About Bioline  All Journals  Testimonials  Membership  News  Donations

Memórias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz
Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Fiocruz
ISSN: 1678-8060 EISSN: 1678-8060
Vol. 93, Num. 3, 1998, pp. 417-422
Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz, Rio de Janeiro, Vol. 93 (3), May/June 1998, pp. 417-422


Tuberculosis and HIV: Renewed Challenge

Afranio L Kritski^+, Jose Roberto Lapa e Silva, Marcus B Conde

Unidade de Pesquisa em Tuberculose, Servico de Pneumologia, Hospital Universitario Clementino Fraga Filho, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Av. Brig. Trompowsky s/no. , Ilha do Fundao, 21941-590 Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil
+ Corresponding author. Fax: +55-21-270.2193. E-mail:
Supported by grant from CNPq n. 35 04 77/ 95. 7

Received 11 March 1998; Accepted 16 April 1998

Code Number:OC98081
Sizes of Files:
      Text: 24K
      Graphics: No associated graphics files

Key words: tuberculosis - HIV

HIV infection is responsible for an increased incidence of pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) in several areas of the world (MC Raviglione et al. 1995 JAMA 276: 220-226). In general, active TB happens as a consequence of a recently acquired exogenous infection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis or of endogenous reactivation of old infection. In some regions, besides the increase of the incidence, an important change in the dynamics of the transmission of M. tuberculosis took place. This change was more evident in closed places (hospitals, prisons, housings) where the prevalence of inmates infected by HIV is high (D Alland et al. 1994 N Engl J Med 330: 1710-1716, PM Small et al. 1994 N Engl J Med 330: 15-21, TR Frieden et al. 1996 JAMA 276: 1229-1235). The infection by HIV also interferes with the diagnosis of TB, especially in patients in the advanced form of the HIV infection. In these cases, the clinical picture of TB is quite similar to other opportunistic infections (PC Hopewell et al. 1992 Clin Infect Dis 15: 540-547, RE Chaisson & CA Benson 1995 p. 1-125. In MD Rossman, RR MacGregor (eds), Tuberculosis Clinical Managment, and New Challenges, AL Kritski et al. 1995 Bol Ofic Sanit Pan-Amer 118: 542-554). HIV seropositive patients tend to stay longer in hospitals, increasing the risk of transmission of TB or even of multidrug resistant TB (TB-MDR) to other patients, health care workers and students in teaching institutions (Alland et al. loc. cit., Frieden et al. loc. cit.). The clinical evolution of co-infected patients is diverse from immunocompetent individuals, with higher rate of adverse drugs reaction and mortality (JH Perriens et al. 1995 N Engl J Med 332: 77, Kritski et al. loc. cit.). The emphasis given in the last decades to outpatient treatment of TB should be now revised in areas with high rate of TB and AIDS, especially in great urban centers. Hospital treatment of tuberculosis patients with co-morbidities, such as AIDS, is much more common now. Should be taken into account in the elaboration of public politics the occurrence of TB in general hospitals, above all in developing countries, such as Brazil.

According to the World Health Organization (WHO), in the year 2000, 14 million cases of tuberculosis will be notified, of which 3 to 4 million will die (WHO 1996 TB/96.197). Of these, about 1.5 million patients will die with HIV/AIDS. It is important to call attention to the fact that TB is an easily curable disease in 85-95% of HIV seronegative patients. In Brazil, up to 1990, the incidence of TB was falling 2 to 4% a year. In the last years, however, this rate decreased to 0.4% a year (Ministerio da Saude 1996 Boletim Epidemio-logico No. 9, 12 pp). Brazil is a country of great dimensions, with many disparities. When we analyzed the data for the city of Rio de Janeiro, in the southeast region, we verified that while in 1986 the TB incidence rate was 80/100,000 inhabitants, in 1995 it reached 160/100,000, similar to some African countries (Coordenacao de Pneumologia Sanitaria, Secretaria Municipal de Saude, Municipio do Rio de Janeiro 1997, unpublished data). Even in areas with good TB control programs, as in Malawi and Mozambique, the TB incidence increased 30 to 50% in the last years (Raviglione et al. loc. cit.).

