|
Reports from
Union of African Population Studies / L'Union pour l'Etude de la Population Africaine
Num. 11, 1995
|
Union for African Population Studies, Rapport de Synthese / Summary Report,
Numéro/Number 11, March 1995
SMALL GRANTS PROGRAMME ON POPULATION AND DEVELOPPEMENT
FERTILITY AMONG ADOLESCENT GIRLS IN SENEGAL : A SUMMARY
Nafissatou J. DIOP, Ph.D
This document is an abstract of the thesis presented by Mrs N.J.
DIOP in 1993 at the University of Montreal. The views expressed in this study
are the author's and cannot in anyway be taken as the views of UAPS.
Research sponsored by the Small Grants Programme on Population and Development
funded by the IDRC, the Rockefeller Foundation, the Mac Arthur Foundation,
SAREC and the French Cooperation Ministry.
Code Number: uaps95003
TABLE OF CONTENTS
FOREWORD
I. INTRODUCTION
II. THE SOCIAL CONTEXT OF FERTILITY INADOLESCENCE
2.1 The ambiguity of the term adolescence
2.2 Adolescence in traditional society
2.3 Adolescence in modern society
III. METHODOLOGY
3.1 Analytical framework
3.2 Source of data and methods
IV. SUMMARY OF THE MAIN RESULTS
4.1 Fertility and its determinants
4.2 The medical consequences of teenage pregnancies
V. IMPLICATIONS FOR THE POPULATION POLICY
BIBLIOGRAPHY
FOREWORD
Africa is the continent where population problems are most
acutely felt. These problems have repercussions in all areas of life. The awareness
of these problems and the dearth of african specialists on population issues
had led governments to set up, with the help of the United Nations, a number
of regional training institutions on Demography.
However, despite the large number of demographers trained
over the last two decades, the improvements of the demographic date base and
the commitment shown by governments, the taking on board of demographic factors
in development strategies has remained very tentative. These mitigated results
are attributable, in part, to the inadequacy of theoretical and empirical knowledge
about the dynamic character of socio-economic and demographic systems and the
difficulties in translating policies into a programme of action.
Nonetheless, the greater part of the specialists who uderwent
training in the field of population often find themselves left to their own
devices, isolated in structures ill-prepared to utilize their expertise. Moreover,
with the persistence of the economic crisis the continent is going through,
african countries cannot meet their research financing requirements. These
specialists rarely have the means which would allow them to undertake research
work.
It is, in an effort to respond to all these problems, that
UAPS embarked on the implementation of a Small Grants Programme on Population
and Development. This programme's main goal is to help junior african specialists
to strenghten their research capacity in the field of the interrelations between
population and development. Through this initiative, UAPS hopes to contribute
not only to smooth handing-over conditions but also, and above all, to improve
the existing knowledge on population issues in Africa, in an integrated and
comprehensive perspective.
Since its creation, the Small Grants Programme has received
over 800 requests for funding. In total 81 researchers have had to benefit
from funding, including 29 during the first phase of the Programme (1986-1991)
and 52 during the second phase (1992-1995). Researches funded during the first
phase have resulted in the production of 26 reports, 8 of which have already
been published and 9 others are being edited. These researches cover a wide
range of topical issues. They consisted in case studies which deeply explored
the problems studied (urbanization, rural migration, street children, women's
status, reproduction strategies, etc.).
By and large, the Small Grants Programme's harvest is impressive
both in terms of research training and the results obtained. This Programme's
merits are all the more important as its design and thrust do respond to current
concerns. It has adopted an open perspective on population issues which integrates
economic, cultural and strictly demographic aspects. What's more, it lays the
stress on research training, in the very countries, thus contributing to the
maintainance of skilled people on the spot and the development of the capacity
of national institutions. Finally, through its philosophy, the Programme works
towards regional integration and cooperation between francophones and anglophones.
The present study which is part of the reports produced within
the framework of the Programme, mainly focusses on fertility among Female Adolescents
in Senegal. It basically hinged on the review of the data of the 1986 Demographic
and Health Survey (DHS) in Senegal concerning menses, nuptial ceremony and
1st rank fertility among senegalese women before they celebrate their 20th
birthday.
The main problematic of this study is the analysis of the
possible trend of first-fertility before the age of 20 among the different
generations under consideration. This is obviously a very important subject
and the longitudinal approach used is particularly pertinent, in the present
context of international research where "Fertility among Female Adolescents" has
become a "problem", thereby an extra argument in favour of the strenghtening
of family planning programme.
