|
African Journal of Reproductive Health
Women's Health and Action Research Centre
ISSN: 1118-4841
Vol. 7, Num. 3, 2003, pp. 92-100
|
Untitled Document
African Journal of Reproductive Health, Vol. 7, No. 3, December, 2003,
pp.
92-100
Economic Empowerment and Reproductive Behaviour of Young
Women in Osun State, Nigeria
Emancipation économique et le comportement
reproductif
des jeunes femmes dans l'etat d'Osun, Nigeria
Oluwole Odutolu1, Adebola Adedimeji2,
Omobola Odutolu3, Olatunde Baruwa3 and Funmilayo
Olatidoye3
1AIDS Prevention Initiative in Nigeria, Ibadan,
Nigeria. 2Department of Sociology, University of Ibadan, Nigeria. 3Life
Vanguards, Osogbo, Nigeria.
Correspondence: Dr Oluwole Odutolu, AIDS Prevention Initiative in Nigeria, Plot
990, NAL Boulevard, Central Business District, Abuja, Nigeria. Tel: 234 9 6704004
E-mail: apin@cgiar.org
Code Number: rh03043
Abstract
Women are increasingly being recognised as equal partners
in development. However, there is a growing awareness that negative health,
social and economic consequences act as barriers in their efforts to contribute
to sustainable development. Consequently, to fully harness the potentials of
women in this regard, these barriers have to be addressed. This paper utilises
qualitative data collected as part of an intervention programme designed to
increase access to reproductive health information/services and economic resources
among young women in Osogbo, Nigeria. The aim was to provide reproductive health
information and training in basic business skills and micro-credit facilities
to enable beneficiaries to establish private businesses. Findings from the
study highlight the importance of the relationship between female education,
access to economic resources as a means of furthering empowerment of women
especially in terms of their reproductive behaviour. The paper argues that
increased access to resources is a major factor toward ensuring the much desired
empowerment. (Afr J Reprod Health 2003; 7[3]: 92-100)
Résumé
Emancipation économique et le comportement reproductif
des jeunes femmes dans l'etat d'Osun, Nigeria. Les femmes sont de plus
eu plus reconnues comme des partenaires égaux en matière du
développement. Pourtant, il y a une conscience croissante du fait
que la santé négative et les conséquences sociales et économiques
constituent des obstacles dans leurs efforts pour contribuer au développement
viable. Par conséquent, à fin de profiter pleinement des potentiels
des femmes à cet égard, il faut résoudre ces obstacles.
On se sert dans cette étude, de données qualitative recueillies
dans le cadre d'un programme d'intervention conçu pour augmenter l'accès à l'inforamtion/au
service de la santé reproductive et les ressoruces économiques
parmi les jeunes femmes à Oshogbo, Nigéria. L'Objectif était
de fournir l'information concernant la santé reproductive et d'assurer
la formation dans les techniques des affaires de base ainsi que les facilités
micro-crédits, à fin de permettre à l'audience visée
d'établir des entreprises privées. Les résultats de
l'étude soulignent l'importance des rapports entre l'éducation
féminine et l'accès aux ressources économiques comme
moyen de promouvoir davantage l'émancipation de la femme en ce qui
concerne leur comportement reproductif. L'article soutient que l'augmentation
de l'accès aux ressources est un facteur majeur pour assurer l'emancipation
tant désirée. (Rev Afr Santé Reprod 2003; 7[3]:
92-100)
Key Words: Young women, empowerment, reproductive health
Introduction and Background
One of the significant milestones of the twentieth century
in the field of population and development is the recognition of women as equal
partners in development efforts in all societies of the world. Two major events
of the last decade, the International Conference on Population and Development
(Cairo, 1994) and the World Women Conference (Beijing, 1995), were instrumental
in this regard. At these meetings, it was recognised that issues affecting
the reproductive health of women are linked to wider issues of economic and
educational status and gender equality. Gender equity and women empowerment
were particularly emphasised as a catalyst for promoting and sustaining economic
growth and development.1 By locating women within the context of
global development, these conferences have encouraged women to openly discuss
issues that affect their status and reproductive health. A major response to this development is a review of programmes
and strategies aimed at improving the reproductive health of women. This response
has been in form of increased research and programme focus on the reproductive
health needs of women, especially girls. This interest has been fired by a
growing awareness of the negative health, social and economic consequences
of early sexual activity and childbearing including unintended pregnancies,
unsafe abortions, sexually transmitted diseases (STDs), acquired immune deficiency
syndrome (AIDS) and decreased economic power among women. Available data from
the Population Reference Bureau2 illustrate the magnitude of the
problem worldwide. About 15 million young women aged 15-19 years give birth
every year, accounting for more than 10% of births worldwide. About two million
adolescent women in developing countries have illegal unsafe abortions each
year and at least 10% of abortions worldwide occur among women aged 15-19 years.
