The Agbiotech Bulletin
Volume 4 Issue 10 October1996
Published by AG-WEST BIOTECH INC.
Current Issues in Intellectual Property Rights
Changes in the way new crop innovations and varieties are
being generated have transformed the agricultural sector's
understanding of intellectual property rights (IPR).
Traditionally, most new innovations and varieties have come
from the public sector which, in the main, has been financed
through public tax dollars. Understandably, these innovations
have largely been viewed as public property. Today, however,
cost cutting by government has reduced tax dollars available
for crop development, while the private sector has become much
more involved in introducing crop innovations, particularly
for oilseeds and legumes.
A great deal of money is required to carry out crop
innovations. Although biotechnology offers a wide area of new
opportunities to develop crops with desirable agronomic and
quality characteristics, it adds additional costs to the
process. Innovation is also time consuming: new
introductions take an average of six years from inception to
commercialization.
Ongoing research investment is needed to ensure a flow of crop
innovations. In the current economic climate, research money
for either public or private research must come from the
marketplace. The marketplace increasingly generates this
money through the recognition that intellectual costs involved
in research and development impart intellectual property
rights to innovators. Intellectual property rights in
agriculture are recognized through such mechanisms as patents
or Plant Breeders Rights (PBR), with research money coming
increasingly form royalties on the use of intellectual
property included in the price for the new crop seed carrying
the innovations.
Farmers and Intellectual Property Rights
The growing importance of IPR will have considerable impact on
the way seed is distributed within the farm sector, according
to Robert Morgan, President of the Canadian Seed Trade
Association and Manager of Research and Development with the
Saskatchewan Wheat Pool. To understand this impact, one must
know how seed "ownership" has traditionally been viewed by
farmers.
"Traditionally, as new varieties come into the marketplace
some farmers will buy certified seed from their local seed
grower or farm supply outlet. From the subsequent harvest,
some seed will be held back for next year's planting. While
this is legitimate, some growers will also sell some of this
bin seed to their neighbours who may have seen the crop in the
field and would like to try this new variety themselves
without paying the additional cost of certified seed. In the
trade this practice is known as brown bagging which is
illegal under the Canadian Seeds Act, if the seed is sold by
variety name. Only certified seed can be sold by variety
name."
Morgan says estimates indicate that over 90 per cent of
the cereal seed and 20 per cent of the canola seed planted in
Western Canada is bin run seed. The seed industry knows a
good portion of this comes through brown bag sales.
Over the years, the seed industry (which includes seed
growers, seed companies, Agriculture Canada, and universities)
have used various communication/education programs to outline
the benefits of certified seed. At the same time, Agriculture
Canada's regulatory personnel have monitored advertised seed
sales to insure that violations under the Seeds Act are
corrected. Most of these violations have been dealt with in
an "informative rather than prosecutive fashion," says
Morgan.
"There also has been the perception that once certified seed
was purchased, the growers had ownership and could do with it
what they pleased, including replanting from harvest and
selling to neighbors."
While seed certification has also provided a form of property
rights in the seed industry, the new realities of market
driven crop research and development have broadened the scope
of IPR in the seed trade. There is new attention to the
importance of informing farmers about intellectual property
and of enforcing property rights.
IPR and Plants: A Special Case
IPR are rights in law provided in recognition of a
contribution that has monetary value directly or indirectly in
the marketplace. To be eligible for such rights (which
provide exclusive ownership for up to 21 years), an invention
must meet specified criteria that clearly differentiate it
from previous inventions. In addition, it must come "by the
human hand". A well-recognized form of intellectual
protection is the patent.
"Much of the success and standard of living we enjoy in the
industrial world is predicated on innovation," says
Morgan. "To insure that there is a continued flow of
such innovation, there has to be an incentive (normally
monetary) and some assurance that there is recognition of the
rights to the innovator to collect this incentive. In
essence, the patent system was set up to do this. Legal
protection from copying of the innovation is provided for a
period of time (now about 20 years) in exchange for a
disclosure of the details of the innovation. Disclosure
facilitates further enhancements of the innovation through the
work of others."
The monetary incentive often comes through a royalty contained
within the price of the product. Therefore every time a new
product is sold, the innovator receives a royalty. If anyone
else wants to develop such a product, they must either
negotiate a licensing arrangement with the innovator or
develop a totally new product/process which is not in
violation of the original patent.
This process works well for material goods where only the
first sale of a product involves a royalty. Living organisms,
on the other hand, replicate themselves, and this presents a
challenge for innovators in the area of seed development.
Over the past few years, farmers have been exposed to a number
of forms of "innovation protection".
Plant Breeders' Rights were put in place by the Federal
Government over five years ago. This legislation recognizes
the ownership of a variety by the developer. In essence, it
provides 17 years of protection for a variety which exhibits
distinctiveness, uniformity, and stability. The breeder
negotiates a royalty with the marketer of the seed, who is
designated by the breeder. Protected seed cannot be legally
sold outside of this system.
Canada is part of a worldwide system which recognizes in law
and through reciprocity these rights. For instance, an
American variety protected under the US version of PBR is
protected in Canada by the collection of royalties on
certified seed sold in Canada. The US provides protection for
Canadian varieties covered by PBR and sold in the US.