N.J. DIOP's line of argument is interesting indeed, as she
strives to demonstrate that fertility among female adolescents raises both
problems of health and social acceptability. The conclusions of this study
are all the more interesting as they do not always coincide with our expectations
and has resulted in pragmatic recommendations.
I wish to congratulate N.J. DIOP on the innovative and interesting
work she offers us in the following pages. Moreover, I would like to thank
all those who, directly or indirectly (donors, grantees' supervisors and research
report readers), have contributed to the completion of this study.
May this Programme further stimulate research on the complex
relationships which exist between population and development and enable researchers
to fulfil their scientific responsability in the battle for development in
Africa.
Finally, I wish to pay tribute to the late Richard HOROWITZ,
former regional representative of the Ford Foundation for Africa who, along
with Sidiki COULIBALY, the current UNFPA Director in Senegal, have launched
the Small Grants Programme.
Prof. Mumpasi LUTUTALA
UAPS President
I. INTRODUCTION
The study of fertility among adolescent girls has for a long
time been assimilated to that of general fertility, before it was felt necessary
to specifically study this group of women. It is in the United States that
the interest in this subject as an object of study was born with the coming
into adolescence, in the 1960s, of the "Baby Boom" generations. Under the influence
of all sorts of factors these generations adopted behaviours different from
those of the preceding generations, in particular a more widespread practice
of sexuality before marriage (Furstenberg, 1976; Elder, 1980). A moral, political
and legislative debate took place over the recourse to abortion, the necessity
for sexual education and family planning services in schools. The reasons behind
this debate are diverse: for Geronimus (1986), these are riks for maternal
and child health; others justify it by the desire of a more egalitarian policy
towards minorities, as it is estimated that about 63% of young black girls
in the United States are affected by the problem (Davis,1988; NRC, 1987). For
Phipps-Yonas (1980), it is the fact that the problem is not exclusively a problem
of sub-culture, as it is increasing among white adolescent girls. The economic
cost of teenage pregnancy is also put forward (Moore, 1978; NRC,1987).
In Africa, that question is starting to arouse special interest.
It is not perceived as a problem everywhere. But for Gyepi-Garbrah (1985),
in we place ourselves in the perspective of reduced fertility, the contribution
of birth from adolescent girls is considerable. For Nichols and his colleagues
(1986), pregnancies before marriage are assuming increasing proportions in
Nigeria and in Liberia because of socio-cultural changes. For Senderowitz and
Paxman (1986) the social and medical consequences of early fertility are too
significant to be glossed over. Bamikale and Pebly (1989) talk of a disorganisation
of traditional society.
In Africa, urbanization and schooling rates keep increasing.
Thus, for two decades now, an increasing number of girls are schooled and urbanized
(Nichols and al., 1986). However, these young girls tend to get married later,
and they are the most exposed to the dilemma of adolescence (Cherlin and Riley,
1986; Ladipo and al., 1983). Studies have revealed that in this population
the rate of sexual activity, pregnancy and abortion (Oronsaye and Odiase, 1983;
Oyeka, 1986; Gyepi-Garbrah, 1985; Ladipo and al., 1983; Nichols and al. 1986;
Akuffo, 1987) are very high.
Some aspects of african culture and the social structure are
also reported to influence the behaviour of urban adolescent girls. This greater
freedom combined with the images of a sexual freedom coming from the West would
lead to greater propensity to having sexual intercourse before marriage (Bamikale
and Pebley, 1989; Demehin, 1983).
Other studies have shown that cohabitation and promiscuity
in the cities were such that they pushed children into the streets, where they
were left to their own devices (Jean-Bart, 1988; demehin, 1983).
These ideas are taken up by Cherlin and Riley (1986) who,
in an effort of conceptualisation, have affirmed that the sexual activity of
single adolescent girls today can be accounted for by the two following reasons: "rational
adaptation" or "social disorganisation".
Social disorganisation is part and parcel of the general
theory of modernization which revealed the weakenening of traditional structures
and the slackening of the contol by the elders over the younger members of
the family. The thus newly born attitudes are geared more towards personal
satisfaction and emotional gratification, than towards family responsibility.
Within this framework, it would seem that sexual relations are spontaneous
and do not respond to any special purpose.
Rational adaptation is reported to be rather related
to the dependence theory. This model is mainly based on the effects of the
poverty of the populations. Adolescent girls who come into town looking for
greater economic power often have no other choices but to rely on the help
of a "friend" to pay for their studies or to offer them presents, clothes,
money or work in exchange for sexual favours (Cherlin and Riley, 1986; Caldwell,
1990; Akuffo, 1987), which may lead into marriage. Engaging into sexual relations
is therefore a rational decision.
