About Bioline  All Journals  Testimonials  Membership  News  Donations

Iranian Journal of Environmental Health, Science and Engineering
Iranian Association of Environmental Health (IAEH)
ISSN: p-ISSN: 1735-1979
Vol. 1, Num. 1, 2004, pp. 1-4

Iranian Journal of Environmental Health Science & Engineering, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2004, pp. 1-4

Performance of a Direct Horizontal Roughing Filtration (DHRF) System in Treatment of Highly Turbid Water

*A H Mahvi, M Ahmadi Moghaddam, S Nasseri and K Naddafi

Dept. of Environmental Heath Engineering, School of Public Health
Center for Environmental Research, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran

*Corresponding Author: E-mail: Tel: +98 21 88954914, Fax: +98 21 88950188

Code Number: se04001


Vertical or horizontal flow gravel beds can be used in water treatment as roughing filters. In order to improve the performance of horizontal flow roughing filtration (HRF) this process has been modified earlier by applying a constant coagulant dose prior to filtration named direct horizontal roughing filtration (DHRF). In this research a lab scale DHRF pilot plant was used for investigate DHRF performance. The study results indicated that DHRF (6.5 m long consisting of 2.5 m first compartment with 12-18 mm diameter grain, 2 m/s compartment with 8-12 mm diameter and 1.5m third compartment with 4-8 mm diameter) was systematically yielded good effluent quality (<2NTU, C.I=0.95) with raw water quality of 200-400 NTU. DHRF is a versatile pretreatment process capable of handling wide fluctuation in raw water turbidity (200-400 NTU) while operating condition such as coagulant dose [2mg Fe (III)/L], mixing intensity, time and filtration rate remained unchangeable.

Keywords: Direct horizontal roughing filter, Treatment, Highly turbid water


The demand for safe water is increasing drastically in the urbanizing areas of the developing countries. Many tropical rivers show a wide fluctuation in suspended solids content and other water quality characteristics; water treatment plant drawing raw water from such rivers are facing growing problems in providing desired treated water quality as well as quantity. This problem is compounded for the towns and small cities in developing countries due to their limited financial resources (Wegelin and Schertenleib, 1993). The horizontal - flow roughing filter (HRF) is claimed to have the advantage of being able to tackle relatively high raw water turbidity, whilst at the same time offering long filter run time and a simple technology (Galvis et al, 1993). Its applicability is, however, limited, e.g. due to its low filtration rate and limited capability to remove stable colloids and color. In order to improve the HRF performance a modified configuration (DHRF), which combines it with other water treatment, process (es) can be considered. DHRF can overcome the limitation of HRF and on the other hand retain its advantages, notably long run time and ease in operation and maintenance, would be advantages (Pardon, 1992).


Laboratory scale pilot plant was operated, which consisted of a raw water preparation system, a coagulant dosing system and a roughing filter unit. Tap water was fed continuously to the constant head water tank, from there water was passed though a flow meter into the clay mixing tank where it was mixed with clay slurry continuously added by a peristaltic pump. The required clay slurry was prepared every two days. The stack slurry was kept under continuous and vigorous mixing with two constant speed mechanical stirrers was used in the clay-mixing tank.

The turbid suspension was passed to a plain sedimentation tank (l h detention time) to eliminate coarse particles. The required amount of Fe (III) was pumped to the rapid mixing unit and mixed by the same type with the clay suspension. The coagulant suspension was then passed on to the roughing filter unit. The container of the filter bed was made of Plexiglas with 6 m length, 10 cm width and 10 cm height and had 3 compartments. The length and grain size of 1st, 2nd and 3rd compartment were 2.5, 2, 1.5 m, 12-18, 8-12 and 4-8 respectively. Turbidity as the main indicator of the removal performance was expressed in NTU (APHA, 1998). After reaching to head loss around 20 cm, filter cleaning through hydraulic flushing was started.