Under this enhanced IPR regime, "brown bagging" now has the
implication of violation of the Seeds Act and Plant Breeders'
Rights. There is an exemption in these rights for a farmer to
save seed for his own plant back, but not for resale.
Plant Breeders' Rights protect the whole plant and the rights
are granted to the breeder. If the breeder includes via
biotech some genetic material which imparts some desirable
property and which does not naturally occur in the plant type,
then the protection of that material may also be carried out
separately through a patent. (To date, however, whole plants
can not be patented in Canada as is the case in the USA and
Japan.) A patent is much more restrictive than other forms of
IPR in that every time a seed containing a patented gene(s) is
to be used for planting, a royalty has to be paid to the
developer because its properties provide a benefit to the user
and the properties are no different than the original seed.
Genetic transformation requires significant effort and
resources in itself. Also, the genetic material has to be
incorporated into an agronomically satisfactory variety which
also has market acceptance. In addition, all this has to meet
additional regulatory approval beyond the variety registration
process. Currently, the worldwide seed industry is working to
develop a method to protect these investments so that they can
continue to bring new products to market. This is not only a
concern for privately-funded organizations such as the
Saskatchewan Wheat Pool. Declining funding for public
research institutions also means that royalty income is more
critical and protection of the seed innovation in the
marketplace with subsequent royalty return is a higher
priority.
Enforcing Intellectual Property Rights
Prosecutions of violators of Plant Breeders' Rights and plant
patents have only taken place to a limited extent since no one
really likes taking a customer to court.
Companies which have a significant technological investment at
stake have been exploring various means in the development and
marketing of their seed to restrict use of its progeny for
plant back or illegal sale. Hybrid seed is the answer for a
number of crops, but even there, "gene theft" can occur unless
vigilant action is taken. Another means of protection is a
licensing/contractual arrangement whereby the grower agrees to
deliver all seed and not hold any back for planting. In
essence, the grower is licensed to grow the seed and reap the
rewards of the harvest, but does not own or have any rights as
to further use other than planting in the season of sale.
"Over the next few years we will see more activity by seed
developers in the public and private sectors in trying to find
ways to protect their rights," says Robert Morgan.
"They will use a number of avenues and combinations of
approaches. I expect that most will refrain from using "hard"
tactics unless their requests for compliance are repeatedly
ignored, in which case, ultimately, litigation could be
used."
Morgan says that some of the tools that have been tried
include: information/education programs on what IPR are;
monitoring of potential violations; follow-up on violations;
requests for compliance; and following up more strongly for
repeat violation.
The application of IPR to seed (and seed components) is a
global phenomenon and is being led by private seed developers
large and small. Farmers must be prepared to recognize the
investment made by the developer by recognizing the monetary
obligation that they have in supporting further research.
"Farmers receive the value of this development every time they
plant the seed," says Morgan. "The developer should also be
recognized and appreciated."
This feature is adapted from an article for Production
Perspectives by Robert Morgan. Contact: Saskatchewan Wheat
Pool, 103 - 111 Research Drive, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan S7N
3R2. Phone 306/668-6630; fax 306/668-6654.
News
Seed Oil Modification Results in Quantity Increase
Experiments at the NRC Plant Biotechnology Institute in
Saskatoon which were designed to modify oil composition in
canola produced some "remarkable and unexpected" results when
they unintentionally increased the oil content of the canola
seeds by up 25 per cent.
The experiments were intended to increase the seed oil erucic
acid content by expressing a yeast transfer gene in
Brassica cultivars. While this occurred, the amount of
seed oil in the transformed plants also increased
substantially.
While oil composition has been previously altered by genetic
engineering, this is the first time that oil content has been
increased in transgenic plants. The researchers involved in
the experiments now believe that there is a high possibility
that oil content can also be increased in other commercial
oilseed crops, such as corn, flax, sunflower and soybean.
This item adapted from the NRC's PBI Bulletin. Contact:
Sam MacKenzie, Group Leader, Seed Oil Modification Group, NRC-
PBI at smackenzie@pbi.nrc.ca or David Taylor at
dtaylor@pbi.nrc.ca
Science and Technology Week October 18-27
Science and Technology Week is Canada's annual celebration of
achievement in the fields of science, technology, engineering,
and mathematics. This year, from October 18-27, thousands of
events and activities will help to promote a science and
innovation culture by showcasing Canadian innovations and
enhancing public awareness of the benefits gained through
scientific research and development.
In Saskatchewan, the week will kick off with a rocket launch
organized by the Western Space Education network on Saturday,
October 19th. Participants have built their own rockets and a
mass launch is planned. Other events include television and
radio science trivia contests, a number of Beaver Creek family
programs, and many school events.
In recognition of the special week, Ag-West Biotech sponsored
an Agbiotech Essay Contest, inviting Saskatchewan's twelfth
grade students to submit essays on the topic of
"Biotechnology, Agriculture, and Our Future." Three
scholarships of $1000 each will be awarded to the contest
winners during Science and Technology Week.
Contact: National Science and Technology Week, Science
Promotion and Academic Affairs Branch, Industry Canada, 8th
Floor, West Tower, 235 Queen Street, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0H5.