In addition, rates of STD infection among adolescents are high and their risk
of contracting HIV is growing rapidly. In many countries, women aged 15-24
years account for 40% of all new HIV infections.
Although power is a significant dimension of all human
relationships, few studies have examined how power operates in adolescent sexual
relation-
ships. Adolescent relationships are often assumed to occur in a context of mutual
choice and benefit for both partners, particularly in western societies where
women's movement has made great strides in extending equal rights to women
and men.3 In recent years, however, it has been recognised that power
struggles continue to play an important role
in courtship and dating relationships.4
In developing countries, issues of power and reproductive
decision-making have come under closer examination as young women's vulnerability
to AIDS and unintended pregnancy has increased. Studies5 suggest
that culturally-based gender roles that reinforce male rights over sexual and
reproductive decision-making can contribute in an important way to female adolescents'
vulnerability to unintended pregnancies and STDs including AIDS. Adolescent
girls are often engaged in relationships with older men, creating a potential
for unequal power in relationships. This in turn reduces the ability of adolescent
girls to negotiate sex with condom and contraceptive use.6 In many
instances, the threat of male violence can also contribute to the pressure
on teenage girls to agree to unsafe sexual practices. Poor adolescent girls
who depend on sexual relationships for part of their economic survival are
particularly vulnerable since they may have little leverage around such issues
as safe sex and condom use. The importance of empowering women during adolescence cannot
be overemphasised. The social costs of young people's inability to exert control
over their lives and fulfil their educational, economic and reproductive goals
can be enormous. Women who become parents as teenagers experience more social
and economic disadvantage throughout their lives than those who delay childbearing.
They are less likely to complete their education, be employed, earn higher
wages and be happily married; they are also likely to have larger families.7 Ultimately,
pregnancies can also impede women's attainment of healthy living as evidenced
by unsafe, and sometimes fatal, abortions in many countries where abortion
is restricted. As gender identities are often crystallised during adolescence,
empowering women in the early stages of their lives can lay the foundation
for achieving a positive balance of power in marriage
and for women's enhanced social and economic position later in
life.5
Empowerment, according to Batliwala,8 is the process
by which the powerless gain greater control over the circumstances of their
lives. It includes control over resources (physical, human and intellectual)
and over ideology (beliefs, values and attitudes). It means not only greater
extrinsic control but also a growing intrinsic capability, greater self-confidence
and an inner transmission of one's consciousness that enables one to overcome
external barriers to accessing resources or changing traditional ideology.
Empowerment is about the transformation of power relations between men and
women at four distinct levels, namely, the household/family, the community,
the market and the state. Such transformation, viewed in different contexts
of power, includes access to and control over material and other resources
(economic, legal, institutional and social) as well as a possible and measurable
change in self-perception and confidence.9 Empowerment can also
be viewed as a means to an end, incorporating the improvement of quality of
life of everyone in society through specific demographic outcomes (decline
in fertility, maternal mortality, rate of unsafe abortion, etc), or as an end
in itself, directly resulting in improvement of women's rights and status in
societies.10 Two other important dimensions to the understanding of the
concept of empowerment are decision-making power and the view of empowerment
in relational terms. While the former stresses the crucial role of women, the
latter focuses on relationship between empowerment of women and its impact
on men in different societies. Empowerment is context-specific, varying for
women in different cultures, situations and stages of their life cycles. Genuine
empowerment must necessarily include these aspects. Thus, as Seen and Batliwala10 argued,
any development programme that changes women's control over resources must
also build their confidence in themselves, if women are to have the resilience
and motivation to retain and build on that control. Similarly, programmes that
change awareness without leading to greater access to material resources can
lead to frustration and high dropout rates.