In the literature on childbearing among adolescent girls in
Africa, as in developed countries, the fertility of married adolescent girls
was hardly studied. The stress was mainly laid on the sexual activity of urban
schoolgirls. If this approach can be justified in developed countries where
over 90% of adolescent girls are single and still at school, in Africa where
more than half of adolescent girls are married and uneducated it is not very
efficient as it would not take into account the greater part of the target
public for which an intervention programme should be designed. Our study sets
itself three major objectives: firstly, to update the definition of the concept
of adolescence by putting it into senegalese perspective; secondly, to indicate
the determinants of fertility among adolescent girls in Senegal, to design
the theoretical framework for socio-demographic research in Africa; and finally
to compare the behaviour of adolescent girls to that of older women to determine
the reasons for which behaviour, which is the main determinant of morbidity
and maternal and child mortality (Hobcraft, 1991; Adelunke and al., 1992; Gernimus,
1987; 1991; Leslie and Gupta, 1991), is more negative among adolescent girls.
2. THE SOCIAL CONTEXT OF FERTILITY IN ADOLESCENCE
2.1. The ambiguity of the term "adolescence"
In most dictionaries, adolescence is defined as "the process
through which an individual goes through the transition from the stage of childhood
to that of adulthood". Adolescence is characterized by efforts made to reach "social,
physical, mental and emotional development" (Elder, 1980).While the beginning
of adolescence is currently associated in most cultures with the beginning
of puberty, the end of adolescence is rarely clearly defined (Senderowitz and
Paxman, 1985; WHO, 1986). Senderowitz and Paxman (1985) think that the definition
of adolescence may vary from one culture to the other, as long as certain recognized
criteria like those of an adult do not manifest themselves.
If it is widely believed that adolescence is the period in
life when the individual goes through the transition from the stage of childhood
to that of adulthood, it is difficult however to determine where this childhood
ends and where adulthood starts. However, as is pointed out by Elder (1980),
what defines adolescence is not puberty, or sudden development, or still the
process of general maturation, but rather the perception of that maturation
commonly admitted in the society considered. How do the Senegalese perceive
adolescence ?
2.2 Adolescence in traditional senegalese society
In traditional senegalese society, the influence of age is
in fact paramount and respect for the elder is important, in accordance with
the hierarchization advocated by society (Diop, 1981). According to these norms,
the education of the child, and that of the adolescent, and the learning of
his trade are assumed by the members of the extended family. The latter form
the character of the individual and his professional orientation (Miske-Talbot,
1984).
The compound is an instrument of control as it regulates the
life of its members. Social control is all the more necessary as the behaviour
of an individual can earn the entire lineage condemnation or fame (Ayodele,
1983; Miske-Talbot, 1984). The fact that the members look after one another
is even more pronounced among adolescent girls who are in the process of learning
a woman's role.A girl who does not go to school gets very early into the process
of learning her future role both as a woman and mother under the supervision
of her mother and the female members of the compound. Responsibilities are
gradually entrusted to her, to such an extent that as soon as she reaches puberty,
she is given in marriage.
However, girls also enjoy relative autonomy within age groups.
In fact, the importance of peers in the child's social development is largely
recognized by traditional society. As Kelly and his colleagues say (1987),
the adolescent girl has, along with the parents, sisters and peers of the same
and opposite sex, different relations with the same persons, during childhood.
Relations among peers become more intense, and those with the family less strong.
Traditional societies also recognize this difference and the age group is an
institution in which the child, and then the young girl are going to develop.
Under various forms (songs, tales, proverbs) the norms and
values of society (honour for her and for her family, sense of decency, dignity,
self-respect, and above all tolerance and patience in her future married life)
are reminded to the girl, for these are the virtues that are going to make
her a good wife. The adolescent girl should remain a virgin and chaste girl,
and should abide by a rule of conduct enabling her to protect her virginity
and future fertility (Miske-Talbot, 1984; Ayodele, 1983; Diop, 1981).
A woman's marriage and sexuality can only been perceived in
relation to fertility. Marriage and childbearing are perceived as a duty for
the individual, for society's survival and regulation (Miske-Talbot, 1984).
Thus, early fertility is encouraged , for it is valorizing for women, men and
the lineage.
