|
Reports from
Union of African Population Studies / L'Union pour l'Etude de la Population Africaine
1997
|
TRANSMISSION OF POVERTY: EXPERIENCES OF UNMARRIED ADOLESCENT MOTHERS INOSUN STATE, NIGERIA
Union for African Population Studies, Rapport de Synthese
/ Summary Report, Mar. 1997
TRANSMISSION OF POVERTY:
EXPERIENCES OF UNMARRIED ADOLESCENT MOTHERS INOSUN STATE, NIGERIA
Dr. Olabisi Idowu Aina & Prof. Adetanwa Ibironke
Odebiyi
Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Obafemi Awolowo University,
Ile
- Ife, Nigeria.
Code Number: uaps97028
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
List
of Figures:
1.Introduction 1
2.Research Methods
3.Results
3.1.Socio-Economic Chararcteristics of the selected UAMs their Parents
3.2.Daily Activities, Food Intake, and Child care
3.3.Reactions to Adolescent Pregnancy
3.4.Ante-natal/Post natal Cares
3.5.Childcare Practices and Family Planning Knowledge
3.6.The Control Group
3.7.Discussion of Study Propositions
4.Conclusions and Policy Recommendations4.1.Conclusions
4.2.Policy Recommendations
References:
LIST OF FIGURES
1.Transmission
of Poverty: the Unmarried Adolescent Mothers and Their Children
2.Plans of UAMs if they had not been impregnated
3.The Stage of Pregnancy Before Becoming aware of Pregnancy
4.The Stage of Pregancy Before Starting Ante-Natal Clinic
5.Percentage Distribution of UAMs by Knowledge of Family Planning Method
6.UAM: Poverty Transmission Cycle Schema
1.INTRODUCTION
Poverty
is believed to be concentrated among people with certain characteristics
including low education, unstable employment/unemployment, low status job,
low and unstable income, poor housing condition, large families, absence
of savings, constant struggle for survival and absence of material possession.
The major category of people vulnerable to poverty are women and children,
majority of whom live in the rural areas, or migrants from rural areas with
no skills, and thereby cannot fit into many of the urban jobs. In many cases,
young girls, because of situation of poverty tend to engage in illicit affairs
with older men. Urban poverty in Nigeria has been traced to a high rate of
urbanization, accompanied with high rate of migration, population density,
high rate of population growth, the unemployment, inflation and bad governance
(such that urban centres in Nigeria generally lack basic social infrastructures
to meet the needs of the teaming population).
On
the whole, women and children are reportedly the worst hit by the prevailing
economic crises which have resulted in erosion of the real purchasing power
of the average Nigerian household. The present study presents the situation
of unmarried parenthood as a causal factor of poverty, which can be heightened
by the poverty background of both the unmarried adolescent mother and her
child.
It
has been documented that poverty is a significant factor in the exchange
of sexual favours for material gains (Miller and Rockwell 1988; Orubuloye
et al, 1992). It has been observed that girls from poor homes do not have
access to health information (Hall, 1970). Even when they have access to
such information, the adolescents have been found not to be favourably disposed
towards the use of condoms (Odebiyi, 1991). Also, these young girls do not
insist on their partners using condoms because of the fear of losing a very
wealthy partner. With the present biting economic crises, one of the survival
mechanisms adopted by young girls is to solicit for sexual partners in the
premises of hotels and drinking bars in the cities. They engage in these
sexual relations to augment their income or that of the family.
Again,
there is a growing interest in sexual experiences of the adolescents, with
increase in the prevalence of the AIDS crisis. This is because risk-related
sexual behaviour begins in adolescence (Hein, 1989); whereby majority of
teenagers have had sexual intercourse by the age of 19 (CDC, 1991); and by
adulthood, most would have had several partners (Hein, 1992), and yet with
a low degree of contraceptive use among the youths (DiClemente, 1992). According
to Gayle, Manoff and Rogers (1989), with the estimated latency period of
11 years from time of infection to development of AIDS, many adolescents
would contract the HIV virus as adolescents, and might not realize this until
much later. This risk environment is also expanding in the developing nations,
and much more further compounded by their economic situations whereby both
old and young are faced with daily struggle for survival needs.
In
Nigeria, there is so much agitation about the decline in moral standard.
Adolescent pregnancy is becoming a common occurrence (Aina et al.,
1996), while the deaths of young girls through abortions is causing a great
concern for both the people and the government of Nigeria (Okonofua, 1993).