The World Health Organization defines repro-ductive health as a state of complete
physical, mental and social well being in all matters relating to the reproductive
system and processes. The most important aspects of reproductive health include
family planning, safe motherhood, safe and satisfying sex, prevention and treatment
of reproductive tract infections and sexually transmitted diseases, as well
as the decision-making power associated with
these. Thus, as Adedokun11 argues, the extent to which women have
and can exercise power of decision in the timing of marriage, the number and
spacing of their children and access to quality reproductive health services
are some of the important indicators of the level of empowerment in different
societies.
Given the foregoing, this paper examines the relationship
between empowerment (defined in terms of increased access to reproductive health
information and economic resources) and reproductive behaviour among women
aged 19-25 years. Data for the study was obtained from part of a large-scale
intervention programme that was implemented by Life Vanguards, a non-governmental,
non-profit making organisation based in Osogbo, Nigeria. The intervention programme
was designed to increase access to reproductive health information and services
and economic resources among young women who had received formal education
in tertiary institutions and those who had completed training as apprentices
in various vocations. There were two components of the intervention programme. The
first sought to increase access to reproductive health information and services
among the target population. The second sought to involve the provision of
training in basic business management, survival strategies and micro credit
facilities to a selected group of recent graduates of tertiary institutions
who were unemployed and those who had completed a period of apprenticeship
in tailoring, hairdressing, fashion design, e.t.c., from the larger group.
Loans were disbursed after the participants had successfully developed and
presented a feasibility study of their business plans. The modality for repaying
the loan was jointly worked out by programme beneficiaries and officials of
the implementing NGO.
The intervention programme spanned a two-year period, June
1999 to July 2001, after which an assessment of impact on knowledge, attitudes
and practices of beneficiaries was undertaken by an independent assessor. The
authors of this paper, based on empirical evidence, argue that empower-ment
is important in securing the reproductive and sexual rights of young women,
which in turn affect their perceptions of issues, their health, reproductive
behaviour and to a large extent that of their male partners.
Data and Methods Qualitative data was generated. Focus group discussion (FGD)
guides were designed and used to conduct interviews with groups of young women
who had benefited from the first and second components of programme implementation.
FGD was also held with their parents and opinion leaders in the selected communities
within Osogbo, Ife and Iree towns of Osun State. A total of eight focus group
discussions were held with each group consisting of between eight and ten participants
who had homogeneous characteristics. In other words, four FGDs were held for
each category of graduates and non-graduates. Out of the total of eight FGDs
held, four were held in Osogbo, being the largest of the three communities
with the largest number of beneficiaries. In addition to the FGDs, case studies
of beneficiaries who had set up their private businesses were conducted. A
total of five case studies were conducted.
Field activities were undertaken between August and September
2001. The guides used consisted of issues that examined knowledge of reproductive
and sexual activities, attitudes and practices of contraception, knowledge
of sexually transmitted infections and HIV/AIDS, sexual health negotiation
skills, myths and misconceptions surrounding sexuality issues, and health-seeking
behaviour. Additionally, issues of community perception of adolescent sexual
and reproductive behaviour, the linkage between economic conditions and
development aspect of the programme and sexual health were included in
the instruments.
Project evaluation was designed to examine the impact
of the project on beneficiaries. Specifically, the evaluation procedure sought
to determine the impact of information, skill building and the micro credit
scheme on sexual and reproductive
behaviour of female adolescents. One major hypothesis was tested: that economic
empowerment through entrepreneurial skill development and availability of credit
facilities to start a business venture could significantly alter the perception
and behaviour of young women in sexual and reproductive issues. Key indicators
in these areas were assessed after a period of project implementation.
The intervention was expected to meet the following objectives:
- Improve the reproductive health knowledge of the
target population.
- Improve accessibility to reproductive health services
among the target population and eliminate all barriers to the use of
these services.
- Develop and strengthen entrepreneurial capabi-lity
of young women and empower them economically.
- Improve their self-efficacy and skill acquisition,
thereby reducing susceptibility to pressures to initiate or continue
sexual activity as a result of economic deprivation.