This early nature of marriage and childbearing made people
say that adolescence in traditional society is a notion that does not exist,
as once the girl reaches puberty she is given in marriage (Chui, 1978), for
marriage is synonymous with respectability, maturity and adulthood. Childbearing
is also recognized as such. This is when it takes place out of wedlock, the
adolescent girl loses all privileges associated with being a young girl, including
material and social assistance by the parents.This system has been prevalent
for several centuries in Senegal. The changes that took place a few years ago
only affected urban areas.
2.3 Adolescence in Modern Society
Colonization led to rapid economic, administrative and religious
changes in african societies. The manifestation of these changes in the social
structure is complex. Modern society is mainly visible in urban areas under
the combined effects of the cash economy, the introduction of education, the
media, different technological imports and religion.
If the family still remains for many people the basic social
institution, its authority is reduced however (Caldwell, 1991; Diop, 1985).
In modern african societies, relations between parents and children are different
from what they used to be in traditional societies. In fact, as society gets
more and more technologically advanced, the individual's education passes more
through schooling, television and radio, the press and new ideas which create
new attitudes. These new attitudes affect society's perception of adolescence.
The education of young people, and young girls in particular,
passes through the school network and no longer prepare them to nothing but
the roles of actors within the family, but to those actors operating in a new
environment in which an individual's success is no longer related to his lineage,
but results in his/her capacity to assimilate "scientific" knowledge and to
innovate. The learning process here is above all longer and thereby disrupts
the normative time-table by lengthening the period between childhood and marriage.
This is what made Chui (1978) say that there is in it an emergence of the period
of adolescence.
This period of adolescence is a source of conflicts. In modern
society, the activities carried out by groups of adolescents take them increasingly
away from adults and the separation of sexes is no longer so pronounced. All
new recreational activities such as going to the cinema or dancing parties
contribute to the shortening of the period spent within the family. In modern
african society the adolescent is starting to look very much like his counterpart
in western countries.
Thus, his social environment starts perceiving him differently.He
becomes economically independent and only starts taking part in the community's
decision-making process very late. He becomes increasingly useless and is less
and less likely to be entrusted with responsibilities as he behaves less and
less as a member of the collective group.Thus, although he is biologically
mature, he is socially immature.
The adolescent himself goes through a change of attitude.
He develops his own culture, generates a different lifestyle with his own codes,
his tastes in music and in dance, and his ideas on what morality is all about.
The content of these styles changes as time elapses, but it still contains
the same message: an expression of segregation and opposition to the society
of adults (Kelly and Hansen, 1987).
In modern society, the group of peers serves as a stepping-stone
for the adolescent to go from childhood to adulthood and from the ascendancy
of the family to making personal decisions. Senegalese adolescent girls in
urban areas learn by imitating their peers, and mass media play an important
role in the popularization of modes of clothing and the new values created
by young people in western societies.
Moreover, with the introduction of mechanized work following
modernization, a population movement from rural to urban areas starts. The
migration of adolescent girls towards the cities, be it with their family or
by themselves looking for a job, just like the migration of Diola and Serer
girls towards Dakar and other secondary cities looking for jobs as domestic
workers, leads to the rapid transition from a traditional to a modern system.
The adolescent girl is no longer in a position to internalise a coherent system
of sufficient normative barriers to forestall certain behaviours. Thus, without
reference nor reliable guide as to how to cope with new situations which they
find themselves in while living in the cities, adolescent girls start adopting
different behaviours. The conflict between traditional values and modern habits
is even more heightened by this when their family reamains in the village.
These two perceptions of adolescence in Senegal are going
to have repercussions on the fertility of adolescent girls. Thus, according
to whether we consider one or the other perception, fertility will be perceived
differently. In traditional society, teenage pregnancy is accepted and even
wished for by society, and it is part and parcel of the traditional normative
programme. Therefore in traditional Africa, fertility during adolescence is
not a social problem. In modern society where sexual activity seems to have
become more frequent, the way young girls view pregnancies has considerably
changed.
In the case of pregnancy before marriage, childbearing among
adolescent girls is considered as a disruption to the mother's normal life
cycle. This is what Furstenburg (1976) refers to as the "disruption of the
normative programme", insofar as adolescent girls, and to a large extent the
entire community, find themselves in a premature status transition, propelling
them into positions which they are not ready to assume. These pregnancies are
strongly rejected by the family and the social environment, and will create
integration difficulties for the mother.
To what extent do the two approaches to adolescence thus defined,
the resulting social evolution as well as the slackening of family authority
affect puberty, marriage and childbearing before the age of twenty ? This is
what the next part is endeavouring to study without forgetting to analyse the
reasons for which the behaviour of adolescent girls is more negative than that
of older mothers regarding the use of heath services.