In many countries, the TB control programs do not usually include the information on HIV when a case of TB is notified. Also, the AIDS control programs do not share its information related to the AIDS cases with notified TB. Therefore, there is a sub-notification and little reliability of the epidemiological indicators about the association of TB/HIV, mainly in developing countries. In 1991, seroprevalence studies in the city of Rio de Janeiro showed that, in the health posts, 4% of the patients notified as having TB were infected by HIV. In 1996, this rate reached 10%. In 1997, about 9,500 cases of tuberculosis were notified, 70% in health posts and 30% in hospitals (Coordenacao de Pneumologia Sanitaria, Secretaria Municipal de Saude, Municipio do Rio de Janeiro 1997, unpublished data). The frequency of HIV/AIDS infection among tuberculosis patients was of 5-10% in heath posts and of 15-35% in the hospitals. In the Clementino Fraga Filho University Hospital, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (HUCFF), among 300 patients notified a year, the infection rate for HIV was 35% (Kritski et al. loc. cit.).

In 1995, patients with pulmonary TB and positive bacilloscopy in the sputum in health posts were 50% while in the hospitals were 56%. These data are alarming because these patients are assisted in hospitals without infection control measures, placing under risk health care professionals and other patients. In the city of Rio de Janeiro the culture for mycobacteria carried out in just 30% of the cases assisted in hospitals. A study accomplished in the HUCFF showed that introduction of the culture in the patients' investigation under suspicion of TB increased the diagnosis yield from 6% to 21% (MB Conde et al. 1998 pers. comm.).

Among the 72,209 cases of pulmonary TB notified to the state secretaries of health in Brazil in 1995, 38% were treated without bacteriological confirmation, 22% with negative acid fast bacilli of sputum and 16% without bacilloscopy (Ministerio da Saude loc. cit.). In Rio de Janeiro and Sao Paulo the proportion of patients treated empirically was even higher (43 to 45%), mainly in hospitals (FQ Mello et al. 1996 Tuberc Lung Dis 77: 95). This probably has an impact in patients co-infected by M. tuberculosis and HIV, because they tend to present smaller expectoration and/or larger frequency of negative smears.

A current subject of consideration is the relationship between infection by HIV and the risk of MDR-TB. In the United States of America (USA), from 1984 to 1992, the frequency of primary resistance to at least one of the anti-TB drugs increased from 10% to 23% (AB Bloch et al. 1994 JAMA 271: 665-671). In New York, where several outbreaks took place in hospitals and in prisons, the frequency of primary MDR (resistance to isoniazide and rifampin) in patients with HIV/AIDS was 20% (Frieden et al. loc. cit.). However, in Tanzania, differences were not observed in the frequency of primary resistance to anti-TB drugs among patients infected or not by HIV (HJ Chum et al. 1996 AIDS 10: 229-309). In this study most of the patients originated from health posts. In England, in a national study of resistance to anti-TB drugs performed in TB clinics and hospitals, the frequency of primary multi-drug resistance in HIV seropositive patients was 7% and in seronegative ones 1% (DE Bennet et al. 1996 Tuber Lung Dis 77: 91). These data suggest that the primary MDR in patients infected by HIV increases in closed places such as hospitals, prisons and shelters. In New York, the "clusters " of strains associated with the occurrence of recent exogenous infection and followed by active TB happened more frequently in patients born in the USA, in blacks, in patients with AIDS and in health care workers. However, this frequency was smaller among immigrants thus probably happened because these patients got sick due to endogenous reactivation of old infection acquired in their countries of origin (CR Friedman et al. 1995 Am J Respir Crit Care Med 152: 355-359). From 1992 through 1994, in New York, with the expansion of measures to prevent and control tuberculosis, a decrease in MDR-TB has been detected. But, among notified MDR-TB patients, the proportion of health care workers was 5% (6/109) in 1995 and 15% (13/84) in 1996 (TR Frieden et al. 1995 N Engl J Med 333: 229-233, B Nivin et al. 1997, p. 145, Infect Dis Soc America 35th Annual Meeting)

Among Latin American countries, Bolivia presents high primary resistance to streptomicin and isoniazide, while in Argentina it is elevated to isoniazide and rifampin (A Laszlo & I Kantor 1994 Bull WHO 72: 603-610). In Buenos Aires, several outbreaks were described in hospitals for MDR tuberculosis, similar to that observed in New York (V Ritacco et al. 1997 J Infect Dis 176: 637-639). In these studies, techniques of molecular biology such as the "fingerprint" were useful. Recently, an outbreak of tuberculosis in a rural community of 10,000 inhabitants was described, and when checked with epidemiological evaluation with molecular methods and studies in animals, the M. tuberculosis strain was found to be one of the most virulent identified up to this moment. Just after casual contacts, three patients infected 25% of the 337 appraised close contacts and 21 people got ill (L Valways et al. 1997, p. 137, Infect Dis Soc America 35th Annual Meeting).