The data were transcribed, edited and pro-cessed using Microsoft
WordPad, after which they were coded. Where necessary, statements
were quoted verbatim in order to demonstrate the importance of opinions
expressed by participants. Data processing was done with Open Code, a
software for analysing qualitative data.
Findings A critical aspect of the programme was the entre-preneurial
skill development. This aspect was initiated because of the pervasive belief
that female adolescents succumb to pressures to initiate sexual activity early
and make wrong decisions about sexual and reproductive health issues for economic
reasons. Consequently, the programme planners believed that efforts to address
the sexual and reproductive health of young women must begin by empowering
them economically and providing access to opportunities for improving their
social and economic conditions.
The result of this was the entrepreneurial skill development component that was
built into the programme. There were two levels of training; the graduate training,
which targeted those who already had tertiary education, and the non-graduate
training, which targeted those who had completed appren-ticeship training in
the informal sector. The curriculum of training was similar for both graduates
and non-graduates. The overall goal was to make available to them credit facilities
with which they could establish/strengthen their individual business ventures.
In several cases, some of them could not effectively practice the skills they
had acquired while a few others who had started their private businesses were
not making progress because of a lack
of economic resources.
Although all the businesses selected in some of the case studies
were operating on a small scale, they were nevertheless doing well. This conclusion
is based on the results of assessments carried out on the beneficiaries. The
beneficiaries indicated that they were able to manage their businesses well
and had acquired useful skills during the entrepreneurial skills training programme. Available information revealed that the exposure of participants
to basic business survival and management skills has enhanced their efficiency
in the day-to-day management of their businesses in addition to the training
they received in their various vocations. They were also trained in book keeping
to enable them to manage their funds properly. Some of the participants were
of the opinion that without such additional training it would have been more
difficult for them to successfully manage their businesses financially. As
a result of the training, beneficiaries were able to account for their overhead
and maintenance costs and the profit they make. One of the participants in
the case studies made the following comments:
Ah ... for me, the training programme has been very useful
to the extent that I am able to manage my own finances ... something I was
previously unable to do. At a point, it was difficult to know the amount
of profit I was making in this business simply because I could not render
an account of what goes in and what comes out! (Non-graduate participant,
Osogbo, September 2001)
All those interviewed were beneficiaries of the loan scheme that was built into
the programme. The loan scheme was introduced to facilitate the establishment
of business ventures for those who were yet to start their own businesses or
to strengthen already existing ones. One of the strategies employed was to request
would-be beneficiaries to apply for loans after conducting feasibility studies
on any business they wished to embark upon. Many of them said it was a useful
aspect as it enabled them to have adequate information about their business of
choice and it prevented many of them from investing in a business that would
have run bankrupt. It was also as a learning process for them, as they became
knowledgeable of the need to conduct feasibility study before starting a business.
One of
the participants said:
I had finished my diploma course in the polytechnic and
was finding it extremely difficult to get employed. As a result of frustration,
I tried my hands on several businesses but none proved profitable. In any
case, I was fortunate to participate in this programme and I learned what
it means to conduct feasibility studies about a business before you embark
on it ... today I am a better person for it. I, who had once been an applicant,
am now an employer of labour. (Graduate participant, Iree, September
2001)
Many of those interviewed confirmed that without the loans
it would have been difficult for them to start the businesses they are now
managing. They cited the poor state of the economy that has made it almost
impossible to raise loans from family members who may want to help them, while
the banks are described as a "no go area". They are aware of the
stringent conditions that have to be fulfilled before qualifying for a loan
in any bank. Apart from the non-availability of collateral, the interest rates
on bank loans would have discouraged them from obtaining loans from banks.
One of the participants spoke thus:
After my training, I had approached a wealthy relative
to assist me with money to start a business, rather than tell me he had no
money, he kept promising without fulfilling. After a while, I became fed
up and thought of going to a bank to ask for loan. When I approached the bank, the things (collateral) I was asked
to bring were just too much that even if I had them I would not need to go to
anybody to ask for a loan in the first
place. The experience was quite frustrating. (Non-graduate participant, Osogbo,
August 2001)
There was variation in the amount of loan given participants
in the graduate scheme and those who participated in the apprentice girls'
scheme. There were however complaints by the non-graduates about this variation.
