|
Indian Journal of Plastic Surgery
Medknow Publications on behalf of Indian Journal of Plastic Surgery
ISSN: 0970-0358 EISSN: 1998-376x
Vol. 36, Num. 1, 2003, pp. 53-54
|
Indian Journal of Plastic Surgery, Vol. 36, No. 1, Jan-June, 2003, pp.
53-54
Letter to Editor
We need to think and act
Dr. Ajay Singh
Consultant Plastic Surgeon, Ranchi, Lucknow.
Code Number: pl03015
Sir,
During the Annual conference of APSI
(Bihar-Jharkhand) on 15-16th Feb 2003, the honourable Health
minister of Jharkhand, Dr. Dinesh Kumar Sarangi, in his
Inaugural address raised few very sensitive points, which
though sounded bit crude but was very thought provoking
I am quoting (highlighted) few important parts of
that speech which is very much true in our part of
the country. My purpose of sending this is to take
opinion of our other Plastic Surgeon colleagues
senior, contemporary and juniors, what do they feel about
this. Sir recently I was in Delhi and I was surprised to
see that simple MBBS were doing Plastic surgery
practice saying them self as cosmetic surgeon. Why to go far
a relative of mine is doing that in Delhi and is
getting services of our regular plastic surgeon as his
assistant. Are we not doing injustice to this speciality, can't
we do some thing to stop such act through our association. If needed for the political and
MCI support my services will always be there.
Dr. Ajay Singh
Consultant Plastic Surgeon, Ranchi, Lucknow.
Dear friends,
I am honoured, as today I am amongst a surgical
super speciality group. I my self wished to be here the day
I knew about this conference, just to know
something new. The plastic surgery is now passing the era
of microsurgery, LASER surgery and endoscopes
surgery. Robotics is in pipeline too. We are importing the
latest from abroad the same, which we had long back. I
feel it worth mentioning here that, In 600 B.C in the
city of Varanasi the father of modern surgery
SUSHRUTA was regularly doing reconstructive plastic surgery
of nose, for those who had under gone the
punishment of adultery. That time the nose chopping was
the punishment for this sexual misconduct. The Rhinoplasty done by him is named "Indian
Rhinoplasty " in which he used forehead flap for
nose
reconstruction. The use of honey paste on wounds
was his method of burn treatment. Mention of skin
grafting and genital deformity correction method too
are mentioned in SUSRUTA SANHITA [16,32,fpc
pa.297]. The Kangra valley was world famous place for
EAR reconstruction. The patients who use to
undergo punishment of ear amputation in Middle East
mainly Persia were regularly treated at these centres in
pre mughal and mughal era. But we could not retain
our skill due to regular invasions linked problems in
the nation. I said this on to impress that it was we
who started this surgical craftsmanship, and we are
proud of it. Because the father of modern Plastic
SURGERY Sir. Harold Gillies too on a later date
acknowledged Sushruta's method of plastic surgical process.
The word PLASTICOS it self means remodelling or reconstruction so he concentrated
him self
on reconstruction. Thus basically plastic surgery to
the best of my knowledge is reconstructive surgery and
it is the surgery for those who have been deprived
of any part of their body, which either the nature
denied then of accident deprived them.
The congenital deformities from lip, palate.
Other parts of the face, hand, foot and the genitals. Or
the part or parts lost in accidents or body part
got deformed due to burns. Thus it was a boon for
the poor ailing masses. I said "was" as Gradually
the reconstruction expanded to the reconstruction according to desire, and desire crossed the limits
of possibilities. I think here we got detracted. The
plastic surgery started getting status of five star surgery
and we missed the masses for which this super
speciality was evolved. I may not be correct in my
statement, but with all due regards to my seniors, friends
and others, till date plastic surgery has not reached
to the real needy. Till date plastic surgery is
considered as surgery of stars be of film, fame or politics.
The failure was improper communication and lack of awareness.
The films, magazines made some false notion and till
date no one ever tried to remove the myths from
the masses regarding the process and cost of surgery.
So ultimately the subject got lost. Result, that it
remained confined to one and half medical colleges in
unified Bihar in last 40 years and after Jharkhand we have
non. Not because the need is not there, but whenever
it was proposed every body gave a sarcastic smile as
if what rubbish you are taking. Why government
will open a department of affluent in its medical
college? This is the question they put to us. It is due to
non-aware ness of the masses for this wing of
medical science and public representatives come from
them only.
To start with medical therapy was a mission, then
it became profession then business and now
finally commercialisation by few. The worst influence
of business came on super speciality branches, be it
renal transplant or by pass surgery. These vices
too influenced plastic surgery in the name of
cosmetic surgery. The surgical beautification has become
a medical industry. The black ships of profession
defined plastic surgery as only cosmetic surgery and in the
mad rush of money the basic were left the actual and
real roots were forgotten. The result being
genital deformities went to genital-urinary surgeons and
lip palate went to oral [dental] surgeons, hand
surgery went to orthopaedics, facial injury to ENT
specialist, neck surgery to oncologist and the plastic
surgeons are left with burns, grafting and flap surgery. It is
pain full to note that a super speciality became
dependent speciality of orthopaedics and general surgery, who
did it? IT IS YOU TO ANSWER (SIC).
Looking good is desire of all, it is not wrong But
the givers should know his limit and, the recipient
should know what they are getting. There should be
full transparency in our approach, I am sorry to say it
not there today. We give hopes of impossible result
IN plastic surgery and out come is bad name to the profession and speciality. It may be practice of
few, but as you work on skin surface the result is to
be audited by the society not you. So please ask
your fellows to restrain your self from these
petty temptations as temptation of few millimetres
may result into disaster.
My deliberation is not to discourage you but to
caution you what masses feel for this speciality. When I
was coming for this meeting, my own men said to me,
"you are going to these surgical sculpters at the right age,
as very soon you may need them". The comment
sounds innocent but not the feeling. It is not good for
this supreme speciality for which I had the fascination
since my student days in medical college. Destiny took me
to political side. I may be of some help in getting
this department in our medical colleges in Jharkhand, but
I am bit shaky in this statement of mine as I am fully
aware of this fact that patron of this Plastic
surgeon's association himself is a Plastic surgeon and
cabinet minister Dr. Ashok Kumar, the other plastic
surgeons too are equally influential, if they couldn't do any
thing then where do I stand. The Association of
Plastic surgeons of India, Bihar -Jharkhand branch is still
united like sesames twins, it is a healthy trend for this
subject. The effort too should be united if we really want to
have this branch which started in Patna Medical College
in 1963 and could not cross even river Ganges till date.
But a ray of hope is always there I know a few who
are trying to propagate the basics of plastic surgery,
this silver lining is giving me impetus to try once
for creation of this important unit in at least each
medical college of Jharkhand, But at least demand should
come from your end. I need this department in
Jharkhand for my poor burn victims, for have-nots
having congenital deformities and victims of
industrial accidents. We need microsurgical units, we
have industries and mines how can they afford
private treatment we need it not as luxury but as
necessity. We need this department for what it was meant.
Wishing you all a very comfortable, hospitable,
and productive stay at Jamshedpur, during the
conference, the first after formation of Jharkhand. Hope
this conference will give awareness to the masses
regarding the actual scope of this subject. In this post
valentine day a message of love to all our guest and good
wishes to my colleague of Jharkhand who always stood by
me when and where I needed them."
Dr. Dinesh Kumar Sarangi
Hon. Health Minister, Jharkhand.
Copyright 2003 - Indian Journal of Plastic Surgery.
|