3. METHODOLOGY
3.1 Analytical framework Model for the study of fertility
and its determinants
The transition from adolescence to adulthood is studied according
to a longitudinal perspective so as to better understand social change. The
life cycle approach makes it possible to better understand the links which
exist between age and time (Elder, 1980).
Three temporal modalities are defined:
The effect of age (lifetime); it is more related
to the process of the individual's physical development. This study will try
and identify adolescent girls. Puberty will be used to understand the effect
of age.
The effect of the moment (social time); it is
more concerned with the age differentiation for the sequence of events and
roles. This idea is perceived on the basis of two perceptions of adolescence.
In fact, with the evolution of the concept of adolescence, society accepts
a chain of roles which is different according to whether one finds oneself
in the traditional system or in the modern system. Marriage and childbearing
further call for the role and norms of society. These variables are used to
understand the effect of the moment, which is used here in an urban-rural context.
The effect of cohort (historical time) is rather
based on the differentiation and succession of the roles of cohorts, with their
influence on lifestyles. This study is aimed at identifying differences in
the emergence of events according to generations.
As for the study of determinants, given the fact that the
Demographic and Health Survey (DHS) has interviewed women aged between 15 and
49 years at the time of the survey, the top limit of the reflection framework
will be the age of 20. However, with retrospective data, events took place
at any age. One adaptation to the sociological framework developed earlier,
which indicates that the end of adolescence is marked by marriage and childbearing,
consists in using as a definition "any event which took place before the age
of twenty years", without giving any pecision on the lower limit. And this
is valid for all the generations covered by the survey.
Model for the study of the medical consequences of pregnancy
The medical consequences of pregnancy in adolescence are largely
a function of the behaviour of mothers during pregnancy. The mother's decision
to make use of health services is based, according to the literature, on three
sets of factors : predisposing factors, reinforcing factors and on facilitating
factors (Green and al, 1980). Predisposing factors are elements anterior to
behaviour but which are going to lead to the motivation of behaviour. Facilitating
factors precede behaviour and are going to make its achievement possible (personal
and community resources). Reinforcing factors are elements which act subsequently.
This model is referred to in the health literature as the PRECEDE model.
3.2 Sources of data and Methods of analysis
This study uses the data of the 1986 Demographic and Health
Survey (DHS).
The methodology used for the analysis of fertility and its
determinants calls for survival tables.These make it possible to avoid systematic
errors, to use all the data and to take advantage of the information from incomplete
stories as in a cross-section survey like the DHS one, the experience or exposition
of some members of the sample to a risk is interrupted by the survey, that
is to say that ulterior events are not seized.
1) For most of the tables where generations are compared,
the gross tables describing the occurrence of events in the absence of disruptive
factors and which make the description of a phenomenon in a pure state possible
are used (Smith, 1980).
2) A net table is designed which take two competing
phenomena into account. It is a question of considering two causes of eventuality:
premarital
conceptions and marriages before childbearing (Smith, 1980).
3) A table of occurrence
over the duration of the protogenesic interval according to the age at marriage
has also been used
4) Logistical
regression is used to describe the relations between dependent variables with
two modalities and risk factors, independent
variables for the study of medical consequences.
- If the woman has had a prenatal medical examination during
her pregnancy, and if so, who did she see?
- If she has received an injection against tetanos during
pregnancy?
- Who was assisting her during confinement ?
4. SUMMARY OF THE MAIN RESUILTS
4.1 Fertility and its determinants Puberty
Survival tables did not point out the drop in the age at which
menses start for the generations born between 1946 and 1971. Longer observation
and more reliable data are needed for one to draw final conclusions.
However, according to certain socio-economic characteristics
like residence and education, for the generation aged between 15 and 19 years
at the time the survey was being conducted, the puberty extinction curve of
the most educated women and which are subject to variations in urban areas
is the one that decreases more quickly. Suppose the most educated women and
who live in urban areas are the best fed ones, the change in this group confirms
what has already been verified in several countries. In the other age groups
that relationship does not exist or is less marked. This is not surprising
insofar as nothing indicates that nutritional conditions in the part were better
in urban areas, or for ducated women.
Thus, if in the literature it is admitted that age at puberty
should have been brought down as a result of improved nutritional level (Burrel,
Healy and Tanner, 1961; Gyepi-Garbrah, 1985; Senderowitz and Paxman, 1986),
with data on Senegal, it has not been possible to confirm this hypothesis.