Religious leaders are blaming both parents and teachers for sexual laxity
amongst the youths. The economic situation in Nigeria is affecting homes
and the standard of living is declining daily.
There
are so many unanswered questions about the unmarried adolescent motherhood
experience. What are the precipitating factors in becoming an unmarried adolescent
mother (UAM)? What are the implications of premature parenthood on victims,
families, and the society at large? What are the sources of support available
to UAMs? Are UAMs always from poor homes? Are there differences in the coping
strategies of UAMs from urban and rural areas? How can the incidence of unmarried
adolescent motherhood be curtailed in the society? etc. These and many other
questions are intended to be answered by the present study.
Objectives
of the study:
These
are categorized into immediate and the long-term objectives. The immediate
objectives are -
i)to
describe the socio-economic background of unmarried adolescent mothers in
Osun State;
ii)to
examine factors responsible for premature parenthood in the state;
iii)to
investigate the type of safety nets now available to unmarried adolescent
mothers; and
iii)to
examine the quality of life/health status of unmarried adolescent mothers,
and their child rearing practices.
The
long term objective representing the final goal of the research is the
accumulation
of rich qualitative data which would help in planning intervention aimed
not only at improving the plight of unmarried mothers, but would also be
geared towards curtailing the incidence of unmarried motherhood among young
girls.
Conceptual
Discussions and Framework:
(a)Major
Assumption of the Study
The
major assumption of the study is that unmarried adolescent mothers would
tend to be mainly from poor homes, and that they were thrown into their present
predicament by their desire to gain monetary rewards from sexual relationships.
Consequently, their own children would be raised in a poorer state and the
vicious cycle of poverty would tend to ensue.
(b)Conceptual
Framework:
Figure
1 presents the pattern of transmission of poverty from parents of the girls
(i.e. as children in their parents' homes); and later through the girls as
adolescent mothers; and then to the children born and brought up by these
adolescent mothers. To trace the processes of transmission of poverty status
from one generation to another, the state of poverty is treated as the dependent
variable, while the predictors (i.e. explanatory variables or the independent
variables) are the socio-economic status of the parents of the unmarried
adolescent mothers (i.e. a background preceding the state of adolescent motherhood);
and the present socio-economic status of the girls (UAMs).
2.
Research Methods:
The
study was undertaken in two communities in Nigeria - Orileowu (a rural town)
and Oshogbo (an urban town) - both in Osun State, of Southwestern Nigeria.
The fieldwork for the study was carried out between September, 1994 and February,
1995. Both primary and secondary data were collected. The primary data were
mainly qualitative data collected through the use of indepth interviews,
and Focus Group Discussions. Secondary data were collected on the available
health facilities in the study areas using available baseline data in the
State Ministry of Health, and the specific LGA secretariats.
The
unmarried adolescent mothers in this study were identified and enumerated
during household surveys, and through key informants and principals of schools.
The study sample was limited to the cases of a total abandonment of such
mothers and their children by the biological fathers of the children. Originally,
researchers planned to use a control group consisting of about 20 adolescents
who were impregnated but whose partners accepted the responsibilities to
care for them and their babies. This would have enabled comparisons of the
situations of both the UAMs without support from their partners and those
with support from their partners. However, only 2 of such adolescent mothers
(with supports from their partners) were found in Orile-Owu. These two girls
were interviewed indepth, and their situations compared to those without
the support of the sexual partner and the family of the man. Also, the UAMs
(who had no support from sexual partners and their families), who were the
focus of the study, were interviewed indepth noting their experiences before
and after becoming premature parents.
3.Results:
3.1Socio-Economic
Characteristics of the Selected Unmarried Adolescent Mothers and their
Parents:
Data
on parents of the UAMs were collected through personal interviews conducted
with the parents of the selected UAMs (i.e a father or a mother selected
alternately in 30 households with UAMs in the rural settlement of Orileowu,
giving 17 fathers and 13 mothers; while at the urban area of Oshogbo, parents
included in the survey were 9 fathers, and 31 mothers). The background data
on the parents of the UAMs presents a picture of poverty and ignorance in
many of the households surveyed, a background which might have precipitated
the UAMs phenomenon. Parents were generally illiterates, poor, and with relatively
large family sizes, meaning that a large number of children competed for
the families' scarce resources.
A
total of 67 UAMs were studied indepth. Their ages ranged from 14 to 19 years.