Some of them felt that it was not good enough especially because they believed
they were operating in the same environment and under the same economic conditions.
They said they should have been given more money because they are educationally
disadvantaged and may not be left with any alternative like the graduate participants.
In the words of one non-graduate participant:
... those of us who never went to the university should
have been given more money or at least given equal amount of money as those
who are graduates. You know, those who are graduates have a choice ... that
they can get employed if things do not turn out the way they expect. As for
those of us (non-graduates) whose livelihood is tied to this business,
we will do everything possible to make sure it succeeds. This is why we need
more money than they do ... or at worst, the same amount so that we can also
compete favourably with them. (Non-graduate participant, Osogbo, September
2001)
In spite of the complaints about discrepancies in the amount
of money given to graduate and non-graduate participants, the method of repayment
was highly commended. Beneficiaries had a 24-month period to repay whatever
amount of loan was given to them. The loans ranged from N 25,000
for non-graduates to N 40,000 for graduates. The repayment
method adopted was based on a mutual agreement between beneficiaries and officials
of Life Vanguards. On some occasions, it was difficult for beneficiaries to
meet up with the schedule, and in such cases Life Vanguards was willing to
accommodate their shortcomings. One of the non-graduate benefi-ciaries, who
operates a hair dressing salon, com-mented on this:
Sometimes you run short of your expectations in terms of paying back your
monthly instalment, the officials of LIVA do not bother you at all. They are
willing to accommodate these shortcomings as long as they know you are not
defaulting intentionally. For instance, I have defaulted on two occasions now
but nobody has come here to
harass me. (Non-graduate participant, Osogbo, September 2001)
Participants were asked to list the benefits of participating
in the programme. Apart from the economic benefits they cited, the strong linkage
between poverty and individual behaviours manifested in the responses they
gave. The non-graduate beneficiaries opined that if they had not participated
in the programme, life would have been more difficult for them. They said even
if they had acquired the training but had no initial capital to start off,
they would have had to depend on their family members or other people (men)
for survival. This was echoed by some of the participants:
What would be the benefit of acquiring training such as
I have and not be able to stand on my own at the end of the day? If there
is nobody to help me, I would remain like I was before this help came my
way. (Graduate participant, Ife, September 2001)
The benefits I have gained from this programme cannot be
quantified. Where do I start? Is it from the knowledge I have gained about
my body or the fact that I now command respect in the community as a responsible
lady? Both young and old, especially the men in this community, now see me
as a big woman ... somebody who a few years ago was an apprentice and now
a manager of my own business. In fact, I cannot quantify the benefits. (Non-graduate
participant, Osogbo, September 2001)
The opinions expressed by respondents suggest that when women
are economically disadvantaged and they have to seek help from a man, it serves
as some sort of invitation for the man to have his way with them. The girls
did not mince words in castigating men for this behaviour, lamenting that they
take undue advantage of girls because of their helpless situation.
In this part of the world, a man sees nothing wrong in asking for sexual and
other kinds of favours in return for any help rendered a woman who is obviously
disadvantaged. When you ask a man for help, he takes that to mean an invitation
from you to sleep (have sex) with him, and there are few men who would think
otherwise. If I have to be honest with you, I would have found myself in this
situation if not for the opportunity I have
with Life Vanguards. (Gradate participant,
Ife, September 2001)
I want to thank God and this organisation (Life Vanguards)
without whose help and support I would not have been what I am today. Who
could have imagined that I would today be a manager of my own business? I
had lost all hope of a great future with the death of my parents and with
no one to help me. I have been saved from the dilemma of depending on a man
for daily survival for the rest of my life. (Non-graduate participant,
Osogbo, August 2001)
Respondents were asked to indicate which aspect of the programme
has been most effective. Their responses varied from the loans given to them
to the reproductive health information they were exposed to. A greater proportion
of the respondents said the training and entrepreneurial skill develop-ment
component complimented each other. They said without the reproductive health
knowledge acquired they may have had to indulge in negative behaviours without
knowing the consequences. One of the participants noted:
You may have all the money in the world, but it would amount
to nothing when you don't know that certain kinds of behaviours put you at
the risk of pregnancy or AIDS, and you know when AIDS strikes, there is no
amount of money that can save a victim. (Graduate participant, Osogbo,
September 2001)
Many of those interviewed suggested that many girls are still
disadvantaged and that there is an impending need to reach them. There were
calls from the beneficiaries for the laudable programme to be extended to as
many girls as possible.