Phone 800/268-6604; fax 613/998-0943; e-mail
NSTW.SNST@ic.gc.ca; web site
http://schoolnet.carleton.ca/NSTW/ or in Saskatchewan contact
Maurice Robert at Maurice.Robert@innovplace.saskatoon.ca or
http://www.stpaulrcsd.saskatoon.sk.ca/NatSciTech
Plant Disease Forecast Based on GIS
A plant disease risk forecasting service which can provide a
regional indication of weather conditions and disease
progression has been developed by Manitoba Agriculture and
several corporate and public partners. Using Geographic
Information Systems (GIS) software, the service analyzes crop
stage, weather, and soil moisture conditions from 50
Environment Canada weather stations to produce maps indicating
conditions favorable to the outbreak of plant diseases.
Barley Biotech in Brandon
The Ag Canada Research Centre in Brandon, Manitoba has
initiated a project to take advantage of the new tools
afforded by biotechnology in barley breeding. The first major
goal of the project is to determine the utility of molecular
marker assisted selection for disease resistance and quality
traits in barley-breeding programs with a view to establishing
a routine screening lab at Brandon.
The second goal is to optimize tissue culture techniques for
regenerating barley from microspores or other tissues in
support of the doubled haploid project in Brandon and genetic
transformation research at Brandon and Winnipeg. This reduces
the breeding cycle by two to three years.
The project is supported with funds from the Western Grains
Research Foundation Barley Check-off and the Ag Canada
Matching Investments Initiative.
Contact: Bill Legge or Mario Therrien. Phone 204/726-7650;
fax 204/ 728-3858; web site
http://res.agr.ca/brandon/brc/welcome.htm
Pest Management Agency Moves
The Pest Management Regulatory Agency is on the move. Their
new address is: Pest Management Regulatory Agency, Health
Canada, A.L. 6605E1, 2250 Riverside Drive, Ottawa, Ontario K1A
0K9. The web site is http://www.hwc.ca/pmra
Enhancing Gene Expression
Researchers at the University of Guelph have cloned and
sequenced several repetitive DNA sequences from alfalfa,
according to the Green Gene Gazette. The objective of
the project was to discover DNA sequences that would enhance
transgene integration. The process involved the
identification of an alfalfa sequence with homologies to the
transformation booster sequence of petunia which increased
petunia transformation rates up to 20-fold.
Contact: University of Guelph Crop Science Department lab web
site at http://www.uoguelph.ca
Achieving High Gene Expression
Although recombinant technology in plants is becoming
commonplace, achieving a high expression of introduced genetic
material in target plants remains a challenge, particularly
when the goal of the project is a plant "biofactory" for the
production of products such as pharmaceuticals. Levels of
gene expression are partly a function of the promoter to which
the coding region of the gene is fused. According to an item
in ISB News Report, Purdue University scientist Stan
Gelvin has developed what is being hailed as a "super-
promoter" from Agrobacterium which results in
substantially improved gene expression over the most popular
promoter currently in use, the 35S promoter from cauliflower
mosaic virus.
Plastid Transformation Technology
Calgene Inc. of Davis, California has announced that it has
been granted two US patents involving plastid transformation
technology. Plastid transformation allows expression of a
foreign protein in the plastids of plant cells. A plant cell
contains one nucleus and multiple plastids. Typically,
genetically engineered plants contain a low number of gene
copies inserted into the nuclear genome. Insertion of a
foreign gene into the plastid genome via plastid
transformation, on the other hand, can produce up to 10,000
copies of the foreign gene per cell. Thus, there is a great
potential for amplifying gene expression using this
technology. Furthermore, plastid transformed traits are
inherited exclusively from the maternal parent in most plant
species and, consequently, there is no possibility for pollen-
mediated outcrossing of a genetically engineered plant.
Increased Functional Chlorophyll
The Green Gene Gazette reports the development of a
gene construct which increases the amount of the functional
chlorophyll a/b binding protein (Cab) involved in
photosynthesis. Transgenic tobacco plants containing the
construct have up to 50 per cent more active chlorophyll and a
50 per cent increase in photosynthesis. The plants also have
200 to 300 per cent more biomass, faster growth, earlier
germination, sturdier stalks, 200 per cent more carbohydrate
content and increased shade tolerance.
New Flour Properties from Transgenic Wheat
Researchers at the USDA Agricultural Research Service Lab in
Albany, California have genetically-engineered a wheat
cultivar to accumulate high levels of glutenin, a seed
storage protein that affects the elasticity of bread dough.
Ann Blechl and Olin Anderson are currently
assessing the transgenic lines. After four generations, eight
lines were found to exhibit transgene expression, and
researchers hope to have enough flour to test dough qualities
within a year.
Pesticidal Sugar Esters
Orestes Chortyk and fellow researchers at the USDA's
Natural Products Utilization Research Unit in Athens, Georgia
have succeeded in producing synthetic sugar esters which can
be used as an environmentally-friendly pesticide. The esters
are similar in structure to the natural sugars found in plants
of the Nicotiana family which offer a natural protection
against whiteflies and other pests. The synthesized sugars
have proven to be equally toxic to whiteflies.