Relations between age at puberty and age at first marriage
The marriage schedule according to the age at which women
reach puberty shows that when age at puberty is early, age at marriage follows
suit. It also appears that the interval between marriage and puberty is very
short. Thus, the coming of an adolescent girl's menses entails a process of
marriage organisation or consummation on the part of senegalese parents. In
fact, the relation which was established between age at puberty and age at
marriage shows that the beginning of menses leads to a recognition by society,
for the girl is physically mature for reproduction and thereby for marriage.
This confirms that puberty is a non negligible determinant for the formation
of families.
Age at first marriage
Even if marriage is quasi universal, with a few persons remaining
definitively singles, it appears that significant changes are taking place
in the premarital schedule. The proportion of women before the age of 20 years
has regularly diminished as the generations are getting younger. The Khi 2
test confirms this by turning out to be significant around 1%.
As marriage socially marks the end of adolescence, the duration
of adolescence can be affected by it. If four fifths of the generation born
in 1941-1917 were no longer adolescents before reaching their twentieth birthday,
it is half of the generation born in 1966-1971 who were not so any longer before
reaching their twentieth birthday. There has therefore been a gradual lengthening
of adolescence. In urban areas, the lengthening of adolescence was really started
with generations born as from 1957. In rural areas, the transition was also
set into motion, but with a delay of two five-year groups of generations on
the urban environment, it is therefore definitely slower.
Thus, adolescence is a short period in rural areas, and a
longer one in urban areas. But what the data have been able to show is that
this difference, which was not significant with older generations, becomes
so with younger generations. This does confirm the study plan which was proposed,
namely that in Senegal we have two social systems. While in the past there
was only one system, in which the adolescence transition was virtually the
same as for the two residential areas, today, this adolescence transition is
much longer in the modern system, for the gap widened as the urban environment
became preponderant and was modernizing itself.
Age at first childbearing
The age at first childbearing increased only very little as
time went on, the progress having been exclusively brought about by the younger
generation. It remained constant for three generations, before it started increasing
slightly with the generations born between 1961 and 1966, and started going
down with the generations born after 1966.
The age at marriage having regularly declined, one could have
witnessed a similar trend at the level of the age at first childbearing, instead
of witnessing some kind of stability at the age of first childbearing. Adolescent
girls in the rural areas continue to have their first birth much earlier than
their counterparts in the urban areas. But, the difference is only significant
for the first four age groups covered by the survey. For the 40-44 and 35-39
age groups, the difference is not significant.
According to the educational level, the same trend seems to
take shape in all generations. The more educated women are, the longer they
delay their first childbearing. The difference noted at 19 years of age between
the educational levels is significant for all three age groups , even if the
threshold of significance increases as we move from younger ages to older ones.
On the other hand, when one considers separately educational categories, there
is no significant difference of age at childbearing between the 40-44 age group
and the younger ones.
Premarital pregnancies
The data available did not confirm the assumption according
to which premarital pregnancies increased in Senegal. There was no increase
in rank 1 fertility before marriage, but the percentage of women having experienced
premarital childbearing as the major event before the age of 19 years is on
the increase. In fact, a change was set into motion with the generations born
as from 1961.
In checking with the place of residence, it has been possible
to note that for all women, there is virtually no difference in attitudes.
However, when each generation is observed, it can be said that it is above
all the generation aged 15-19 years in urban areas at the time the survey was
being conducted who seems to have the attitude depicted in the assumption.
For the other age groups, the percentages are are more significant in rural
areas.
Thus, it is in urban areas that a real change of attitude
took place as in the younger generation, a greater number of young girls aged
15-19 years reach adulthood after having given birth. What also come out of
this analysis is the high rate of this percentage among women having had primary
school education.
This confirms the theory which has it that the longer the
time between the beginning of adolescence - which is characterized by the appearance
of menses - and the end of adolescence - which is often assimilated to marriage,
the bigger the risk for the young girl to have sexual intercourse before marriage,
and probably to become pregnant.
The study of the protogenesic interval shows that as the age
at marriage increases, the shorter the interval between first marriage and
the first birth becomes. There is a clear upward trend of fertility during
the first years of childbearing when the age at marriage increases, and it
would seem that premarital pregnances also increase in this case.
4.2 The medical consequences of early pregnancies
Health care during pregnancy is not yet systematic for senegalese
women. Non only one third of the women are not immunized against tetanos during
pregnancy so as to forestall neo-postnatal mortality for their child. Even
by taking into account socio-economic characteristics, albeit very discriminatory,
the difference in attitudes remains very significant for very young mothers
aged below 18 years. Moreover, residence in rural areas and illiteracy are
the two factors most associated with non immunization.