Majority of them (71.6%) were nursing their first babies, 11% were nursing
their second babies, while 16.4% were still carrying their first pregnancies.
At Orileowu, about 86% of the UAMs got impregnated whilst in either primary
or secondary schools, while 14% had never been to school. In Oshogbo, majority
(80%) got impregnated while in the secondary school, while only one person
had never been to school.
3.2.Daily
Activities, Food Intake, and Child Care.
Each
UAM was observed for a period of 24 hours (a typical day), during which notes
were taken on daily activities, food intake and child care. The UAMs devoted
much of their time to child care and productive tasks. On the average, each
person woke up at about 6 a.m daily, spent 2 to 3 hours on house cleaning,
preparation of breakfast and child care. In most cases, they left the house
by 9 a.m for the farm, markets or shops. At Orileowu, the apprentices or
food vendors among the UAMs returned home to prepare dinner at about 6 p.m.
In Oshogbo, even though most UAMs returned home at about 6 p.m, some still
engaged in the selling of food items such as akara and eko in
the late evenings. The UAMs carried their babies on the back while they did
most of their farm work/trading.
Some
UAMs hawked their wares in the heat of the sun with their babies on their
backs, cooked lunch was bought at the place of work rather than being prepared
at home. The babies were breastfed at convenience. There was no relaxation
for most of the UAMs. Meal times for both the UAMs and their babies were
not too regular. The infants on breast milk were the most well fed. Outside
breast milk, other foods were rationed.
Immunization
was completed for an average child. The mothers visited clinics (where available)
only when a child was sick. When drugs prescribed were unaffordable, mothers
resorted to local herbs for their babies. Apart from some assistance from
their own mothers, the UAMs were solely responsible for taking care of their
children, washing their clothes, carrying them around, and cleaning them
when necessary.
3.3.Reactions
to Adolescent Pregnancy
Data
were collected through FGDs and personal interviews on individual and community
reaction to adolescent pregnancy. A total of 12 FGDs were conducted, with
8 people in each of these homogenous groups (i.e. group was made up of the
same sex, age group, and the same socio-economic class). Generally, the phenomenon
of premature parenthood was frowned at across gender, age, occupational and
religious groups. Those in the older generation, and those who were mainly
from the rural centre appeared a little permissive. For many of them, the
primary role of women is to procreate. According to them - "if girls decide
to start child bearing early, it is all well and good so far they can identify
the father of such babies......". The young female adults at Oshogbo agreed
that urbanisation has led to the weakening of the family ties. "Each person
is now concerned with self. What now exists is alajogbe (i.e. persons
who merely share residence) and not alajobi (i.e. people who share
blood relations, and are thereby committed to each other's course)". Thus,
the upbringing of the child rests solely on parents, while neighbours merely "gossip" rather
than "correct" bad behaviour amongst youths.
The
FGD data showed that generally, members of the two communities (Orileowu
and Oshogbo) were not happy with the increasing rate of adolescent pregnancy
which they attributed to the following:
-broken
homes/single parenthood;
-illiteracy
(i.e. illiterate parents are said to condone a lot of undisciplined acts
among their school-age children);
-changes
in the societal value systems and economic problems which make girls in poor
homes look up to boy friends for sustenance;
-polygynous
homes where children are many and thereby lack adequate care;
-peer
group influence;
-girls
who hawk wares for parents are said to be susceptible to rape and sexual
aggressions/harassment;
-teachers'
incessant strike actions and school closures which make school children roam
the streets unoccupied, and become vulnerable to rape, sexual harassment
and even promiscuity.
Three
major factors precipitating adolescent pregnancy came out in the FGDs. A
major cause generally identified is the social status of families particularly
a poor or broken family, or a family where there is a general lack of discipline
among both the adults and the children. Poverty in homes is seen as a major
cause of adolescent parenthood. A general remark from FGDs is that an average
home in Nigeria now, can hardly feed, not to talk of sending children to
school. Although girls in both rich and poor homes can be victims of adolescent
pregnancy, FGD results showed that it is more common in homes where parents
are poor and are illiterates. Another major reason for increased rate of
adolescent pregnancy is the present political atmosphere and its effects
on the school system. "Series of teachers' strikes and school closures have
rendered boys and girls walkabouts" retorted one of the opinion leaders.
