|
Colombia Médica, Vol. 41, No. 4, October-December, 2010, pp. 336-343 Analysis of HLA-A, HLA-B, HLA-DRB1 allelic, genotypic, and haplotypic frequencies in colombian population Análisis de frecuencias alélicas, genotípicas y haplotípicas HLA -A, HLA-B, HLA-DRB1 en población colombiana Yazmin Rocío Arias-Murillo, Bacteriol, MSc1,2, Miguel Ángel Castro-Jiménez, MD, MSc2,3, María Fernanda Ríos-Espinosa, Bacteriol1, Juan Javier López-Rivera, MD, MSc1, Sandra Johanna Echeverry-Coral, Bacteriol Esp1, Oscar Martínez-Nieto, MD4 1Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Clinical Pathology Research Group
(INPAC), Clínica Colsanitas SA, Bogotá, DC, Colombia. e-mail: ariasmurillo@hotmail.com mafecita74@hotmail.com jlopez@colsanitas.com jecheverry@colsanitas.com Received for publication September 19, 2009 Code Number: rc10048 SUMMARY Introduction: The high
polymorphism of the HLA system allows its typification to be used as
valuable tool in establishing association to various illnesses, immune
and genetic profiles; it also provides a guide to identifying
compatibility among donors and receptors of organs transplants. Keywords: HLA; Genotype; Haplotype; Allele; Gene RESUMEN Introducción: El
alto polimorfismo del sistema HLA, hace que su tipificación sea
una herramienta de gran valor al establecer asociación con
diferentes enfermedades, patrones inmunológicos,
antropogenéticos, así como para establecer probabilidades
de encontrar donantes compatibles con receptores de diferentes tipos de
trasplante de órganos. Palabras clave: HLA; Genotipos; Haplotipos; Genes; Alelos. The human leukocyte antigen system (HLA) of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) contains a numerous family of genes located on the short arm of the 6th chromosome (6p21.1-6p21.3). These antigens are expressed in autosomal and codominant manner and they are inherited from both parents, which is why each individual expresses an antigen of paternal origin and one of maternal origin for each of the loci1. The high polymorphism of the HLA system and advancements in molecular biology have permitted for the typifying of these antigens to become important tools in establishing associations of susceptibility or resistance to disease, development of tumor processes; playing an important role in understanding the variability of the immune response and determinant on the survival of organ or tissue transplants2-8. Because the allele frequencies and the disequilibrium patterns vary within a given population, the characterization of these molecules and the determination of their frequencies gain much pertinence and permits establishing parameters of association to disease in the population, which has a predictive value in managing self-immune diseases like Systemic Erythematosus Lupus (SEL) and Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA), also becoming an important tool for the distribution of organs donated in the different transplant groups in the National Donation Network, as well as having an additional usefulness in estimating times the receptors must remain in the waiting list9,10. Most of the Latin American populations studied are of indigenous origin or barely mixed11-15. The population treated in the Molecular Biology laboratory at Clinica Colsanitas SA for HLA typifying comes from different Colombian cities, offering an opportunity to determine the allele, genotype, and haplotype frequencies in patients of diverse origins. MATERIALS AND METHODS Design and population. This is a retrospective descriptive study, which included 561 patients treated in the cities of Bogota, Cali, Barranquilla, Medellin, Villavicencio, Armenia, Bucaramanga, and Neiva. The patients underwent HLA A,-B and -DRB1 typifying in the Molecular Biology laboratory at Clinica Colsanitas between January 2004 and August 2008. Definition of variables. The variables of interest for this study were: demographic characteristics (gender, age, place of birth), alleles for each of the 3 loci analyzed (HLA A*, HLA B*, HLA DRB1*), as well as the genotypes and haplotypes found. Procedure of HLA typifying. DNA extraction was carried out with the Wizard® Genomic DNA Purification kit, adhering to the protocol recommended by the manufacturer from the white blood cell layer obtained from blood samples