The Polytene Chromosomes of Cnesia dissimilis (Edwards) and Three Species of Gigantodax Enderlein (Diptera: Simuliidae) from Lanin National Park (Argentina)
Cecilia L Coscaron Arias
Catedra de Ecologia y Fitogeografia, Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias,
Universidad Nacional del Comahue, Casilla de Correo 85, 8303, Cinco Saltos,
Rio Negro, Argentina
Received 15 May 1997; Accepted 4 March 1998
Cytological studies were made on larvae of Gigantodax marginalis, G. chilensis, G. fulvescens and Cnesia dissimilis from four creeks in Lanin National Park, Neuquen province, Argentina. Chromosome maps and idiograms of these species are presented. The following inversions were observed: G. marginalis: IL-1 (X-linked inversion), IL-2 (Y-linked inversion), IIS-1.2, IIL-1, IIIL-4,5; G. chilensis: IL-4 (X-linked inversion), IIS-1.2, IIIL-4,5; G. fulvescens:IL-1 (X-linked inversion), IL-3 (Y-linked inversion), IIS-1.2, IIL-1, IIIL-4,5; C. dissimilis: IL-1, IL-5, IIIL-1. Karyological information was used to construct a cladogram and Cnesia sp. Was found to show close resemblance to the three Gigantodax spp.
Key words: Argentina - Neotropics - Simuliidae - blackflies - polytene chromosomes - cytotaxonomy
Studies of larval salivary gland chromosomes have been of major importance in the taxonomy of a number of Diptera worldwide. The differences observed in chromosome banding patterns allow the recognition of biologically distinct sibling species which is useful to establish species identity and phylogenetic relationships. In the neotropical region, blackfly chromosome studies are very scarce. Of about 350 known species (Crosskey & Howard 1997) in this area only a few have been studied cytogenetically (Hirai & Uemoto 1984, Shelley et al. 1986, Hirai 1987 a,b, Conn 1988, 1990, Conn et al. 1989, Millest 1992, Charalambous et al. 1993 a,b, 1996, Hirai et al. 1994, Munoz de Hoyos 1995).
Gigantodax is a Prosimuliini genus (sensu Crosskey & Howard, 1997), composed of 71 species distributed along the Andean range from Mexico to Tierra del Fuego (Argentina). Females are not anthropophilic and can be found as well as in mountain creeks from sea level to 4,700 m of altitude (Wygodzinsky & Coscaron 1989). Gigantodax is a peculiar genus, showing the greatest diversity among the Prosimuliini genera, with synapomorphies in imago and preimaginal stages that help to differentiate species in this genus from other genera. The unusual morphology of the respiratory filaments in the pupal stage is useful in differentiating species.
Cnesia, another Prosimuliini genus, is sympatric with southern Gigantodax. Both genera breed on both sides of the Andean range in Chile and Argentina in the subantarctic, central Chile and Patagonia realms. In this area these species are sympatric with Simulium (Pternaspatha) in the fast streams (Coscaron & Coscaron Arias 1995).
The object of this study is to provide cytological descriptions of three species of Gigantodax and one species of Cnesia, to supply basic chromosome maps for future comparisons and to achieve a more complete resolution of their phylogenetic relationship. This objective could explain possible relationships among Simuliidae genera and to ascertain if there is agreement with Wygodzinsky and Coscaron's (1989) group species division using exosomatic characters. One Cnesia species and three of Gigantodax were analyzed cytologically. A cladistic study using the cytological characters analyzed by the HENNIG86 program was done to evaluate the relationships between the species in these two genera.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The larval collections available for this analysis are part of a study on the ecology of blackflies from the Lanin National Park (Neuquen Province, Argentina) (Coscaron 1989). The Gigantodax species studied here are G. marginalis (Edwards), G. fulvescens (Blanchard) and G. chilensis (Philippi). The first species is distributed on both sides of the southern Andes area, from Valparaiso to Llanquihue (Chile) and from the center of Neuquen to Chubut (Argentina). G. fulvescens has a similar distribution but it extends from Coquimbo to Chiloe in Chile. G. chilensis has a larger range in the south from Coquimbo to Magallanes in Chile and from Neuquen to Tierra del Fuego in Argentina (Wygodzinsky & Coscaron 1989, Coscaron 1991). C. dissimilis is sympatric with the Gigantodax species studied, ranging from Valparaiso to Magallanes in Chile and from Neuquen to Chubut on the eastern flank of the Andes (Wygodzinsky & Coscaron 1973, Coscaron 1991).