Pig Genome Updates
- Dr. Gary Rohrer and his colleagues at the USDA-ARS
MARC facility have published the largest single porcine
genetic linkage map, including 1116 genes and markers, tying
together many markers from previous maps. Contact: The map
can be seen on the USDA homepage at
http://sol.marc.usda.gov.8400/pigbase/manager/html
- An additional 33 pairs brings the number of fluorescent
primers available from the US Pig Genome coordinator to 96.
Each primer pair is composed of one fluorescently labeled and
one unlabeled primer. Contact: Max F. Rothschild, US Pig
Genome Coordinator by phone at 515/294-6202 or by e-mail at
mfrothsc@iastate.edu
- Two French researchers are looking for collaborators in
their search for the RN gene associated with an undesirable
cooking quality in ham. Contact: Anyone interested in
collaborating on the search can contact Dennis Milan at
milan@toulouse.inra.fr or Pascale LeRoy at
leroy@dga.jouy.inra.fr
- The Salt Lake City, Utah firm Linkage Genetics has launched
a joint venture with the Franklin, Kentucky-based company PIC
USA to use Linkage's genomic analysis technology in the swine
sector.
Regulatory
Transgenic Crops Receive Japanese Clearance
Two canola biotechnologies have received important regulatory
approvals from the Japanese Ministry of Health and Welfare
(MHW).
Japan's MHW has granted safety clearance for food products of
canola seed grown from AgrEvo's Liberty Link canola. This
clearance follows environmental approval early in June. It
applies to Liberty-resistant transgenic varieties from Regina,
Saskatchewan-based AgrEvo Canada and from PGS, the plant
genetics company recently acquired by AgrEvo. The Liberty
Link production system was registered in Canada in 1995.
Margaret Gadsby, regulatory and scientific affairs
director of AgrEvo, says this food safety approval
represents the Ministry's scientific assessment that Liberty
Link canola seed represents no significant risk in terms of
food safety in Japan. "The final step for complete Japanese
approval is safety of animal feed," says Gadsby. "That
decision is expected shortly."
Japanese regulatory clearance is a major step toward allowing
Liberty Link canola to move freely through conventional
marketing channels, and trade freely on world markets.
Final safety approval has also been given to Monsanto's
Roundup Ready canola. Two other Monsanto products, as well as
a third product that features Monsanto technology, were also
approved. These are NewLeaf potatoes, protected from the
Colorado potato beetle; Roundup Ready soybeans; and Northrup
King's corn, which is protected from the European corn borer
by Monsanto's YieldGard technology.
Roundup Ready canola has full regulatory approval in Canada
where it is currently being grown on some 50,000 acres.
Proposed Biotech Amendments Published
Document containing proposed amendments to various federal
regulations affecting the agricultural biotechnology sector
were published in the Canada Gazette, Part I, on August 17,
1996. These documents include:
- Regulations for Environmental Safety Assessments of Releases
of Plants With Novel Traits Under the Seeds Act;
- Regulations for Environmental Safety Assessments of
Veterinary Biologics
Under the Health of Animals Act;
- Regulations for Environmental Safety Assessments of Releases
of Novel Feeds Under the Feeds Act; and
- Regulations for Environmental Safety Assessments of Releases
of Supplements Under the Fertilizers Act.
All of these documents can be accessed on the Internet at
http://aceis.agr.ca/fpi/agbiotec/english.html.
Interested parties are invited to review and comment on
these regulatory amendments and to distribute them to
colleagues or to any others who they believe may have an
interest in this area. Recommendations and comments would be
appreciated, particularly on the appropriate level of detail
of information requirements in this proposed regulatory
amendment compared to the level of detail in existing
guidelines on plants with novel traits. Comments should be
submitted within 60 days of the date of this document to
bsco@em.agr.ca or to the Associate Director, Biotechnology
Strategies and Coordination Office, Food Production and
Inspection Branch, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, 59
Camelot Drive, Nepean, Ontario K1A 0Y9
Contact: Biotechnology Strategies and Coordination Office,
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Nepean, Ontario K1A 0Y9.
Phone: 613/952-8000; fax 613/ 941-9421.
US EPA Approves Sandoz Bt Corn
The US Environmental Protection Agency has approved the Swiss
company Sandoz's application to market its corn hybrids
containing Bt genes for resistance to the European corn borer.
Northrup King, the seed division of Sandoz, will market the
seed. It is anticipated that enough seed will be available to
plant several hundred thousand acres by next spring.
Ag Canada Approves 113 Field Trials
Approvals for 113 field trials of plants with novel traits
have been granted by the Food and Inspection Branch of
Agriculture and Agri-food Canada as of June 18, 1996. The
trials, which are taking place over 747 sites, are being
carried out for 14 genetically modified crops by 20 companies
and organizations.
Canola is the most widely tested crop, with 483 trial sites,
followed by corn (107), potato (93) , and alfalfa (30). The
largest number of trials are taking place in Saskatchewan
(224), followed by Alberta (186), Ontario (152), and Manitoba
(95). A number of new species are being tested for the first
time this year, including Ethiopian mustard, cherry, and grape
vine.
The majority of trials are evaluating herbicide resistance in
crops (569), although these trials involve multiple testing
sites for just 52 submissions. Other trials are evaluating
insect and viral resistance, stress tolerance and nutritional
changes. The trials involve plants altered through three
different biotech processes, although Agrobacterium
transformation is the most commonly used method. A number of
trials involve backcrossing to transgenics, which reflects
decisions to advance modified lines into varietal
development.