One third of women did not undergo any prenatal medical examination
during pregnancy. For very young mothers, the risk of not undergoing any medical
examination is highly significant and remains so when one takes socio-economic
variables into consideration. The fact of being poor, living in rural areas,
being illerate and married is closely related with the absence of quality medical
examination.
As for assistance when delivering, it is the very young mothers
who have the most positive behaviour. However, this positive attitude disappears
when the quality of the assistance is taken consideration. Very young mothers,
becausae of their lack of experience, are taken in charge by older women, and
are therefore more inclined to resort to traditional services.
In examining independent variables, service factors are more
discriminationg regarding the use of health structures than factors related
to the users, for the absence of services in the rural areas can be largely
explained by the fact that women resort less to health services. In urban areas
a non negligible proportion of women do not resort to health services. For
these, it is not because of the absence of services, but perhaps for reasons
related to the times when they are available or the quality of the health care,
or to education or other cultural barriers.
5. IMPLICATIONS FOR THE POPULATION POLICY
It can be said of this study that the putting in place of
a health policy more directed towards young mothers would improve the population's
health status. Family planning campaigns lay the stress on delayed childbearing
during very early adolescence, are reported to also have a positive effect
on the mother's health.
But any policy aimed at raising the age at marriage should
introduce the necessary accompanying measures to make sure the attainment of
the objective pursued is not accompanied with increased fertility and premarital
pregnancies.
It is urgent that 60% of women living in rural areas and who
continue mostly to resort to traditional medical services have access to modern
health services.
It is also particularly urgent that measures be taken to obviate
these problems. IEC campaigns are the basis on which the National Family planning
Programme rests are mainly a birth spacing message; this means that women who
have already given birth are above all targeted. A Family Planning Programme
specifically intended for young girls not only from the IEC point of view,
but above all from the clinical point of view should be developed.
The issue of fertility among adolescent girls and its various
consequences might assume increasing proportions in the years to come, insofar
as "modernization" of society keeps accelerating. Even international aid and
structural adjustment policies contribute to compound this problem. Being educated
is more and more necessary, but at the same time, the possibilities of entering
the job market dwindle. The schooling of young girls at secondary and higher
education levels gets accelerated. The mediatization of a western culture,
thus creating a universal "youth" culture establishes itself. The desire, but
above all possibilities of getting married dwindle insofar as the latter are
closely related to the socio-economic situation, illegal abortion becomes widespread,
creating serious health problems. All these factors are going to contribute
to make this problem even more serious in the future.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Adelunke Christie, Véronique Filippi, Wendy Graham,
Patricia Onyemunwa and Eric Udjo, April 1990. "Patterns of Maternity
Care Among Women in Ondo State, Nigeria". in Allan Hill éd., Determinants
of Health and Mortality in Africa, DHS Further Analysis Series, n° 10,
pp. 1-45.
- Adetoro O. and A. Agah, 1988 aug. "The Implications
of Childbearing in Postpubertal Girls in Sokoto, Nigeria" International
Journal of Gyneacological and obstetrics, 27 (1), pp 73-77.
- Akuffo F.O., 1987. "Teenage Pregnancies and School
Dropouts: The Relevance of Family Life Education and Vocational Training to
Girls Employement Opportunities", in C.Oppong ed., Sex Roles, Population
and Development in West Africa, Heinemann, Portsmouth, N.H., and James
Currey, London, pp. 138-154.
- Arney W. et B. Bergen, 1984. "Power and Visibility:
the Invention of Teenage Pregnancy" Social Science and Medecine vol.18,
n° 1, pp.11-19.
- Ayodele S., 1983. The Impact of the Process of Modernization
on Authority and Stability in the Yoruba Family, Ph.D dissertation,
Washington D.C.
- Bamikale F. and Anne R. P., November/December 1989. "Premarital
Sexuality in Urban Nigeria", Studies in Family Planning, Vol.20, n° 6,
pp 343-354.
- Burrell R.J, M.J. Healy and J.M. Tanner, 1961. "Age
at Menarche in South African Bantu Schoolgirls Living in the Transkei Reserve "Human
Biology vol. 33, pp.250-261.
- Caldwell J., Orubuloye I.O, Pat C., Juin 1991. "The
Destabilization of the Traditional Yoruba Sexual System Population and Development
Review vol 17, n° 2, pp. 229-263.