It was agreed that there is currently no incentive for children to read,
given the increased rate of unemployment amongst school leavers, and the
lack of commitment among teachers due to poor working conditions. The latter
was found to be more pronounced in the rural location where teachers find
schools inaccessible due to poor roads. Also, because the rural towns lack
basic infrastructural facilities, most teachers resist transfer to such towns/villages.
A female headmistress in Orileowu said: "at every strike action by teachers,
an average of 20 - 40 school girls are impregnated in the town".
Hawking
of trade wares by young girls was identified in the FGDs as causing unnecessary
exposure of young girls to promiscuity. Over 35 of the girls in this study
got pregnant whilst hawking. About 29 of these said they were "lured into
the act", with the men threatening that the girls dare not report this to
anybody.
Another
important point which came out of the FGDs is the issue of the general laxity
in parental and maternal roles, which discussants found to be due to the
present arrangement whereby parents leave young children by themselves, largely
uncared for. Parents, especially mothers, who are employed outside the homes
(especially in the formal labour market) fail to arrange adequate care for
their children. Such children either roam around the neighbourhood uncared
for, or are kept with neighbours who could sometimes abuse such children
if they are young girls. Although, all the members of the 2 FGD groups who
raised this issue agreed that women have a right to work outside the home,
as much as men; they argued that merging motherhood with working outside
the home have too many negative implications for the children and this should
attract policy attention.
When
the UAMs were asked the reasons for indulging in sexual relations at a tender
age, many reasons unfolded:
"for
the fun of it"; "lured by men"; "to be like friends"; "desire to have husband"; "for
monetary gains"; or are victims of rape.
In
the rural town of Orileowu, girls engaged in premarital sex mainly because "they
were lured by men"; "for the fun of it"; and because of "the desire to have
husband". The case is slightly different in the urban town. In Oshogbo, girls
engaged in premarital sex "for the fun of it"; "to be like their friends"; "desire
to have husbands"; and because they were "lured by men". "Desire for monetary
gains" was a less popular reason. Desire for monetary returns for premarital
sexual activities came out in the FGD discussions much more than the personal
interviews held with victims. This discrepancy could be accounted for in
two ways. One, it might mean that the UAMs were socially embarrassed to accept
selling their bodies for money; and two, this might be an indication of a
gap between societal prejudices and the empirical reality of a social fact.
However, in a society where poverty is not socially acclaimed, individuals
may find it difficult to admit being economically disadvantaged.
Although,
many of the adolescents said they knew that family planning programmes were
available in most health centres, they dared not ask for such services because
of their age, and for fear of "getting a bad name in the community". Very
few of the UAMs from the rural town had ever heard of FP programmes.
The
few (17) who engaged in premarital sex because of monetary gains claimed
that they used such money to augment family earnings, or on other items such
as clothing, food, and sometimes for paying school fees. Trading in sex for
monetary gains seemed to be a phenomenon that is emerging rapidly both in
the urban as well as in the rural towns. For example, over 50% (21 girls)
were impregnated by "sugar daddies" (older but rich men, sometimes old enough
to be the girl's father), while 11 out of the 27 UAMs at Orileowu (the rural
town) reported the same.
The
issue of the "sugar daddies" syndrome came out strongly in the different
FGD sessions. The following are some of the major descriptions made of this
phenomenon:
i.there
was an agreement that this phenomenon is growing rapidly in both urban and
the rural centres with the emergence of the nouveaux riche and the emergency
contractors of the late 70s and the early 80s; and further compounded by
the economic crisis which has left the wealth of the nation in few hands,
worsening the conditions in poor families;
ii.that
the relationship of young girls with the so-called "sugar daddies" is usually
based on "fun seeking" rather than on marriage;
iii.that
many adolescents became victims of premature parenthood as they indulged
in high taste introduced to them by these older adult males with material
riches;
iv.that
the "sugar daddies" factor plays a dominant role in the future of the education
of the girl child in the State, and in Nigeria at large.
Different
reactions have been demonstrated against premature parenthood. UAMs reported
that their parents often frowned at it, but more support came from their
mothers, than from their fathers. A father (at Oshogbo) was reported as having
beaten a daughter to death because she got pregnant while still in school.