Contact: Simon Barber, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada,
Plant Protection Division, Nepean, Ontario K1A 0Y9. Phone
613/952-8000 ext 4390.
Events
Biotech Networking Session - Saskatoon
A "Biotech Networking Session" will be held Wednesday, October
16, 1996 from 7:00 - 8:45 a.m. at the Picasso Room of the
Radisson Hotel in Saskatoon. Dr. Brian Morrissey,
Assistant Deputy Minister, Research Branch, Agriculture and
Agri-Food Canada, will speak on the topic "Future Direction of
Agricultural Biotechnology Research Within the Research Branch
of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada". Tickets are $12.00 per
person and include a breakfast buffet. Seating is
limited.
Contact; To order tickets, call Anne Broda, Saskatoon
Regional Economic Development Authority at 306/664-0724.
AgBiotech Market Research Seminar
An educational seminar on market research for agbiotechnology
companies will be presented on November 5, 1996 at Innovation
Place in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan. The seminar will cover the
fundamentals of market research - tools and techniques, when
research should be done, and how to do research so that the
results will enable companies to develop a strategic marketing
plan.
This full-day seminar is sponsored by Ag-West Biotech Inc.,
the AdCulture Group Inc., the Canadian Institute of
Biotechnology and Innovation Place. Registration is $70.
Contact: Susan Wychara, AdCulture Group Inc. Phone
306/652-2986; fax 306/653-1782, or Shannon Schneider, Ag-West
Biotech Inc., Phone 306/975-1939; fax 306/975-1966; e-mail:
agwest@innovplace.saskatoon.sk.ca
Animal and Plant Cell Meeting
An Animal and Plant Cell Working Party meeting under the
auspices of the European Federation of Biotechnology will be
held in Brussels, Belgium on October 21 and 22, 1996. The
theme of the informal meeting will be high-density
cultures.
Contact: Dr. Kees de Gooijer, Wageningen Agricultural
University, Food and Bioprocess Engineering Group, P.O.Box
8129, 6700 EV Wageningen, The Netherlands. Phone 31-317-
483975; fax 31-317-482237; e-mail
kees.degooijer@algemeen.pk.wau.nl
Fall Seminar Series at Saskatoon's Innovation Place
Innovation Place is hosting a series of noon hour business
seminars this fall in conjunction with Canadian Profit Systems
and Trimension Group. The topics and dates follow:
- Work Place Training - October 29
- Benchmarks for Corporate Success - November 5
- Financing Options - November 12
- How to Use the Internet to Achieve Your Marketing Goals -
November 19
- Success Through Database - November 26
The cost of each seminar is $25.00 ($100 for full series).
Lunch is included.
Contact: Lori at Innovation Place, phone 306/933-
6295.
Conference on Biotechnology of Bt
The Second Pacific Rim Conference on Biotechnology of Bacillus
thuringiensis and Its Impact to the Environment will be
held in Chiang Mai, Thailand, November 4-8, 1996.
Contact: The Secretariat, The 2nd PacRim Conference on Bt,
P.O. Box 1087, Kasetsart, Bangkok, Thailand. Phone 66-2-
5795583 or 5793704; fax 66-2-5795583.
Biotech Opportunities in Singapore and China
Agriculture and Food Biotechnology in Asia Recent
Advances and Commercial Opportunities in Singapore and
China is the title and theme of a conference to be held
December 10-11, 1996 at the Concorde Hotel in Singapore.
Contact: A/Professor Soong Tai-Sen, Institute of Molecular
Agrobiology, 59A The Fleming, 1 Science Park Drive, Singapore
118240. Phone 65/771-9815; fax 65/773-4988.
Trends
New Market Opportunities Identified at NABC 8
Workshop
Several new areas of market opportunities were identified by
participants at the Food Industry Workshop held at the
National Agricultural Biotechnology Council's Conference (NABC
8). A report on the workshop in NABC News (available from
NABC, 419 Boyce Thompson Institute, Tower Road, Ithaca, NY USA
14953) lists a number of these opportunities, including:
- increased food quality and safety including improved
nutritional, taste, and safety features (such as packaging
indicators), as well as nutraceutical products and processes
that remove detrimental elements from foods;
- vaccine production and delivery via crop plant
"biofactories";
- increased producer productivity, through higher yield,
expanded growing range, and "pharming";
- processing for increased efficiency, such as better methods
of using processing by-products; and
- environmentally benign/beneficial foods, such as more
environmentally friendly crops or packaging.
After discussing barriers to the development of products in
these new market areas (including public acceptance), and
methods of overcoming barriers, the group recommended that
measures be taken to:
- increase public awareness and input regarding novel foods
and processes;
- ensure that industry takes clear responsibility for risk;
- establish competitive research consortia to share and
leverage knowledge and expertise; and
- allocate monies to examine social. ethical, and legal issues
surrounding food innovation.
The workshop also considered that new food products and
processes will cause economic and structural changes in the
industry. Impacts could involve
- increased horizontal integration, including linkages with
other sectors such as pharmaceuticals, energy and
environment;
- more vertical integration in the industry;
- more dependable, improved food sources;
- increased resistance to controls in insect pests and
diseases; and
- "quick fix" approaches that neglect longer term social and
ethical solutions to food security, such as more equitable
trade or distribution of resources.
