|
Neurology India
Medknow Publications on behalf of the Neurological Society of India
ISSN: 0028-3886 EISSN: 1998-4022
Vol. 52, Num. 2, 2004, pp. 213-214
|
Neurology India, Vol. 52, No. 2, April-June, 2004, pp. 213-214
Some observations on the spectrum of dementia
Sanjeev Jha, R. Patel
Department of Neurology, SGPGIMS, Lucknow, India.
Correspondence Address:
Associate Professor, Neurology Department, SGPGI, Lucknow, India
sjha@sgpgi.ac.in
Code Number: ni04065
Abstract
A study was designed to generate epidemiological and clinical data on
dementia, in a teaching hospital in India. It was conducted on 124 (94
male and 30 female) elderly patients (aged more than 60 years) presenting
with clinical syndrome of dementia (DSM-3). Their age range was 64-78
(mean 65.7 4.1) years. Detailed clinical, biochemical, radiological and
electrophysiological evaluation was done to establish etiology. Patients
with psychiatric ailments, cranial trauma and tumors were excluded. The
study period was 4.2 years. Multi-infarct dementia (MID) was observed
to be commonest cause of dementia and was present in 59 (47.6%) cases.
There were 10 (8%) patients each of tuberculosis (TB) and neurocysticercosis
(NCC). Alcohol-related dementia was present in 13 (10.5%), while malnutrition
(Vitamin B12 deficiency) was present in 9 (7.2%). Alzheimer's Disease
(AD) was present (NINCDS-ADRDA criteria) in 6 patients (4.8%). There
were 3 (2.4%) cases 1 each of Huntington's disease, Parkinson's and Normal
Pressure Hydrocephalus and 2 each of diabetes, hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism
and Creutzfeldt' Jakob Disease. We conclude that AD, which is irreversible
and common in the west, is relatively uncommon in India as compared to
MID, infections and malnutrition, which are potentially treatable.
Introduction
Dementia in the elderly is an important, common disabling problem seen
worldwide. It is a clinical state in which acquired cognitive decline
impairs occupational and social life. There is a paucity of epidemiological
data about dementia in India, where it is ignored and dismissed as senility.
It is important to define and identify the treatable causes since it
can initiate the process of the patient's (and his family's) adaptation
to managing the disease symptoms.[1] This study was designed to assess
the spectrum of dementia, which may be beneficial in therapeutic planning.
Material and Method
The study was conducted on 124 (94 male and 30 female) elderly patients
treated in our Institute. These patients presented with a clinical syndrome
of dementia (DSM-3) viz.: impaired memory, abstract thinking, judgment,
language-praxis, visuospatial attention. AD was diagnosed as per the
NINCDS-ADRDA criteria.[2] The diagnosis essentially included exclusion
of all known causes of dementia on the basis of clinical evaluation and
cranial imaging (CT/MRI). Neurosurgical and psychiatric patients were
excluded. Their age range was 64-78 years (mean 65.7 ± 4.1yrs).
After clinical and neurological examination, psychometry and cognitive
assessment was performed (by a clinical psychologist) using modified
WAIS. The modification was done according to the Indian population, and
it consisted of test of attention, orientation, calculation, fund of
knowledge, judgment and abstract thinking. For visuospatial analysis,
Bender Gestalt Test (BGT) cards were used. Biochemical (hematological,
hepatorenal and endocrinal functions); neuroradiological (CT and MRI
studies of cranium) and electrophysiological (EEG, NCV, EMG and evoked
potential) evaluations were done to establish etiology. Special investigations
like bone marrow, ultrasound, Elisa for TB and NCC, CSF manometry for
NPH and immuno cytochemistry were done whenever required. The study period
was 4.2 years.
Results
MID was present in 59 (47.6%) cases while AD was present in only 6 (4.8%).
There were 10 (8%) patients each of TB and NCC. Alcohol-related dementia
was present in 13 (10.5%). Malnutrition and sub-acute combined degeneration
was documented in 9 (7.2%). There were 3 cases (2.4%) each of Huntington's,
Parkinson's and Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus. Metabolic etiology was
identified in 6 (4.8%) patients, 2 each of diabetes, myxedema and thyrotoxicosis.