Neighbours
and friends become hostile to pregnant adolescents, and UAMs are often treated
as outcasts. Many of the girls said they went into hiding while carrying
the pregnancies, while others felt happy for being alive afterall. Majority
(89.6%) withheld information about the pregnancies from the men responsible,
for they feared such men could lure them into having abortions. Only 37.3%
ever thought of aborting the pregnancies. UAMs said their present situation
of premature parenthood had disrupted their original plans to be in school
or learn a trade (see Figure 2). Over 75% of the UAMs were not happy with
the jobs they engaged in now which were farming, cracking palm kernels, and
hawking.
FGDs
with men, women and school children, as well as indepth interviews with opinion
leaders (school teachers, church pastors, community leaders, etc) confirmed
that children born by adolescent mothers lacked proper care and were poorly
fed. In some cases the girls still had 2 to 3 other children for different
men who repeatedly denied fatherhood. When school girls were impregnated,
they either voluntarily left school before the pregnancy was noticed or were
expelled. In most cases, the boys responsible continued their own schooling,
and often escaped from school punishment by maintaining a complete denial.
One of the opinion leaders in Orileowu retorted:
"nkan
ti n fun yan l'oyun de po lara okunrin de bi pe o le maa fin kiri bi eni
n fin koko ni"
(meaning
that a boy can impregnate several women within a tinkle of an eye) yet "...
he has nothing to fear, no pregnancies, no abortions".
Despite
the predicament of the adolescent mothers, community members argued vigorously
against helping them in any way. They should be made to face the music alone
to deter others. The social environment is generally hostile towards the
adolescent mothers and their children. No wonder cases of abandoned children
are on the increase as reported in the various interviews. One of the opinion
leaders in Oshogbo reported that more than six cases of abandoned babies
were reported during the year at Oshogbo. A school principal in Oshogbo explained
that sometimes babies were abandoned when it became too tough on the mothers,
with the hope that the Social Welfare Department would take up the care of
such babies. She further stated that adolescent mothers faced general condemnation
and rejection, and that they often ended up as misfits in the society. The
school policy is that a girl should be sent out of school as soon as it is
known that she is pregnant. In reality, many of such girls left school before
their pregnancies became noticeable, because of shame and regret.
3.4Ante-natal/Post-natal
Cares
Only
31.3% became aware of their pregnancies at the first month. Others were in
fact unaware until about the 4th month. About 30% were not aware of pregnancies
until about the 3rd to 4th month (see Figure 3). This points to the ignorance
of the adolescents about pregnancies and child birth, and their implications
too. The girls became aware of their pregnancies as a result of sickness
and tip offs from boyfriends, parents and friends.
Although
majority (86.6%) attended ante-natal care, the duration varied. In most cases,
the pregnancies would had advanced before the girls reported at ante-natal
clinics. While about 48% in the urban town started ante-natal clinic within
the first 4th months, only about 22.2% did so in the rural town of Orileowu.
More of those who registered late for antenatal clinics were from Orileowu
(i.e. 35% of those in Oshogbo, and 70.3% of UAMs in Orileowu) (see Figure
4). Reasons for late registration for antenatal clinics include:
-
fear of public negative comments on the UAMs;
-
lack of funds for registration;
-
inability of the young mother to tell the truth about her new status;
-
ignorance, and lack of knowledge of the appropriate steps to take.
The
UAMs registered in various clinics (44.8% registered at major hospitals like
State Hospitals; 23.9% registered at Maternity Homes; 19.4% at rural clinic;
3% at Dispensaries; 4% merely visited patent medicine stores, while 1.5%
preferred faith clinics (churches). In one or two cases, where the sexual
partners admitted being responsible for the pregnancy, they were made to
pay antenatal care fee. Otherwise, the parents of the adolescents paid antenatal
bills.
Most
of the children nursed by the UAMs were still infants and toddlers. Although
some (29.9%) of the UAMs had children who were already between 2 to 3 years
old, none of them had remarried, neither did they resume schooling or other
vocations. This may imply societal rejection of unmarried adolescent mother
in matters of contracting acceptable marital relations, and getting a place
in the formal educational institutions.
Majority
(67%) of the UAMs were informed about children immunizations including BCG,
DPT, Oral Polio and measles vaccination; while 32.8% were not. Majority of
the adolescent mothers tend to self-medicate because they could not even
afford the charges of the healers.