- Cherlin A. and Nancy R., July 1986. Adolescent
Fertility: An Emerging Issue in Sub Saharan Africa Population Health
and Nutrition Department, Washington D.C: World Bank.
- Chui J., 1978. Policies and Programs on Adolescent
Fertility in Developing Countries: an Integrated Approch New York:
United Nations Fund for Population Activities (UNFPA).
- Davis R., winter 1988. "Adolescent Pregnancy and
Infant Mortality: Isolating the Effects of Race" Adolescence vol.23,
n° 92,
pp 899-908.
- Demehin A. O., 1983. "Sexual Attitudes in Traditional
and Modern Yoruba Society", International Quaterly of Community Health Education vol.4
n° 3, pp 231-238.
- Diop A., 1981. La Société Wolof: Les
systèmes d'inégalité et de domination Paris
Khartala.
- Elder G., 1980. "Adolescence in Historical Perspectives", Handbook
of Adolescent Psychology ed. by Joseph Adelson, New York: Wiley, pp
3-46.
- Furstenberg F., 1976. Unplanned Parenthood: The
Social Conséquences of Teenage Childbearing, New York: Free
Press.
- Geiger R. P., July 1976. Youth and Social Change
in a West African City Southern Illinois University, Ph.D. Anthropology
Cultural.
- Geronimus A., 1986. "The Effects of Race, Residence,
and Prenatal Care on the Relationship of Maternal Age to Neonatal Mortality" American
Journal of Public Health, vol 76, n° 12, pp 1416-1421.
- Green L.W., Kreuter M.W., Deeds S.G, Partridge K.B., 1980. Health
Education Planning: A Diagnostic Approach, Palo Alto, CA: Mayfield.
- Gyepi-Garbrah B., Douglas N. and Kpedekpo G.M.K, 1985e. Adolescents
Fertility in Sub-Sahara Africa, Boston Massachussets The Pathfinder
Fund.
- Hobcraft J., 1991. "Child Spacing and Child Mortality",
paper presented at the DHS World Conference, August 5-7, Washington,
D.C.
- Jean-Bart, A., 1985. "Running Wild in Dakar", People 12
(1), pp.18-19.
- Ladipo O.A., Douglas N., John P., Gorgio D., Kelly S.E.,
Otolorin E.O., 1983. "Sexual Behavior, Contraceptive Practice and
Reproductive Health Among the Young Unmarried Population in Ibadan, Nigeria, Final
Report, Family Health International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina.
- Kelly A. and Hansen, 1987. Adolescent Psychology New
York: Wiley.
- Leslie J. and Geeta R. G., 1989. Utilization of
Formal Services for Maternal Nutrition and Health Care in the Third World,
International Center for Research on Women, 90 p.
- Miske-Talbot A., 1984. "Instabilité des valeurs
et socialisation de l'enfant" Environnement Africain n° 14-15-16,
ENDA Dakar, pp. 165-176.
- Moore K., 1978. "Teenage Childbirth and Welfare Dependency",Family
Planning Perspectives vol.10, n° 4, pp 233-235.
- Mosley W. H. and Chen L. C., 1984. "An Analytical
Framework for the Study of Child Survival in Developing Countries.Population and Development
review vol. 10, New York, Population Council.
- Nichols D., Ladipo O., John P., Octolorin E., Mar/Apr 1986. "Sexual
Behaviour, Contraceptive Practice and Reproductive Health among Nigerian Adolescents", Studies
in Family Planning vol.17, n° 2, pp 100-106.
- Oronsaye A., Odiasse G., October 1983. "Attitudes
toward Abortion and Contraception among Nigerian Secondary Schoolgirls" International
Journal of Gyneacology and obstetrics vol.21, n° 5,
- pp 423-426.
- Oyeka I., May/June 1986. "Family Planning among
Nigerian Post-secondary Female Students" Studies in Family Planning,
vol.17 n° 3.
- Phipps-Yonas S., 1980. "Teenage Pregnancy and Motherhood:
a Review of the Literature" American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, vol.5
(3), pp. 403-431.
- Senderowitz J. and John P., April 1985. "Adolescent
fertility: Worldwide Concerns", Population Bulletin vol.40, n° 2,
51 p.
- Smith D. P., 1980. "Life table analysis" WFS Technical
Bulletins n° 6, 25 p.
- World Health Organisation, 1986. "Young People Health-a
Challenge for Society", Technical Report Series 731, Geneva, 117 p.
Copyright 1995 - Union for African Population Studies.
|