The preliminary data of a national survey of resistance of 6,000 M. tuberculosis strains performed by the Ministry of the Health in Brazil in patients attended in health posts indicate a prevalence of primary MDR to isoniazide and rifampin of 1%. In this study the HIV infection rate was not evaluated. In the city of Sao Paulo, in the reference center for treatment of AIDS, the prevalence of primary MDR was of 11% while in two AIDS reference general hospitals in the city of Rio de Janeiro it was of 15% and 5%, respectively (W Pinto et al. 1995 Tuber Lung Dis 76: 141, FCO Fandinho et al. 1995 Tuberc Lung Dis 76: 94). The evaluation of these data suggests that in some urban areas of Brazil primary MDR is happening mainly in closed places that assist patients infected by HIV.

AIDS has produced a great impact in the control of tuberculosis. TB now should be analyzed in a different way. Although maintaining the emphasis in primary ambulatory treatment, surveillance should also increase on patients under risk of co-infection by HIV, mainly in those originating from closed environments such as hospitals, prisons, shelters, etc. In hospitals with high prevalence of TB and AIDS, specific measures should be implemented: (a) the notification of cases, (b) environmental control of the infection, and, (c) education of health care workers. Emphasis should also be given to shorten the time of diagnosis. In areas with a high frequency of treatment failure, some of the patients admitted to the hospitals can harbor a MDR strain. With the absence of rapid methods for diagnosis of tuberculosis in these places, it could take up to six days for the result of the bacilloscopy before treatment starts and/or the patient is isolated. As a consequence, some authors have proposed some rapid amplified direct tests to detect deletion or mutation of certain gen related to the resistance to anti-tuberculous drugs. In 1994, deletion or mutation of the catalase/peroxidase gen (Katgen) was analyzed by the technique of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for the identification of resistant strains to isoniazide (INH). However, further studies performed in clinical samples with resistant strains showed low sensitivity of this technique (11 to 25%) (L Ferrazoli et al. 1995 J Infect Dis 171: 237-240). Other studies showed that the sensitivity of the technique increased when M. tuberculosis strains with high minimal inhibitory concentration of resistance to isoniazide (>50mg/ml), were evaluated while no association with virulence of the strains in guinea pigs was observed (AL Kristki et al. 1996 Am J Respir Crit Care Med 153: 806A).

More recently, it was observed that the rapid tests usually used to detect deletion and/or mutation of the gen rpoB, associated to the resistance to rifampin, detected just 89% of the resistant Brazilian strains in comparison to the French ones (100%). The analysis of the profile of the Brazilian strains should be emphasized to evaluate the true impact of the new methodologies of molecular biology diagnosis in the control of the tuberculosis (SS de Miranda et al. 1998 pers. comm.).

An excellent indicator for the evaluation of the hospital transmission of tuberculosis is the detection of PPD conversion rate among health professionals. In Brazil, the annual rate of infection for M. tuberculosis in the general population is estimated by the Ministry of Health to be 0.8%. In New York, hospitals, where outbreaks by resistant strains took place, the PPD conversion rate among health professionals varied from 20 to 50%. In hospitals without identified outbreaks, the PPD conversion rate varied from 2 to 10% (D Menzies et al. 1995 N Engl J Med 332: 92-98). In Rio de Janeiro, the HUCFF, an AIDS reference hospital, with 2,300 health professionals in clinical activities, the annual PPD conversion rate evaluated in 351 professionals was of 8%, nine times higher than the estimated for the general population. The PPD conversion happened more in the nursing personnel (12%), laboratory and radiology technicians (13%) and doctors (15%), being infrequent in the office employees group (0.9%) (GR Muzy de Souza et al. 1998 Am J Respir Crit Care Med 157: 415A). Hospitals do not have an internal system of infection control procedures, establishing the use of special masks, education of health professionals and the use of HEPA filters and/or exausting systems. All these difficulties point to the need of hospital TB control programs. Thus, in the general AIDS reference hospitals of the great urban centers, the existence of a group of health professionals that act in the same way as the existent hospital infection committees is necessary. These professionals, among other activities, would make sure that the contagious patient is isolated just after admission, would verify if the bacilloscopy of sputum was promptly requested and if the laboratory results were released on time. The presence of a professional working in tuberculosis control has great impact in the decrease of M. tuberculosis risk transmission (K Sepkowitz 1995 Clin Infect Dis 20: 232-242, NP Wenger et al. 1995 Lancet 345: 235-240, JE McGowan 1995 Clin Infect Dis 21: 489-505).