The effluent turbidity from DHRF was < 2 NTU (C.I=0.95) with raw water quality of 200400 NTU and surface rate 1.5-5m/h. (Fig.2). The effluent turbidity of the filter run with the influent turbidity varying over time was compared with that of 2 filter runs, the first with 200-250 NTU and second with 350-400 NTU. All the parameters remained identical. Effluent turbidity fluctuation in the filter run with the variable influent turbidity remained limited (< ± 0.3 NTU) despite the drastic influent turbidity change. In filtration rate 1.5-5 m/h at high influent turbidity (200-250 NTU) and under identical process conditions the average effluent turbidity was from 1.5 ± 0.2 to 1.7 ± 0.2. Also in turbidity 300-350 NTU the average effluent turbidity was from 1.6 ± 0.3 to 1.7 ± 0.3 NTU. The results of the experiments with different Fe (III) dose are summarized in Table 1.At coagulant dose of less than 1 mg Fe (III)/L the effluent turbidity was good to excellent. With dose of ≥ 4 mg (III)/L the turbidity was very low (0.2-0.3 NTU), however, filter run time decreased (< 10.4 h). At 2 mg Fe (III)/l dose the effluent turbidity was low (1.9 ± 0.2 NTU) and the filter run time increased (96h).

The filter run time generally decreased with increasing coagulant dose. Head loss in all cases developed linearly and was within a reasonable limit of 20 cm. The filter ripening period decreased with increasing Fe (III) dose (Table 1). Total filter length was 6.5m, initial turbidity was between 250 to 300 NTU, pH was 7.2 ± 0.2 and filtration rate was 5 m/h.


DHRF is systematically yielded good effluent quality (<2 NTU, C.I = 0.95) with raw water quality of 200-400 NTU it showed to be a versatile pretreatment process in a handling wide fluctuation in raw water turbidity while the process condition remained unchanged (Guibai and Gregrgy, 1991; Aph, 1998 ).In the case where the operational parameters such as coagulant dose and filtration rate require to remain unchanged for reasons of simple and reliable operation, DHRF will be an effective pretreatment process to produce stable effluent quality even if the raw water quality fluctuates widely or shock loads are received. Therefore less operational control, such as adjust coagulant dose, pH and rapid mixing intensity and time, is necessary in DHRF over a wide range of the raw water quality, turbidity and pH (Ahsan, 1995, Fazeli, 2003, Guibai et al., 1988).

Simple DHRF operation suggests that it could be an appropriate pretreatment technology for towns and small cities in developing countries.


The authors are most grateful to the laboratory staff of the Department of Environmental Health Engineering, School of Public Health, Tehran University of Medical Sciences.


  • Ahsan T (1995). Process analysis and optimization of direct horizontal-flow roughing filtration, Ph.D thesis report in Water Engineering, Delft, Holland.
  • APHA, AWWA, WPCF (1998). Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater, 20th ed., APHA, N.W, Washington D.C.
  • Fazeli M (2003). Determination of design basic and development of DHRF, Ph.D thesis report in Environmental Sciences, Tehran University, Tehran, Iran.
  • Galvis R, Visscher J, Fernandez J, Beron F (1993). Pretreatment alternatives for drinking water supply. Occasional paper. No. 22. IRC, the Hagne.
  • Guibai L, Fuyi C, Lihua Y (1988). Optimum GT value in mixing flocculation for highly turbid water. Proc. Eng. Foundation conf, palm coast, Florida.
  • Guibai L, Gregrgy (1991). Flocculation and sedimentation of high - turbidity waters. Wat Res. 25 (9):1137-1143.
  • Pardon M (1992). Research, development and implementation of roughing filtration technology in Peru. Workshop on roughing filters for water treatment, Zurich, Switzerland.
  • Wegelin M, Schertenleib R (1993). Roughing filters for water treatment. IRCWD News, No. 27, PP. 1-8.

© 2004 Tehran University of Medical Sciences Publication

The following images related to this document are available:

Photo images

[se04001t1.jpg] [se04001f2.jpg] [se04001f1.jpg]
Home Faq Resources Email Bioline
© Bioline International, 1989 - 2019, Site last up-dated on 11-Sep-2019.
Site created and maintained by the Reference Center on Environmental Information, CRIA, Brazil
System hosted by the Internet Data Center of Rede Nacional de Ensino e Pesquisa, RNP, Brazil