|
Indian Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, Vol. 9, No. 2, May-August, 2005, pp. 76-79 Original Article Health effects of occupational exposure to static magnetic field in a chloralkali plant Choobineh A, Amirzadeh F Occupational Health Department, School of Health, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran Code Number: oe05018 Abstract A cross-sectional study was conducted to determine if long-term exposure to static magnetic fields could be related to findings of medical examination. Health data was obtained for 20 workers who spent a major period of their working time in the magnetic field produced by direct current through large electric cells. The data was compared to that of control group of 21 workers. Intensity of magnetic flux density was measured in the Chloralkali plant and the TWA exposure to magnetic field was determined for each job classification. Maximum and minimum intensities were found to be 16.99 and 0.49 mT, respectively, which were well below the recommended level. Maximum TWA exposure to magnetic field was equal to 47.59 mT that was less than the acceptable level. The results of clinical examinations and blood tests revealed that there was no significant difference between the two groups. The only effects which were found to be related to exposure to the magnetic field were nervousness and fatigue. Studying a larger sample size may contribute to detect any health effects of occupational exposure to static magnetic field in industrial settings.Keywords: Chloralkali plant, Occupational exposure, Static magnetic field Introduction Static magnetic fields are naturally present everywhere as the earth is surrounded by fields varying between 0.03 and 0.070 mT.[1] Superimposed on the earth′s magnetic field, there may also be man-made static magnetic fields. Certain industry processes use strong static magnetic fields usually created by rectified altering currents. Thus the workers, for instance, in aluminum production industries and at Chloralkali plants are exposed to static magnetic fields ranging from 4 to 50 mT.[2] Although past research has shown that externally applied magnetic fields interact with biological systems to produce detectable changes, there are apparent inconsistencies and uncertainties in the findings.[3] Studies on workers involved in the manufacture of permanent magnets in the former USSR indicated various subjective symptoms and functional disturbances including irritability, fatigue, headache, loss of appetite, bradycardia, tachycardia, decreased blood pressure, altered EEG, itching, burning, and numbness.[4] However lack of any statistical analysis or assessment of the impact of physical or chemical hazards in the working environment significantly reduces the value of these reports. Epidemiological surveys in the USA have failed to reveal any significant health effects associated with long-term exposure to static magnetic fields. A study of the health data on 320 workers in mechanical plants using large electrolytic cells for chemical separation processes, where the average static field level in the work environment was 7.6 mT and the maximum field was 14.6 mT, indicated slight changes in white blood cell picture in the exposed group compared to the controls. None of the observed changes in blood parameters considered indicative of a significant adverse effect associated with magnetic field exposure.[3] Barregard et al. studied a worker cohort at a Chloralkali plant with exposure level of 4-29 mT and found that the observed and expected cancer incidence rates over 25 years were not significantly different.[5] The amount of data available for use in health risk assessment associated with static magnetic field exposure is limited[6] and the available evidence from epidemiological studies is not sufficient to draw any conclusion about potential health effects of static magnetic field exposure.[2] Therefore, conducting more epidemiological studies on exposed workers and investigating possible long-term health effects of exposure to static magnetic fields is needed. Regarding this, the present study was conducted to assess further the health effects of occupational exposure to strong static magnetic field in a Chloralkali plant, in which high-intensity direct current (DC) electrical current (110 kA) was used in industrial electrolytic processes. The main objectives of the study were:
Materials and Methods A cross-sectional study was conducted to determine if there were statistically significant differences in physiological and subjective parameters for groups of workers exposed to static magnetic field as compared to groups not so exposed. Health data were gathered during regularly scheduled physical examination done by the plant physician. Magnetic field density and time-weighted average exposures were measured by a Tesla-meter. The data was then statistically analyzed to determine if a relationship could be established between the medical data and the magnetic field exposure. Health data Study population Magnetic field measurements Results Medical questionnaire [[Table - 3] and [Table - 4] show the results of cardiac factors extracted from electrocardiograms in the two groups. No significant difference was observed between the two groups ( P > 0.05). The results of EEG revealed that four workers had abnormal electroencephalogram, two from the Chloralkali and two from the perchlorine plants. This shows that no difference exists from EEG point of view between the two groups. [Table - 5] demonstrates the frequency of reported subjective symptoms among the exposed and the control groups. Statistical analyses revealed that in spite of higher frequency rate of subjective symptoms reported by the exposed workers, no significant difference was observed for most variables. Statistical analyses demonstrated that only frequency rates of nervousness and fatigue were higher in the exposed group as compared to the control group ( P < 0.01). Magnetic field measurements and dosimetry Magnetic flux density was founded to be very close to zero in the perchlorine plant from where the control workers came. Time-weighted average exposure level to static magnetic field for the five job titles studied in the Chloralkali plant is presented in [Table - 6]. As shown in [Table - 6], the cell coordinator has the highest level of exposure. Discussion The results demonstrated that the frequency rate of nervousness and physical fatigue were higher among the exposed group ( P < 0.01). It is in agreement with the results reported.[3] These two subjective symptoms could, therefore, be related to static magnetic field exposure. The results of clinical examinations and blood tests revealed that there was no significant difference between the two groups. Cardiac and mental activity followed the same pattern in the both the groups and no significant difference was observed. Fields measurements indicated that static magnetic flux density, in all locations of the Chloralkali plant was well below the ceiling value (2T) recommended by ACGIH.[7] On the basis of the measurements, the flux density lowered with the increase of height from the floor. This was because of the distance from the sources (cells), which were located on the floor. The difference between the magnetic flux density at 30 and 160 cm was found to be 20% of the value measured at 30 cm height. This could result in the reduction of the effects of static magnetic flux on the heart and brain known as sensitive organs to magnetic fields. Dosimetry performed, demonstrated that 8-hour TWA exposures of the workers in the Chloralkali plant did not exceed the TLV-TWA value recommended by ACGIH for the whole body (60 mT).[7] The highest TWA exposure occurred for the cells coordinator, who spent most of his working time near the cells. The board man who worked in the control room had the lowest TWA exposure level. Conclusion The data obtained in this study is in basic agreement with the results reported by Marsh et al.[3] and in disagreement with the results of Vyalov′s study.[4] None of the medical parameters studied were found to be dependant on magnetic field exposure at the Chloralkali plant. The only subjective effects found to be associated with exposure to the magnetic field were nervousness and fatigue. Generally, both the groups were found to be in good health. The effects, which were found, are slight and any future studies must be highly refined or must have a large sample size in order to detect them.References
Copyright 2005 - Indian Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine The following images related to this document are available:Photo images[oe05018t5.jpg] [oe05018t3.jpg] [oe05018t1.jpg] [oe05018t4.jpg] [oe05018t2.jpg] [oe05018t6.jpg] |
|