Samples of G. marginalis were from Chapelco Grande, Yuco and Quitrahue brooks, while G. chilensis was collected in the Yuco, Quitrahue and Telesilla brooks. G. fulvescens was collected in Yuco and Telesilla brooks and C. dissimilis in Chapelco Grande, Yuco and Quitrahue brooks. All collections were made from 1980 to 1983 ( Fig. 1, Table I, Table II, Table III, Table IV). Larval instars were identified using Wygodzinsky and Coscaron (1989). The sampling and cytological methods follow standard procedures (Rothfels & Dunbar 1953, Rothfels et al. 1978).
Prosimulium mixtum and P. fuscum (IIIL) were used as the standard pattern because the genera Gigantodax and Cnesia belong to the same tribe (Crosskey & Howard 1997). The standard banding sequence has been previously reported Basrur (1959) and the major chromosomal landmarks are summarized in Fig. 2A. Briefly, chromosome I is characterized by the presence of the NO in IL. IS has the "3 heavy group" at the base near an expanded region. In IIS the RB is located near the centromere while IIL has two distinctive landmarks, the "group of 5", and the pB. Chromosome III is characterized by not having an expanded region. IIIS begins with the F. The B can be observed with two associated dark bands. The S and triad are located on IIIL.
Due to the difficulty in identifying the centromere in all the species analyzed its position was determined by comparison with the banding pattern of the standard species.
Gigantodax marginalis (Figs 2, 3, 4)
Figure 4 : Gigantodax marginalis (female) chromosome I.
Chromosome I - IS is identical to banding pattern in the standard, however, the NO is present in sections 18-19 rather than in IL (Figs 3B, 4). IL is the sex determining arm, with inversion IL-2 Y-linked in section 38, and inversion IL-1 in sections 30-34 X-linked (Figs 3B, 4).
Chromosome II - IIS has inversion IIS-1 in sections 50-57 which includes the RB; an included inversion IIS-1.2 is also recognized in the same region (sections 50-52) (Figs. 2, 5A). The pB, a characteristic landmark of the IIL, is in section 66. This section, along with sections 65 and 67, has been translocated between section 59 and 60 (Fig. 5B). A fixed inversion IIL-1 is present in section 68 (Fig. 5B).
Gigantodax chilensis (Figs 2D, 6, 7, 8)
Figure 7 : Gigantodax chilensis (female) - A: chromosome IS; B: chromosome IL.
Figure 8 : Gigantodax chilensis - A: chromosome IIIS; B: chromosome IIIL.
Chromosome II - The short arm of the chromosome II has the same included inversion (IIS-1.2) as G. marginalis (Fig. 6C).
G. chilensis also possesses the translocation of the segment 65-66 between sections 59-60 as in G. marginalis (Fig. 6D).
Chromosome III - The short arm of this chromosome is identical to the IIIS of the standard. The IIIL has the same inversion (IIIL-4) as G. marginalis in sections 88-89 (Fig. 8A). G. chilensis also has inversion IIIL-5 (sections 93-96) (Fig. 8B).
Gigantodax fulvescens (Figs 2E, 9, 10, 11)
Figure 11 Fig. 11: Gigantodax fulvescens - A: chromosome IIS (part); B: chromosome IIL; C: chromosome IIIS; D: chromosome IIIL.
Chromosome II - IIS shares the included inversion IIS-1.2 with G. marginalis and G. chilensis (Fig. 11A). There is a translocation of the segment involving sections 65 and 66 in the long arm of this chromosome which is rearranged between segments 59 and 60. There is an intraspecific inversion between section 69-70 (IIL-1) (Fig. 11B).
Chromosome III - The IIIS has the same banding pattern as the standard (Fig. 11C). In the long arm (IIIL) two interspecific inversions are observed: IIIL-4 and IIIL-5 (Fig. 11D), as in the other two species of Gigantodax described here.
Cnesia dissimilis (Figs 2B, 12)
Chromosome I - The short arm has the same banding pattern as the standard (Fig. 12A). The NO is in IL (Fig. 12 B) as in P. mixtum. Two inversions were found in IL. IL-5 is an interspecific inversion which includes sections 28-32 and there is an intraspecific inversion IL-1 in sections 43-44 (Fig. 12B).