3.5.Childcare
Practices and Family Planning Knowledge
3.5.1.Breast
feeding Practices:
All
UAMs breastfed their babies. This could be due to tyheir inability to buy
manufactured infant foods, for many of them were not exposed to the current
baby friendly programme in the State. From as early as 4 months, many of
the infants were introduced to adult meals, including "amala" (yam flour
balls), yams, rice, beans, "eba" (cassava cereal made into balls), pap, and
vegetable stews. The few who used tinned baby foods (e.g. cerelac) were mostly
from the urban location. Baby food was not a popular substitute in the rural
location, rather herbal drinks complemented breastmilk until the child was
old enough to start adult meals. Observation data revealed that most of the
infants of the UAMs were not robust despite the long periods of breastfeeding.
They were also poorly dressed. Toddlers were naked with dirty clothes wrapped
around their buttocks to serve as nappies.
Even
though poverty environment is a common experience presently in Nigeria, the
problem was compounded for most of the adolescent mothers in this study.
They had no jobs and were living off their mothers. In some cases, the mother
themselves were still rearing children and were also battling with the problems
of large families.
3.5.2Family
Planning Knowledge
Family
planning (FP) programmes and methods were known to many of the UAMs.On the
whole, 47.5% of UAMs in Oshogbo and 5.6% in Orileowu were using one form
of FP method or the other before their first pregnancy, whereas majority
(60%) were rather ignorant of family planning methods and were not sexually
active (Figure 5). These latter were naive and were those either lured or
raped.
3.5.3.Present
Sexual Habits and Parental Attitudes towards the UAMs:
At
the time of the study, about 14.8% of the UAMs in Orileowu, and 40% in Oshogbo
said they were sexually active. Majority (60%) of those sexually active (20)
were on pills, while 40% said they made sure their partners used condoms.
Several reasons were given for the present indulgence in premarital sex despite
the predicament of adolescent parenthood. Two of the reasons are:
-to
make money; and
-for
satisfaction.
The
adolescent mothers were worse off mainly in the area of income and occupational
prospects, and the treatment received from their fathers. Empirical evidence
in the field showed that the fathers were more hostile towards their adolescent
pregnant daughters, than the mothers were. Many fathers would prefer not
to discuss the issue, while some fathers were hostile not only towards the
daughters but also to their wives, who according to them, had shirked their
mother-role responsibilities by producing UAMs.
3.5.4.Possible
Assistance for UAMs, and Suggestions for Prevention of Adolescent Motherhood
as Presented by the UAMs.
The
unmarried adolescent mothers would want to be helped in the following areas:
-
financial assistance to learn and start a trade/vocation;
-
government support for them and their children;
-
acceptance by the community;
-
availability of jobs for them;
-
opportunity to re-enter school;
-
provision of food, clothes and shelter;
-
moral instructions for them;
-
better organized sex education in schools;
-free
access to family planning by school children that are sexually active;
-mass
media campaign against rape and other abuse of the girl child;
-government
legislation against unlawful sex, and sexual relation with children below
the age of 18 years;
-
more discipline to be instituted in the homes etc.
The
FGD reports and indepth interviews of opinion leaders showed that many people
would like to see the government legislate against adolescent pregnancy,
while children who were victims should be allowed to resume school. Children
born by UAMs should also be given subsidized medical care in government hospitals
and maternity homes. Lastly, to prevent adolescent pregnancy, the following
were agreed upon at the various levels of the FGD sessions:
-making
schools, particularly at the secondary school level, single sex schools;
-sex
education in schools and in homes;
-banning
night parties in all towns and villages;
-returning
schools to the missions so that moral religious instructions can return to
schools (this, it was argued, would make young children to be God fearing);
-jail
terms for men/boys who impregnate adolescent girls;
-parents
are to show more interest in the education of their girls while parents should
interact more with the teachers to understand their children better.
3.6. The
Control Group:
Two
UAMs with full support from their sexual partners were used as a control
group (although 20 UAMs in this category was originally aimed at). Due to
the smallness of this sample, they were not treated as a statistical analysis
category. Rather, a small summary is presented on them here.
The
situation of the 2 UAMs (with supports from sexual partner) was different
from those without such supports. The two girls were impregnated by elderly
men (a popular politician and a mechanic). With family interventions, the
men responsible for the pregnancies were made to marry these girls. Although
the girls were married into a polygynous arrangement, they (both mother and
child) were properly taken care of. The girl married to a politician was
at the time of the study selling provisions and baby dresses, while the one
married to the mechanic became an apprentice to a seamstress. The two girls
had moved to the husbands' houses, while their children were well taken care
of. The two children appeared healthy and better clothed. When interviewed,
both said their husbands were financially responsible for their upkeep and
their new trade. The mechanic promised to buy necessary sewing machines for
the wife after her "freedom". Thus, there tends to be a sharp difference
between the unmarried adolescent mothers and those who had subsequently attained
married status. First, the married adolescent mothers tended to attract more
support and sympathy. Second, the fact that the men accepted both financial
and social responsibilities eased the problems of the married adolescent
mothers. Thus, they fed better; they gained a social status; and they became
gainfully employed.