anticoagulated with EDTA or from spleen fragments contained in sterile containers, hermetically sealed in an RPMI medium supplemented with fetal calf serum. The final concentration for each of the samples was adjusted at 120 ng/µl and then the HLA-A, HLA-B, and HLA-DRB1 genes were determined via single specific primer polymerase chain reaction (SSP PCR) as per manufacturer instructions (Biotest ABDR SSPtray). Thereafter, electrophoresis was conducted on the amplification products in agarose gels at 2% dyed with SYBR® Safe DNA gel (Invitrogen). An analysis was performed of amplified bands by using Quantity One (BIORAD), leaving a photo record and the allele assignation was made by employing the tables provided, as well as the Biotest SSP typing software. Statistical analysis. Proportions were calculated to summarize the qualitative variables. The normality of the age variable was evaluated by using the Shapiro-Wilk test and summarized with a mean. Homologation of the degree of resolution of the typifying to two digits was done on the data base for further analysis of allele, genotype, and haplotype frequencies16. The p values lower than or equal to 0.05 were considered significant. The allele, genotype, and haplotype frequencies and those corresponding to demographic characteristics were calculated in the Stata 9.0/SE program. The Linkage disequilibrium between loci pairs, the Fisher fixation index, and the Hardy Weinberg equilibrium were estimated by employing the GENEPOP genotype analysis package version 1.217, which bears in mind the modifications to the Markov chain algorithm described by Guo and Thompson17. Ethical considerations. This study used data from patients whose samples had already been taken and processed; hence, there was no additional risk. The confidentiality of the information was strictly protected. The samples had been taken after obtaining signed informed consent from the patients or their families and through medical request. RESULTS Demographic characteristics. Of the total number of patients included in the study, we obtained information on the place of birth from 443 patients; who came from 28 departments in Colombia, with a greater representation from Cundinamarca, followed by Boyaca, Santander, Huila, Atlantico, and Cesar. The population distribution per department can be seen in Table 1. Of the individuals included, 57.4% were male and 42.6% female, the mean age was 38 years of age with a range from 1 to 85 years. Within the population analyzed, there were patients who attended outpatient consultation to have the sample taken, as well as patients who were under pre-transplant study by the group at Clinica Colsanitas SA and cadaveric donors from the 1st regional facilities of the transplant network typified by the renal transplant group at Clinica Reina Sofia. Allele frequencies. It was possible to determine 19, 28, and 15 alleles of the HLA A-B-DRB1 loci, respectively, in the population studied. The most frequent alleles in the HLA-A locus were A*24 (26.2%), A*02 (26%), A*01 (7.6%), A*68 (6.5%), and A*29 (6.4%); followed by A*03, A*39, A*33, A*11, A31, A*23, A*26, and A*32 with frequencies over 1% (Table 2). The most frequent alleles in the HLA- B locus were B*35(22.7%), B*44 (11.1%), B*07 (8.6%), B*51(8%); followed by B*40, B*14, B*39, B*15, B*18, B*38, B*13, B*48, B*27, B49, B*58, B*57, and B*45 with frequencies over 1% (Table 3). The most frequent alleles in the HLA-DRB1 locus were DRB1*04 (24.1%), DRB1*15 (11.3%), DRB1*07 (11.1%), DRB1*01 (10.3%), and DRB1*13 (8.3%); followed by DRB1*11, DRB1*08, DRB1*14, DRB1*16, and DRB1*17 with frequencies over 3% (Table 4). Genotype frequencies. We observed 90 different genotypes for the HLA-A locus, 144 genotypes for HLA-B, and 99 for HLA-DRB1; the most frequent genotypes for the HLA-A locus were: A*02,24 (14.2%), A*24,24 (7.3%), A*02,02(6.1%), A*02,68 (4.3%), and A*01,02 (3.95%). Graphic 1 shows the genotypes for each of the loci analyzed, which reveal frequencies over 1%. The genotypes revealing the highest frequencies for the HLA B locus were: B*07,35 (5.53%), B*35,44 (4.63%), B*35,35 (4.28%), and B*14,35 (3.21%); for the HLA DRB1 locus, the most observed genotypes were: DRB1*01,04 and DRB1*04,04 (6.95%); followed by DRB1*04,15 (4.3%), DRB1*04,13(4.1%), DRB1*04,11 (3.6%), and DRB1*04,07 (3.6%). The Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium for each locus was tested through the GENEPOP program, obtaining a deficiency of heterozygous individuals for DRB1 genotypes with p: 0.0091 and reaching a Fisher fixation index of + 0.0344; while the genotype frequencies for the HLA A and HLA B loci were within the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (Table 5). The linkage disequilibrium values among the haplotypes analyzed were significant, obtaining p= 0.00992 between the HLA A and HLA B loci, p= 0.0012 for the HLA A and HLA DR loci, and p= 0.026 for the HLA B and HLA DR loci. Haplotype frequencies. The most commonly found HLA A, B haplotypes in the population studied were: HLA A*24 B*35 (9.2%); followed by A*02 B35 (5.2%), A*02 B*51 (3.1%), A*24 B*40 (2.9%), A*02 B*44 (2.68%). The most frequent HLA B, DR haplotypes were: HLA B*35 DRB1*04 (7.8%), B*44 DRB1*07 (3.38%), B*07, and DRB1*15 (2.6%), and for HLA A, DR: A*24 DRB1*04 (8.1%), A*2 DRB1*04 (7.4%), and A*02 DRB1*15 (3.2%). The haplotypes showing frequencies over 1% are described in Graphic 2. DISCUSSION It was possible to determine the level of the A locus for 19 alleles, similar to those reported by Ossa et al.14, for a population from the city of Bogotá. When comparing with a study reported in cadaveric donors conducted in the city of Medellín, it was determined that the A43 and A80 alleles were not identified, and which were observed in this study. The frequencies obtained were similar for the first two places of the A* locus as those reported by Ossa et al.14, and Rodriguez et al.9, for a Colombian population; however, differences in alleles were found, like: A*01, A*68, A*29, which show higher frequencies (7.6%, 6.5%, 6.4%) with respect to that reported in the Medellin, Colombia study (5.1%, 5.6%, 3.7%). The analyses made by Ossa et al.14, reveal similar frequencies for the HLA A locus to those reported in the current study. The differences observed in relation to the Medellín study may arise because even though it is a Colombian population, they present information from a specific city; while in our case, the individuals come from different parts of the nation, which makes it a heterogeneous population. The results obtained in this study correlate to those previously reported for a Latin American population, where the alleles with the greatest frequency were A02, A24, A01, and A6814,15,18. Only 28 alleles were identified for the B locus; while in prior studies conducted in Colombian populations, 43 alleles were reported for this locus9,14. This marked difference is attributable to the resolution of the technique used in typifying HLA in our study, given that is some instances such resolution did not permit differentiation of the B15, B14, and B40 splits in the allelic variants currently considered. Of the total population typified as B14 (6.2%), 3.2% were differentiated as B64, B65, and B14, where B65 corresponded to the greatest frequency, but since it was not possible to define such in a broad percentage, they were reported for the current study as B14. The HLA B*15 corresponded to 3.3% of the population. For this allele, we were not able to identify in all typifying events the specificity B62, B63, B70, B71, B72, and B75, because of the resolution of the kit used in typifying. Thus, the B15 frequency we found is higher than that reported in previous studies in Colombia. As well as for the B14 and B15 alleles, for the B40 allele we were not able to differentiate between the B61 and B60 alleles; hence, the frequency found for B40 is a reflection of the 3 alleles (B40, B60, and B61). It is important to stress that the B*46, B*47, B*67, and B*78 alleles whose frequency is equal to or lower than 0.2 %, were not found in the population analyzed in this study, contrasting with that reported by Rodriguez et al.9, which is possible bearing in mind that the size of our sample is smaller than that analyzed in the city of Medellín. The most common alleles for the HLA B, B*35, and B*44 loci basically correspond to that reported in prior studies in a Colombian population9 and correlate with the frequencies mostly observed in populations of Uruguay, Peru, and Argentina11,12,15; nevertheless, there are some differences with