There are several girls who are still relatively deprived
and without the help from programmes of this nature, they would continue
to fall prey to the whims and caprices of men who take
advantage of them. (Non-graduate participant,
Osogbo, September 2001)
The linkage between poverty and risky sexual behaviour is
apparently highlighted in these cases. There were other opinions which suggest
that the relationship between poverty and negative/risky sexual behaviour may
not be as strong as previously suggested in literature. The proponents of such
opinions indicated that it is a matter of individual decision.
The entrepreneurial skill development pro-gramme was designed
to address this linkage. In large part, one may conclude that the programme
has been able to achieve this objective based on the responses from participants.
On the other hand, some participants noted that the linkage between poverty
and negative sexual behaviour especially among girls may not be as clear-cut
as the issue has often been painted.
One participant indicated thus:
Not all the girls who are prostitutes or indulge in negative
and risky sexual behaviour are from poor homes. What shall we say about rich
high class ladies who are prostitutes? Would you say it is poverty that has
driven them into prostitution? Those who hide under the guise of poverty
to indulge in this kind of behaviour are not being honest, they simply want
to do it, whether they are poor or not. We have seen cases of people who
are poor, yet they abstain from this kind of behaviour. (Non-graduate
participant, Osogbo, September 2001)
This and similar opinions reveal that there is more to
the issue of risky sexual behaviour among adolescents than poverty and economic
deprivation. It is precisely because of this that some of those interviewed
suggested that programmes should focus on factors other than economic that
make young people to engage in negative risky sexual behaviours. Respondents
suggested that the family background and upbringing of an adolescent play significant
role in the behaviours they manifest. In this regard, they suggested that parents
should be involved in this type of programmes so that they
can better appreciate their children and devote more time
to their training.
When parents are too conscious about money they tend
to have no time for training their children. As a result, some of these
children end up manifesting negative behaviours which they learn from
their peers and parents are not always around to discredit the negative
impressions that young people learn from their friends about a lot of
issues. There is still a lot of grounds for this project to cover. Without
the involvement of parents and a training of this nature organised for
parents, it may be difficult to achieve in totality the goals of this
programme. I will strongly advise that trainings should also be organised
for parents. (Graduate participant, Iree, September, 2001)
These responses were given when respondents were asked
which aspect of the programme should be done differently. They indicated
that boys should also be considered when this type of programmes are being
planned. They believed that boys also have their own problems and these
should be taken care of in order to reduce the rate of such social problems
as armed robbery and other social vices perpetuated mainly by boys.
In my own opinion, I think boys too should be encouraged
to participate and benefit from such programmes. Boys perpetuate a lot
of the armed robbery, thuggery and other social vices going on in our
society and this is because they are idle and are denied of opportunities.
Let their interests be taken care of also ... they need loans to start
off businesses, they need to be trained about reproductive health issues
... so that they will stop putting girls under pressure for sex, they
need to be trained in these aspects and have the same opportunities as
we have in this programme. (Non-graduate participant, Osogbo, September
2001)
Discussions The importance of the relationship between female education
and access to resources such as land and credit facilities as a means to further
empowerment of girls has long been recognised by researchers and policymakers.
Education provides young girls with the capacity and skills to achieve favourable
balance
of power in male-female and inter-generational relationships.
It encourages independence, helps to counter pronatalist attitudes and provides
girls with a wider social network and greater exposure to non-traditional values.
Similarly, employment outside the home can contribute to greater sexual and
reproduc-tive autonomy by reducing girls' dependence on men and children and
providing girls and women with the moral leverage to challenge patriarchal
controls over their sexual and reproductive lives, particularly if the earnings
constitute a significant proportion of household income.
