microbiology, Faculty of Medicine, Kuwait University, PO Box 24923, 13110 Date of Submission: 19-Nov-2004 Code Number: mb05053 ABSTRACT A sunflower ( Helianthus annuus ) seed husk agar medium has been developed and evaluated for differentiation of Candida dubliniensis from Candida albicans on the basis of colony morphology and chlamydospore production. All C. dubliniensis isolates (n=40) produced rough colonies with hyphal fringes and abundant chlamydospores whereas 101 of 105 (96.2%) C. albicans isolates produced smooth colonies with no evidence of chlamydospore production. Since this medium is free from oil droplets, chlamydospores can be examined with greater clarity by Dalmau plate technique. This medium provides a simple and cost-effective tool for the presumptive differentiation of C. dubliniensis from C. albicans and is particularly suited for clinical microbiology laboratories where biochemical or molecular methods for the differentiation of these two species are not available.Keywords: Sunflower, C. dubliniensis, C. albicans, rough colonies, chlamydospores Candida dubliniensis is a newly described species of yeast and is phylogenetically closely related to Candida albicans .[1], [2] Although initially implicated in oral candidiasis in HIV-infected and AIDS patients, it is capable of causing a variety of clinical conditions including vaginal and bloodstream infections.[3],[4] Since C. dubliniensis and C. albicans have phenotypic similarities, such as ability to form germ tubes and chlamydospores, their differentiation in routine clinical microbiology laboratories is problematic and may lead to misidentification.[5] During the last five years several tests based on phenotypic characteristics have been developed to distinguish these two species. [6],[7],[8],[9],[10],[11] In 1999, Staib and Morschausser[6] extended the diagnostic usefulness of Staib′s bird seed ( Guizotia abyssinica ) agar,[12] originally used as a differential medium for Cryptococcus neoformans , to distinguish C. dubliniensis from C. albicans . Candida dubliniensis isolates formed rough colonies with abundant chlamydospores on this medium, whereas C. albicans isolates formed smooth colonies with no chlamydospore production. These observations were subsequently confirmed by Al-Mosaid et al.[7] and Lees and Barton.[8] Recently, sunflower (Helianthus annuus) seed agar has also been found useful for distinguishing C. dubliniensis from C. albicans on the basis of similar morphologic characteristics as have been observed on niger seed agar. [9],[10],[11] In this communication, we report that husk of sunflower seeds can be used as a substitute for whole seeds in the medium without compromising its efficacy.
MATERIALS AND METHODS RESULTS The observations on colonial morphology and chlamydospore formation by C. dubliniensis and C. albicans on SSH agar and CM-T agar are presented in the [Table - 1] and depicted in [Figure - 1], [Figure - 2], [Figure - 3]. Dalmau plate cultures of all the 40 C. dubliniensis isolates including two reference strains produced rough colonies with hyphal fringes and abundant chlamydospores on SSH agar after 24 to 48 hours of incubation at 28º C. In contrast, 101 (96.2%) C. albicans isolates including three reference strains produced smooth colonies with no evidence of chlamydospore formation on this medium. Of the four isolates which showed fringed colonies, only two produced scanty chlamydospores. The results were reproducible when the experiment was repeated. On CM-T agar, all the C. dubliniensis isolates and C. albicans isolates produced smooth colonies and chlamydospores, and no discernible differences were observed in the colony morphology of the two species .DISCUSSION The phenotypic characteristics of C. albicans to form chlamydospores and germ tubes have long been used to differentiate it from other Candida species. However, with the recognition of C. dubliniensis as a separate species,[2],[3] which like C. albicans produces chlamydospores and germ tubes, several investigators have focused attention to develop simple and inexpensive methods for discriminating these two species in routine clinical microbiology laboratories. The tests that have been reported to be useful for this purpose include production of rough colonies and chlamydospores on Staib agar,[6],[7],[8] development of dark green colonies on CHROMagar Candida, [2],[16] inability to grow at 45 °C, [17] and in 6.5% sodium chloride[18] by C. dubliniensis isolates. Recently, several commercial yeast identification systems based on carbohydrate assimilation profiles have also become available for the identification of C. dubliniensis.[3],[4] In an extensive evaluation of commercial yeast identification systems which included API 20C AUX, ID 32 C, RapID yeast plus, Vitek YBC, and Vitek 2 ID YST, Pincus et al.[19] reported that assimilation of a-methyl-D-glucoside, trehalose, and D-xylose could be used for the differentiation of C. dubliniensis . However, the assimilation results were not consistent with different commercial assimilation systems used and varied with the incubation period.[19],[20]Several investigators have reported that C. dubliniensis isolates have the ability to produce chlamydospores more readily and abundantly than C. albicans on rice agar-Tween, Tween 80-oxgall-caffeic acid agar or cornmeal-Tween 80 agar[2], [3] and this morphologic characteristic could be used for differentiating the two species. However, identification of C. dubliniensis on the basis of abundance of chlamydospores or other phenotypic features have not been shown to be reproducible in some laboratories.[16] Moreover, assessment of relative abundance of chlamydospores is quite subjective in judgment, hence this feature alone may not serve as a dependable criterion for differentiation of C. dubliniensis from C. albicans . Recently, Staib and Morschhauser[6] reported that C. dubliniensis on Staib′s G. abyssinca seed agar[12] under appropriate growth conditions forms rough colonies due to mycelial growth and abundant chlamydospores which may be used as a species-specific marker for identification of this species. In an extended evaluation of this medium, Al-Mosaid et al[7] found that 85.4% of the C. dubliniensis isolates (n = 130) while none of the C. albicans isolates (n = 166) produced chlamydospores on this medium. In contrast, while all the isolates of C. albicans produced smooth colonies, as many as 97.7% isolates of C. dubliniensis formed rough colonies. The authors concluded that morphological discrimination between the two species is best achieved on the basis of colony morphology rather than chlamydospore production. In a more recent study, Adou-Bryn et al[9] using a modified sunflower seed agar observed that all the 60 C. dubliniensis isolates produced rough colonies, whereas all the 47 C. albicans isolates produced smooth colonies. Efficacy of sunflower seed agar was subsequently confirmed by Al-Mosaid et al[10] and Khan et al.[11] In conclusion, production of rough colonies and abundant chlamydospores by all the 40 isolates of C. dubliniensis , and of smooth colonies with lack of chlamydospores by over 96% isolates of C. albicans , suggests that SSH agar has a value in the presumptive differentiation of these two clinically important species. The low production cost, wider availability of the ingredients and simple composition make SSH medium ideally suited for routine use in clinical microbiology laboratories. Since the medium is free from oil droplets, it provides a clearer view of chlamydospores during microscopic examination, a problem that could be encountered with media prepared from the whole seeds. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Supported by Kuwait University Research Administration grant MI 118.REFERENCES
Copyright 2005 - Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology The following images related to this document are available:Photo images[mb05053t1.jpg] [mb05053f3.jpg] [mb05053f2.jpg] [mb05053f1.jpg] [mb05053f4.jpg] |
|