The next NABC Conference (NABC 9) is scheduled for June 1-2,
1997 in Saskatoon. The theme will be Resource Management
in Challenged Environments.
Contact: Dr. George Lee, 306/966-4057 for details.
Pests Genetically Engineered for Self-destruction
Researchers at the University of California, Riverside and the
USDA-ARS in Wapato, Washington are developing a technique
called Autocidal Biological Control (ABC). The technique
involves the mass release of insect pests genetically
engineered to be unable to overwinter. When the mutant
insects mate with the normal pest population, the offspring
cannot survive cold weather conditions, causing the pest
population to crash. The researchers are studying the
efficacy of a mutant Notch gene, a gene involved in normal
embryonic development. ABC research is currently underway for
the pink bollworm and the codling moth.
ABC could be cheaper and less labour intensive than the
currently used Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) which involves
the release of insects sterilized by irradiation. The
genetically-engineered insects would have only one mutation
and be hardier and more capable of mating than insects with
multiple mutations from the SIT approach. The ABC would also
result in reduced pesticide use.
Biotechnology in India
With 900 million people to feed, the India agriculture sector
is increasing its interest and activity in biotechnology.
The most significant area of investment so far has been in the
use of tissue-cultures to develop disease free plants for the
quickly expanding ornamental export market. Nearly 10 million
micropropagated plants were exported from India last year, and
a capacity for 100 million plants is predicted. Researchers
have now developed micropropagation techniques for eucalyptus,
bamboo, sandalwood, pomegranate, mango, neem, and tamarind.
While basic research in molecular biology is limited to a few
institutions in India, applied research is going on at many
agricultural universities where transgenic crops, diagnostic
systems, and improved vaccines are being studied. Courses in
biotechnology are also being offered at many universities.
Partnerships between Indian companies and major international
biotech firms have resulted in the production of transgenic
cow pea, mung bean, and other crops, some of which have been
field tested. Biotechnologies for corn, brassicas, silkworms
and other plants and animals are also being developed with
funding assistance from the national government and several
foundations.
Problems faced by Indian researchers include everything from
power outages and the high cost of research journals, to the
lack of intellectual property rights for plants and patent
enforcements (which result in extreme secrecy within the
scientific community.)
Contact: C.S.Prkash, Centre for Plant Biotechnology
Research, Tuskegee University. E-mail at
prakash@acd.tusk.edu
Alliances
Collaborations: Bringing a Research Idea to Fruition
(The following is reprinted from the NRC's PBI
Bulletin.)
Scientists could be forgiven for being overwhelmed by the
avalanche of challenges they face at each and every stage of
their research. In the early days, it seemed clear what their
role was. Today, they collide with the realities of debt and
equity financing, while at the same time deciding on the
research viability of their project.
Some of the practical questions researchers must ask
themselves at the outset of a project are:
- Is this research viable?
- Is the expertise available?
- Do I have an effective business as well as a research
plan?
- How long will this project take?
- Where can I obtain adequate and timely financing?
- Who are potential partners for this research?
- What are the risks? What are the benefits?
- What regulatory bodies must I work with?
- What are the responsibilities and with whom do they lie?
- Who owns the rights?
- Will the consumer accept the final product?
Scientists are further frustrated by the need to produce
practical results while realizing that only through basic
science can applied research be achieved. However, with new
biotech products now on the market, scientists and industry
have obviously found successful ways to work in harmony, and
we have begun a history of collaboration.
Contact: For more information contact Rosemarie Gallays at
306/975-5571.
Mycogen
San Diego, California-based Mycogen Corp. will consolidate its
research operations as a result of its purchase of
Indianapolis, Indiana-based DowElanco's seed business.
Mycogen will close its research sites at Madison, Wisconsin
and San Diego. Research will now be consolidated in
DowElanco's Indianapolis facilities. Some Mycogen
biopesticide research projects will be phased out as part of
this consolidation.
Contact: Mycogen Web site at http://www.mycogen.com
Annual Meeting
Ag-West Biotech Inc. invites you to their 6th Annual Meeting
to be held October 17, 1996 9:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. Da Vinci
Room, Radisson Hotel, 405 20th Street East, Saskatoon.
The new president, Dr. William Riley, will be introduced.
For more information and a personal invitation, contact:
Ag-West Biotech Inc. at (306) 975-1939 or e-mail
agwest@innovplace.saskatoon.sk.ca
Tech Transfer
Pharmaceutical Potential of Flax
A flax extract with medicinal value has been identified by
researchers at the AAFC Saskatoon Research Centre, the
University of Saskatchewan, and the Victoria Hospital in
London, Ontario. Industry partners are being sought for
commercial development of the patented extraction process.
The technology can extract secoisolariciresinal diglucoside
(SDG) from flaxmeal, which can then be used as an animal feed.
The extract has potential in the treatment of diseases
including atherosclerosis, lupus nephritis, and diabetes,. It
also has antioxidant properties and is useful in the lowering
of blood cholesterol.
Contact: Sandy Bresciani, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada,
Saskatoon. Phone 306/975-6420; fax 306/ 975-6419.