that reported by Ossa et al.14 in population from the city of Bogotá, which may be due to the heterogeneity of the population in the current study. At the DRB1* locus level, we found 15 alleles, with the most common being: DRB1*04, DRB1*15, DRB1*07, DRB1*01, DRB1*13, DRB1*11, DRB1*08, DRB1*14, DRB1*16, and DRB1*17, which are also the ones found with the greatest frequency in prior studies in Colombian and Latin populations, although Rodriguez et al.9, found a higher frequency (13.4%) for the DRB1*13 allele and a lower frequency (10%) for the DRB1*15 allele in relation to those obtained in this study (8.3%) and (11.3%), respectively. When comparing our results to the study with the population in the city of Bogota published by Ossa et al.14, there are small differences regarding the order of the alleles found. Upon reviewing the information on haplotypes found in the population studied, we have that the most frequent HLA A, B haplotypes were A*24 B*35, A*2 B*35, A*2 B*51, and A*29 B*44, which correlates with the reports found in studies conducted on Latin populations19; and haplotypes A*02 B*44 and A*02 B*07 with important frequencies in this study are reported most frequently in Caucasian populations. Regarding HLA B DRB1 haplotypes, the first two places were occupied by HLA B*35 DRB1*04 and B*44 DRB1*07, correlating with that reported by Rodríguez et al.9 and they are the haplotypes found in greater frequency in a Hispanic population19,20. It is worth mentioning that since B40 is an important component of high-frequency haplotypes, it is necessary to employ techniques that permit differentiating the B60, B61, and B40 allelic variants, which this study could not establish; hence, the haplotypes in which the B40 is included may be actually made up of any of the corresponding variants and, thus, in prior studies A*24 B*61 occupy a greater frequency, which would be included in the A*24 B*40 haplotype reported in our study because of the resolution of the technique used. The results of the current study correspond mostly to that previously reported for Colombia, where we found a typical component of Latin population with an important Caucasian influence; nevertheless, the differences evidence the variations in the size and origin of the population studied, as well as the important influence of the resolution of the technique used in typifying. Given the heterogeneity of the population analyzed in the current study, it is important to keep the following aspects in mind: these were mostly patients attending outpatient consultation for whom typifying was requested for pre-transplant study in different cities of the nation, they belonged to groups of patients studied to be included in the waiting list for renal transplant or suspect of clinical association to a specific disease, and in a minor proportion they were cadaveric donors from the 1st regional facilities of the National Transplant Network. All these factors may undoubtedly be associated to the results obtained in this study; however, it should be noted that of patients in renal pre-transplant study only 10% are related to self-immune diseases and, generally, HLA-disease association studies estimate that the differential association of different alleles in different populations is merely a reflection of the different distribution of frequencies of the HLA haplotypes or alleles in said populations. For this reason, more than having healthy individuals or patients in the population the origin does set an important relevant factor with respect to the distribution of frequencies. Conducting this study permitted us to know the genotype, allele, and haplotype frequencies of the population analyzed and offers us useful tools to establish probabilities of finding compatible donors for patients in waiting lists for renal transplant. Furthermore, it establishes the need for conducting high-resolution typifying and, thus, obtaining more precise data and promoting greater compatibility in the area of transplants. Conflict of interest. None of the authors has conflicts of interest related to this study. REFERENCES
The following images related to this document are available:Photo images[rc10048f1.jpg] [rc10048t4.jpg] [rc10048t5.jpg] [rc10048t2.jpg] [rc10048t1.jpg] [rc10048t3.jpg] [rc10048f2.jpg] |
|