Chromosome II - Chromosome II of C. dissimilis is identical with the standard banding pattern except that in IIL the pB (66) is translocated between 59/60 as in G. fulvescens and G. chilensis (Fig. 12C).
Chromosome III - The short arm is similar to the standard species but the subterminal blister is not well developed (Fig. 12D). In IIIL an intraspecific inversion (IIIL-1) is observed (83-84).
Coscaron S 1991. Insecta, Diptera, Simuliidae, p. 1-304. In ZA de Castellanos, Fauna de Agua Dulce de la Republica Argentina 38, Fasc 2, FECIC, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Phylogeny - The cladistic analysis gave only one cladogram (Fig. 13) with 11 steps, a consistency index of 1 and retention index of 1. The first clade shows that C. dissimilis has a relationship with Gigantodax species, supported by one synapomorphy, but Cnesia is the outermost taxon of them. A clade includes the three Gigantodax species and is supported by five synapomorphies. Among them G. marginalis and G. chilensis show a relationship supported by one synapomorphy.
Comparing these three species of the genus Gigantodax from Argentina with the five species analyzed by Hirai (1987c) from Ecuador where only the gross features are described and there is no standard species mentioned, we can say that the five species from Ecuador and the three species from Argentina share the following characters: the frazzle end in IIIS; the ring of Balbiani in IIS is inverted; the NO in species Gigantodax 1, 2 and 4 of Hirai are in the short arm of chromosome Y and the sex determining factor of this group may be located in chromosome I.
Munoz de Hoyos (1995) states that G. osornorum, G. ortizi, G. fulvescens, G. marginalis and G. chilensis are homologous for chromosome I and that the species from Colombia differ from the species analyzed here in the position of the NO. This author suggests an indepth analysis of chromosome I is required. We also suggest that it may also be important to examine IIIL because G. osornorum has an inversion in sections 88-90 and in G. fulvescens, G. marginalis and G. chilensis the inversion comprises sections 88-89.
From the genus Cnesia only one species was analyzed. The C. dissimilis banding pattern is most similar to that of the members of the complex P. mixtum, P. fuscum IIIL. This would suggest that among the taxa here analyzed, this species is nearest to the standard. Therefore, it could be considered a primitive species.
Comparing C. dissimilis with the Gigantodax spp. from the Lanin National Park: there are similarities between Gigantodax spp. and Cnesia sp. (translocation and location of the ParaBalbiani, frazzled end in IIIS, chromosome III has the same banding pattern as the standard and IS). These characteristics show the proximity of these two genera emphasizing what was established morphologically by Wygodzinsky and Coscaron (1973) and Py Daniel (1994).
The cladogram shows that C. dissimilis is closer to the standard than the species from the genus Gigantodax. Also, Gigantodax has a well supported monophyly, and G. marginalis and G. chilensis are the most closely related as they share a translocation of 65-66 (where the paraBalbiani is) to 59-60. In fact they only differ in their sex determination and the inversion IIL-1. This relationship is congruent with the placement of these species in the brophyi group and fulvescens in cilicinus group (Wygodzinsky & Coscaron 1989).
To Magda Charalambous (Dept. Entomology, The Natural Museum, London, U.K.) for helpful suggestions and to Prof. Nelida Caligaris (Fac. Cs. Naturales y Museo, Univ. Nac. La Plata) for drawings. To two anonymous reviewers for instructive criticism and comments.
Central and South America, p. 221-243. In MW Service, Biosystematics of Haemotophagous Insects, Clarendon, Oxford.
sis in Simulium metallicum complex from Guatemala. Japan J Sanit Zool 35: 188-192.
Copyright 1998 Fundacao Oswaldo Cruz - Fiocruz
The following images related to this document are available:
Photo images[oc98088m.jpg] [oc98088a.jpg] [oc98088c.jpg] [oc98088b.jpg] [oc98088e.jpg] [oc98088i.jpg] [oc98088h.jpg] [oc98088j.jpg] [oc98088q.jpg] [oc98088k.jpg] [oc98088p.jpg] [oc98088o.jpg] [oc98088d.jpg] [oc98088n.jpg] [oc98088r.jpg] [oc98088s.jpg] [oc98088g.jpg] [oc98088l.jpg] [oc98088f.jpg]