MIT Technologies Licensed to Metabolix
The Massachusetts Institute of Technology has granted two
exclusive licenses to its patents for the production of
naturally occurring biodegradable plastics to the Cambridge,
Massachusetts company Metabolix Inc. The patents cover the
production of polyhydroxalkonoates (PHAs) using recombinant
techniques.
Finance
Saskatchewan Trade to Take Another Step Forward
Saskatchewan's industrial sector and the Provincial Government
have jointly established the Saskatchewan Trade and Export
Partnership Inc. (STEP). Fully 60 per cent of Saskatchewan's
GDP comes from exported products and services; STEP has been
designed to further enhance export opportunities by assisting
Saskatchewan companies to initiate sales, contracts, projects,
and alliances.
STEP services will include: match-making for partnerships and
joint ventures; information about new and existing export
markets, opportunities and trends; advice about promoting
products or services; competitive analysis; networking; access
to export training and education; advice about export
financing; opportunities to participate in trade missions and
meet foreign buyers in Saskatchewan; and referrals to export
contacts.
Established or emerging Saskatchewan exporters can become
members of STEP, while persons, companies, and organizations
with an interest in trade or who provide trade services can
become associate members.
Contact: STEP Inc., Box 1787, 2nd floor, 1919 Saskatchewan
Drive, Regina, Saskatchewan Canada S4P 3C6. Phone 306/787-
9210; fax 306/787-6666; e-mail at inquire@sasktrade.sk.ca;
website at http://www.sasktrade.sk.ca
Ecogen Financial Picture Improves
US biopesticide company Ecogen has announced increased third
quarter total revenue sales of 40 per cent to over $5.5
million. Product sales increased by 36% while operating
expenses decreased by 32 per cent. Nonetheless, a quarterly
loss of $710,000 was still reported.
Ecogen, which has formed a partnership with Monsanto to
develop Bt technologies, was the first US company to receive
approval for sale of a genetically altered biopesticide. New
products soon to be introduced by Ecogen include Aspire, a
biofungicide for post-harvest rot, and a bioinsecticide for
fruits and vegetables called CRYMAX.
Mogen Announces Possible Sale
The Dutch plant biotech company Mogen has announced that
unidentified industrial parties have expressed interest in a
take-over, leading the company to investigate the potential to
shareholders of the sale of the company. The sale of Mogen
would ensure the sustainability of its research and
development program. In August, Mogen announced improved
sales results in the first six months of 1996, although a loss
was reported for the period.
Issues
"Bugs" in Transgenic Cotton Technology
Some farmers in Texas are less than satisfied with the pest
resistance claims made for Bollgard transgenic cotton. The
cotton, which was genetically engineered by Monsanto to
incorporate Bt genes toxic to the cotton bollworm, tobacco
budworm, and pink bollworm, is sold by Delta and Pine Land Co.
It has been planted extensively across the US south.
Farmers in the region are facing extremely high infestations
of cotton bollworm this year. While many report good results
from the new transgenic cotton, some farmers in the Brazos
River Valley of Texas say that Bollgard cotton is not working
out as expected. Possible causes for high level of pest
infestation are favorable weather conditions and increased
planting of corn, the favorite host plant of the bollworm.
The development has resulted in a request from the Union of
Concerned Scientists to the US EPA to suspend registration of
Bollgard cotton. The Union has stated in the past that the
use of Bt genes in cotton could result in insects developing
resistance to Bt, which is used as a bioinsecticide. The
Union states that EPA registration was based on the condition
that a resistance management strategy would be developed. The
possible failure of the cotton to kill the bollworm, at least
in some areas, could mean that large numbers of insects
survive feeding on the transgenic plants, giving succeeding
generations an opportunity to build resistance. Monsanto has
said that it will study the situation in detail.
Meanwhile, the Australian National Registration Authority has
granted registration for Monsanto's Ingard transgenic Bt-
containing cotton. The registration allows Ingard cotton to
be planted over 30,000 hectares. The move sparked immediate
calls for the withdrawal of the approval pending further
testing.
Resources
Canadian Technology Network Office in Saskatoon
The Canadian Technology Network (CTN) has opened a Saskatoon
office at Innovation Place. CTN links federal and provincial
government labs and agencies, universities, community
colleges, industry associations, technology centres and
economic development agencies. Together these organizations
provide innovative Canadian companies with quick and personal
access to expertise, advice and information about how to meet
technology and related business challenges.
CTN a joint initiative of the Industrial Research Assistance
Program (IRAP) of the National Research Council of Canada and
Industry Canada provides a wide variety of information which
makes it easy for small and medium-sized businesses to link
up with other technology related organizations. This
information includes:
1. Profiles of organizations that are doing ground breaking
work in the technology sector.
2. Profiles of organizations that offer business-related
services such as financial, management, marketing and
training.
3. The names and address of experts in a wide variety of
technological fields.
4. Offers of technology and service profiles from more than 30
technology-related business sectors.
5. Access to testing services, capability and equipment
available.
6. Research and development interests within universities, and
published papers by researchers.
7. Sources for relevant documents.
CTN's new coordinator in Saskatchewan is Rob Greer.