In relation to tuberculosis treatment of patients with HIV infection, three aspects should be considered: (a) the higher frequency of adverse reactions, (b) the impact of the use of protease inhibitors and, (c) the higher occurrence of abandonment of the treatment followed by acquired resistance. In Brazil, the drugs used in the treatment of TB are rifampin, isoniazide and pyrazinamide for six months in the HIV seronegative patients and nine months in the HIV seropositive ones. In retreatment patients ethambutol is also indicated. For all HIV cases culture for M. tuberculosis should be requested, besides bacilloscopy. The susceptibility test is indicated for individuals in retreatment for patients in close contact with MDR-TB or in failure of the anti-tuberculosis treatment (Ministerio da Saude loc. cit.).

The literature shows that the frequency of adverse reactions varies from 20 to 30% in AIDS patients. In Brazil, the frequency of adverse reactions varies from 4 to 6% in patient in the initial phase of the HIV infection. In this phase, with CD4 lymphocyte count 300 to 400 cells/mm^3, the cavities observed in the chest X ray were identified in 50%. However, in the advanced phase of HIV infection, the frequency of adverse reactions was higher (25%) with higher hepatitis occurrence and, with cavity observation in the chest X ray occurring less than 10% (Kritski et al. loc. cit.). These adverse reactions happened more commonly in the first three months of treatment, and were related to the use of rifampin, followed by pyrazinamide, and isoniazide (A Toledo et al. 1995 Tuber Lung Dis 76: 138, NA Ackhah et al. 1995 Lancet 345: 607-610). The failure of the tuberculosis treatment in HIV seropositive patient varies of 0 to 6% and the relapse from 0 to 15% (A Castelo et al. 1995 Pharmaco Economics 8: 385-399). These data have been noted in Brazil and in most of the developed and developing countries. In Spain, higher relapse rates have been described (23%). In the studies in USA and in African countries with schemes that contain rifampin, the relapse occurrence did not differ much among the patients with positive and negative HIV. Other studies show that the relapse was larger among individuals in the more advanced stages of HIV infection (Castelo et al. loc. cit.). In Brazil, a study was accomplished by the National TB Program -Ministry of Health in 12 capitals. In HIV seropositive patients, the frequency of abandonment was 40%, while in HIV seronegative ones 28% (LS Diniz et al. 1995 Bol Pneumol Sanit 3: 6-18). These data suggest that HIV seropositive patients tend to abandon the treatment more frequently and therefore can produce more resistant strains of M. tuberculosis. Among HIV seropositive patients, recent studies identified some variables associated with higher mortality: (a) anergy to PPD, (b) the disseminated tuberculosis, (c) lymphopenia < 1000 cells for mm^3, (d) the atypical image in the chest x ray, (e) oral candidiasis and, (f) previous condition associated with AIDS phase as citomegalovirus or Pneumocystis carinii pneunmonia (C Whalen et al. 1996 Am J Respir Crit Care Med 153: 1977-1981, RW Shafer et al. 1996 AIDS 10: 269-272). Although the patients with higher CD4 counts have longer survival, they tend to have a higher rate of relapse and may continue or not disseminating the resistant bacillus to the community.

More recent data observed in USA show that the occurrence of acquired resistance to anti-TB drugs was associated with HIV seropositive patients in the AIDS phase, even among those that use the anti-TB drugs under supervision (CM Nolan et al. 1995 Am J Respir Crit Care Med 152: 1067-1071, WZ Bradford et al. 1996 Lancet 348: 928-931). The real impact in the community of the higher occurrence of acquired myccobateria drug resistance rate among AIDS patients has to be evaluated.