This paper has highlighted the significant contributions of
economic empowerment of adolescent girls to their reproductive behaviour. Without
doubt, a lot can be achieved in the attempts to empower young women by providing
access to opportunities and resources. In spite of what can be achieved by
economically empowering young people, there are several areas that also call
for increasing attention.
The development of a psychological sense of personal control
is also important in the effort to empower girls. As studies have shown, adolescent
behaviours, including sexual activity and pre-marital childbearing, are a function
of low self-esteem and internal locus of control, and low aspirations and expectations
regarding the attainment of salient goals. For girls to achieve some reasonable
level of control over their reproductive lives, they must not only have the
knowledge and resources to exercise their choices, they must also put into
practice what they have learnt by being able to negotiate terms with men regarding
reproductive behaviour on their own. This remains the most challenging part
of reproductive health programmes that seek to empower young women.
There are several other issues to be considered in the attempt
at empowering female adolescents. One of these is the peer group, which has
a vital role to play in strengthening the positions of adolescents in negotiating
the terms of reproductive behaviour. Because adolescents are more likely to
seek opinion or advice regarding their behaviours from their peers, empowerment
through peer education can provide young girls with information
and knowledge about reproductive health and communication skills,
and strategies to resist peer as well as partner pressure to engage in negative
behaviour. Furthermore, communication about sexual matters is a significant
factor associated with decision-making among adolescents. It has been shown
consistently that young girls who discuss sexual matters with mothers or other
family members demonstrate positive sexual behaviours. While it is recognised
that family intervention based on parent-adolescent communication is an effective
strategy for preventing negative sexual and reproductive behaviour among young
people, efforts in this regard continue to be compromised by a lack of understanding
of the specific kinds of messages that affect adolescent sexual decisions and
practices.
Finally, it is important to recognise that to effectively
empower adolescent girls, males must also be educated to respect young women's
rights to control their own sexuality.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the Ford Foundation office
for West Africa for providing funds for the project. We also appreciate the
support of Dr Babatunde Ahonsi for the Integrated Youth Development Project
(IYDP). We are particularly grateful to Lawrence Adeokun, Adebayo Ajala and
Olayemi Alawode for their comments on earlier drafts of this paper, and finally
all the young women who participated in the project and their parents.
References
- UNFPA. The State of the World's Population. New
York: UNFPA, 1995.
- Population Reference Bureau. World Popula-tion Fact Sheet
2000.
- McCormick NB and Jessor CJ. The courtship game: power in
the sexual encounter. In: ER Allgeier and NB McCormick (Eds.). Changing
Boundaries: Gender Roles and Sexual Behaviour. Calif.: Mayfield,
1983, 64-86.
- Felmlee DH. Who's on top? Power in romantic relationships. Sex
Roles 1994; 31: 275-295.
- Gage AJ. Female empowerment and adolescent demographic
behaviour. In: HB Presser and Gita Sen (Eds.). Women's Empowerment and Demographic
Processes: Moving Beyond Cairo. Oxford University Press, 2000.
- Schoepf BG. Women, AIDS and economic crisis. Canad J
Afr Stud 1989; 22: 625-644.
- Hayes Cheryl (Ed.). Risking the Future: Adolescent Sexuality,
Pregnancy and Childbearing. Volume I. Washington: National Academy
Press, 1987.
- Batliwala S. The meaning of women empowerment: new concepts
from action. In: Gita Sen, Andrienne Germain and Lincoln Chen (Eds.). Population
Policies Reconsidered: Health Empowerment and Rights. Cambridge:
Harvard University Press, 1994, 127-138.
- England P. Conceptualizing women empowerment in countries
of the North. In: HB Presser and Gita Sen (Eds.). Women's Empowerment and
Demographic Processes: Moving Beyond Cairo. Oxford University Press,
2000.
- Sen G and Batliwala S. Empowering women for reproductive
rights. In: HB Presser and Gita Sen (Eds.). Women's Empowerment and Demographic
Processes: Moving Beyond Cairo. Oxford University Press, 2000.
- Adedokun OA. Women, empowerment and reproductive health.
In: JA Ebigbola and EP Renne (Eds.). Population and Development Issues:
Ideas and Debates. Ibadan: Africana Book Builders, 2000.
Copyright 2003 - Women's Health and Action Research Centre
|