Greer was previously with the Department of Western
Economic Diversification where he has spent the past 8 years
in a number of roles in the Saskatoon office.
The University of Saskatchewan is also a host to an on-campus
CTN Representative. Renette Kurz will be gathering
information about facilities, services, courses, and other
technology related resources available at the university.
Contact: Rob Greer, Regional Coordinator - Saskatchewan,
Canadian Technology Network, National Research Council of
Canada, Atrium Building, 320 - 111 Research Drive, Saskatoon,
Saskatchewan S7N 3R2. Phone 306/975-6741; fax: 306/975-6743,
e-mail Rob.Greer@irap.nrc.ca or Renette Kurz,
University of Saskatchewan, Kirk Hall, Room 220, 117 Science
Place, Saskatoon SK S7N 5C8. Phone 306/966-8723; e-mail
renette.kurz@usask.ca
Free Lab Help in May
If you are considering hiring a laboratory technician, how
about trying one for free first! The Biological Sciences
Technology Program at Kelsey Institute is just a name change
away from becoming the Biotechnology Program and its students
are anxious to showcase their skills. To that end, the
program has moved its laboratory practicum experience from
January to May, which is at the end of the two year study
period. They have had extensive training in microbiological
procedures; biochemical and analytical chemical analyses and
instrumentation; plant physiology and pathology; plant and
animal tissue culture; immunological procedures include ELISA
and SRID techniques; enumerations of cell populations and
antibody titres; and their new molecular biology course
including bacteriological transformations; DNA isolation,
methylation, restriction analysis, ligations and sequencing;
PCR; electrophoresis; DNA mini-preps; Southern blots and
hybridization.
Students will be actively seeking practicum positions from now
through January. As before, this is a continuing program, so
if you can't use a student this year, please keep the program
in mind for future consideration.
Contact: Dr. Joanne Post, Kelsey Institute, Saskatoon.
Phone 306/933-6454; fax 306/933-6490.
Food Development Centre - Manitoba
The National Agri-Food Development Centre in Portage La
Prairie, Manitoba has changed its name to the Food Development
Centre. Working as a special operating agency of Manitoba
Rural Development, the Centre will concentrate on assisting
the agri-food sector with its economic growth. The new
management of the Centre will focus on helping the food
industry in food product and process development, as well as
in food safety and food quality testing.
Contact: Gerald Offet, General Manager/CEO, Food
Development Centre, Box 1240, 810 Phillips Street, Portage La
Prairie, Manitoba R1N 3J9. Phone 204/239-3167; fax 204/239-
3180.
Agri-Food Entrepreneurship Certificate Program
The Food Development Centre and the Assiniboine Community
College are offering a 16 week Agri-Food Entrepreneurship
Certificate Program in Portage La Prairie. The program is
described as an outcome-based, practical program that provides
the prospective entrepreneur with the knowledge and skills
necessary to create a value-added food business.
Contact: Jyoti Sahasrabudhe, Food Development Centre, Box
1240, 810 Phillips Street, Portage La Prairie, Manitoba R1N
3J9. Phone 204/239-3167; fax 204/239-3180; e-mail
sahasra@eitc.mb.ca.
UK Biotechnology Directory
The 1996 edition of the UK Biotechnology Handbook lists
over 880 British organizations involved in biotech and
contains over 3500 senior contact names. This 11th edition
includes more non-medical contacts and 11 new review articles.
Other information from BioCommerce Data includes an extensive
worldwide directory on the biotechnology industry, updated
twice monthly; targeted mailing lists of up to 11,000 senior
executives in the industry; and a new quarterly information
service on CD-ROM summarizing over 300,000 biotech business
news articles.
Contact: BioCommerce Data Ltd., Prudential Buildings, 95
High Street, Slough, Berks SL1 1DH, UK. Phone 01753 511777;
fax 01753 512239; e-mail at biocom@dial.pipex.com
Proceedings from Beltsville Animal Symposia
Beltsville Symposia in Agricultural Research XX:
Biotechnology's Role in the Genetic Improvement of Farm
Animals has been published by the American Society of
Animal Science, Savoy, Illinois. The ISBN number is 1-887458-
01-8.
We Welcome Your Input
The AgBiotech Bulletin welcomes submissions of news, ideas and
articles from subscribers. Information about new developments
at your company or institution, notices about new products or
resources, or observations about events and opportunities
affecting the agbiotech industry will be considered for
publication. Please put us on your mailing list for press
releases and/or contact us directly regarding story ideas or
submissions.
Contact: Debbie Lepage, Ag-West Biotech Inc., 230-111
Research Drive, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan. Canada S7N 3R2; phone
306/975-1939; fax 306/975-1966; e-mail:
agwest@innovplace.saskatoon.sk.ca
Credits:
The Agbiotech Bulletin is published 12 times per year
on behalf of Ag-West Biotech Inc. by Westcross House
Publications, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada S7K OR1, e-mail:
signatur@eagle.wbm.ca
Ag-West Biotech can be reached at 230-111 Research Drive,
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada S7N 3R2, e-mail:
agwest@innovplace.saskatoon.sk.ca World Wide Web:
http://www.lights.com/agwest/
The Agbiotech Bulletin is published 12 times per year on
behalf of Ag-West Biotech Inc. by Westcross House
Publications,
|