Some authors have proposed that the active pulmonary tuberculosis enhances local HIV-1 replication in vivo (K Nakata et al. 1997 Am J Respir Crit Care Med 155: 1996-1999). More recently, in Uganda, it was observed that even after the treatment adapted for tuberculosis, HIV seropositive patients continue with elevated viral replication in relation to the individuals that did not have tuberculosis. These patients, co-infected by HIV and M. tuberculosis, develop faster to AIDS and have a lower survival rate. Probably the survival rate will increase with the use of anti-retroviral drugs associated to anti-TB drugs. Rifampin cannot be used in concomitance with protease inhibitors due to the impact on the protease inhibitor's on rifampin's metabolism. Recently, in a Consensus Meeting organized by the Ministry of Health and the Brazilian Society of Pneumology, alternatives schemes were proposed regarding the use of anti-TB drugs in association with anti-retroviral treatment (I Consenso Brasileiro de Tuberculose 1997. J Pneumol 23: 279-346). When the patient is not using anti-retroviral and TB is diagnosed, he/she should use na anti-TB scheme with rifampin until the end of the treatment. Later on, protease inihibitors should be initiated. When he/she is already using protease inihibitors and TB is diagnosed, it is proposed not to suspend the use of the protease inhibitor. Rifampin use should be avoided. The alternative anti-TB scheme is ethambutol, isoniazide, pyrazinamide, streptomicin for three months followed by ethambutol and isoniazide for nine months.

Regarding the chemoprophilaxis of TB for HIV seropositive patients, the Brazilian Ministry of Health proposed that isoniazide use is indicated for: (a) asymptomatic with positive PPD skin reaction (induration > 5 mm) and normal chest X ray; (b) patient's close contact with smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis, with normal chest X ray and assymptomatic (PPD skin test here is not necessary). However, there is little information about the effectiveness of INH in these patients under field conditions in the TB control programs. In 1995, an operational study conducted by WHO demonstrated the difficulty in the use of INH for HIV seropositive individuals (T Aisu et al. 1995 AIDS 9: 267-273). WHO proposed that the developing countries prioritize tuberculosis treatment. In these countries, only when the TB control programs reach high levels of cure (> 85%) of the TB cases detected, they should start preventive anti-TB treatment for the individuals infected by HIV+. These activities should be discussed with the AIDS control programs mainly in countries of intermediary level of development, like Brazil. On one side, we should treat only active TB, reaching a frequency of high cure and of low abandonment (< 5%). On the other hand, some experts propose to offer preventive anti-TB treatment for HIV seropositive patients, in spite the the quality of TB control program. In these countries the AIDS and TB control programs should pursue: (a) to evaluate the implementation of the supervised treatment as proposed by WHO; (b) better performance of both programs, with crossing of the data, to define specific strategies; (c) to improve the traditional methods of TB diagnosis like the bacilloscopy, culture and susceptibility tests, and, (d) to evaluate the usefulness of new rapid diagnostic methods (D Chin et al. 1995 Am J Respir Crit Care Med 151: 1872-1877). The Food and Drugs Administration (FDA) approved the Genprobe and of Roche kits for the diagnosis of smear positive patients. The usefulness of those kits did not receive the final approval among smear negative pulmonary TB patients, extra-pulmonary TB patients or among patients treated for TB in the past (AL Kritski et al. 1997 J Pneumol 23: 33-42). Some diagnostic kits for resistant TB have been proposed. Until now, there are few studies that evaluate its usefulness in clinical practice. In developing countries it is extremely important to evaluate its usefulness in the health posts and in hospitals. In places of cold climate, where there is no exausting system of the air, nor ventilation, without infection control policy, probably the implementation of rapid diagnostic tests for tuberculosis can be useful. Isolation procedures can be improved and decreasing the nosocomial transmission of tuberculosis will occur.

Copyright 1998 Fundacao Oswaldo Cruz - Fiocruz

Home Faq Resources Email Bioline
© Bioline International, 1989 - 2019, Site last up-dated on 02-May-2019.
Site created and maintained by the Reference Center on Environmental Information, CRIA, Brazil
System hosted by the Internet Data Center of Rede Nacional de Ensino e Pesquisa, RNP, Brazil