Two patients were diagnosed as Creutzfeldt's Jakob Disease (clinical
triad of dementia, myoclonus and classical EEG).
Discussion
Diagnostic appraisal of dementia needs an optimistic approach for the
benefit of the physician and the patient. With the advancement of new
diagnostic tools it is easy to classify dementia into definite clinico-pathological
groups. Epidemiological data about dementia appear conflicting as till
the 80's MID was reported to be more prevalent than AD in Japan, Korea
and China but in the 90's AD was documented as being twice as common
as MID in these very countries.[3] AD has been consistently reported
to be the commonest type of dementia by American and European studies.
We observed that AD, which is irreversible and common in the west,
is uncommon in India. Similarly, prevalence of AD in Nigeria has also
been
observed as low.[3] Initially, it was attributed to poor suspicion,
but in spite of adopting the NINCDS-ADRDA criteria,[2] we observed that
about
75% patients in our study had a potentially treatable etiology or in
whom progress of dementia could be halted. MID, infections, poorly
distilled country-made liquor were other common yet treatable causes
and so was
nutritional dementia.
Most of the Indian studies have also reported MID to be more prevalent.
In the first epidemiological study from the Indian subcontinent, the
incidence of AD was reported to be amongst the lowest possible.[4]
Explanations forwarded by the authors were short duration of follow-up,
cultural factors
and other potential confounders. In a similar study in rural northern
India an overall prevalence of AD has been described as very low (0.62%
in the population over 55 years and 1.07% in those aged 65 and above).
Of course this prevalence increased with age. Explanations postulated
were low overall life expectancy, short survival with this disease
and low age-specific incidence, potentially due to differences in the
underlying
distribution of risk and protective factors as compared with populations
with higher prevalence.[5]
A community-based study in a rural population in Kerala reported 58%
of patients with MID compared to 41% with AD. There were more women
and positive family history was prominent in the AD group. Smoking and
uncontrolled
hypertension was associated with MID.[6] A few Indian studies are also
contradictory, with AD being suggested to be more prevalent than MID.[3]
Interestingly, in another report from India the prevalence of dementia
was observed to be higher in the rural population as compared to the
urban settings.[7]
There is a difference in the incidence and prevalence of AD between underdeveloped
and developed countries. Many interesting reasons have been cited. The
widespread use of pesticides and the type of smoking has been directly
correlated with MID, which is more prevalent in India. Another reason
forwarded is the widespread use of electric lighting. Exposure to bright
light suppresses the secretion of melatonin, a free radical scavenger,
which inhibits progressive formation of beta sheets and beta amyloid
fibrils. Its production is further reduced with aging, thus increasing
susceptibility to age-related diseases like AD.[8]
References
- Marin DB, Sewll MC, Schlechter A. Alzheimer's disease; accurate and
early diagnosis in the primary care setting. Geriatrics 2002;57:36-40.
- McKhann G, Drachman D, Folstein M. Clinical diagnosis of Alzheimers'
disease; report of the NINCDS-ADRDA Work Group. Neurology 1984:34;939-44.
- Suh GH, Shah A. A review of the epidemiological transition in
dementia, cross-national comparison of the indices related to Alzheimer's
disease
and vascular dementia. Acta Psychiatr. Scand 2001;104:4-11.
- Chandra V, Pandav R, Dodge HH, Johnston J, Belle S, DeKosky
ST, et al. Incidence of Alzheimer's disease in rural community
in India.
Neurology
2001;25,57:985-9.
- Chandra V, Ganguli M, Pandav R, Johnston J, Belle S, DeKosky
ST. Prevalence of Alzheimer's disease and other dementias in
rural India.
Neurology
1998;51:1000-8. [PUBMED]
- Shaji S, Promodu K, Abraham T, Roy KJ, Verghese A, An epidemiological
study of dementia in a rural community in Kerala, India.
Br J Psychiatry 1996;168:745-9.
- Rajkumar S, Kumar S, and Thara R. Prevalence of dementia
in a rural setting: A report from India. Int J Geriatr
Psychiatry 1997;12:702-7.
- Brenner S. Prevalance of AD and other dementias in rural
India. Neurology 1998;51:1000-8.
Copyright 2004 - Neurology India
|