3.7.Discussion
of Study propositions :
Since
the data for the study were collected mainly through indepth interviews,
FGDs and observations - the data were mainly qualitative data. Therefore,
the test of the hypotheses could not be subjected to any rigorous statistical
techniques. Moreover, a lot of the useful data would be lost in any attempt
to quantify the responses too rigorously. Simple percentages and quotes were
used to confirm or refute the propositions (since the statements were not
subjected to rigorous statistical techniques then we cannot talk about test
of hypothesis).
Proposition
1.
"That
the status of unmarried motherhood would tend to be more pronounced among
adolescents in the lower socio-economic class".
To
confirm this proposition, certain socio- economic indices are used which
include:
-income
level of the parents of UAMs;
-education
of parents of UAMs;
-occupation
of parents of UAMs;
-age
of parents at first marriage;
-size
of family - i.e. number of children/number of wives; and
-type
of house and facilities available etc.
This
proposition is tested using the indices above, based on the data obtained
from the interviews with UAMs and their parents, observation data and also
the FGD reports. Data from interviews with the UAMs showed that only a minority
of their parents (15% of fathers and 2.5% of mothers) had university degrees.
In the 2 locations, fathers were mainly farmers, while the mothers were mainly
traders (selling agricultural products/cooked foods etc) and farmers. More
than half (53%) had parents who earned less than N1,000 a month (i.e. income
from all sources including farming, trading, livestock keeping, and other
productive works), meaning that majority of homes are below the poverty line.
Also
significant is the very early age at which the parents of the UAMs themselves
got married. In Orile-Owu the age of the mothers at the first marriage ranged
between 13 and 23 years while at Oshogbo, it ranged between 15 and 20 years.
The total number of children had by parents of the UAMs in both locations
was again very high. Some parents in Orile-Owu had up to 14 children and
in the Oshogbo location a family had up to 35 children.
Apart
from the large number of children, there were also many wives in the households.
In fact, only 47.5% had parents who were monogamously married in Oshogbo
(a family even has six wives), while in Orileowu, only 25.9% were monogamously
married.
From
the observation data, it was noted that the living condition and the feeding
of infants by the UAMs (who are mainly living with parents) were poor.
Above
data tend to reflect a poor socio-economic background, thus confirming proposition
1. Interviews with principals and opinion leaders (especially health workers)
confirmed that most UAMs were from poor backgrounds (i.e. large size families
where parents could not adequately cater for all the children), thereby leading
to some of these adolescents engaging in premarital sex for monetary rewards.
Proposition
2.
"That
unmarried adolescent mothers would tend to lack knowledge of contraceptive
use".
Interviews
with the UAMs showed that on the whole, 40% (47.5% of the UAMs in Oshogbo
and 5.6% of UAMs in Orile-Owu) were using one form of family planning method
or the other before their first pregnancy, while 60% were rather ignorant
of family planning techniques, and were not even sexually active (these were
either lured or raped). Further probing with the UAMs showed that in reality,
adolescents could not often approach established family planning clinics
for contraceptive use/advice because they are still single and they would
be seen as being promiscuous. Therefore, the girls mainly depend on their
sex partners to take precautions against pregnancies. Often, such men deceive
these girls and often give the girls wrong counselling. A girl reported "my
boyfriend told me one needs to have sex several times to get pregnant. Just
an act, he told me can never result in a pregnancy". Above evidences support
the Proposition 2.
Proposition
3.
"That
the present situation of the adolescent mothers must have been caused by
their desire to gain monetary rewards from sexual relationships".
To
support or refute this proposition, the responses of the UAMs as to why they
engaged in pre-marital sex were examined. The most frequently cited response
for engaging in premarital sex was "for the fun of it" in the Oshogbo location
while most of the UAMs in the rural location were lured by men and they fell
for it. The desire to gain monetary reward was the fifth and fourth mentioned
response in Oshogbo and Orile-Owu respectively. When health workers in the
two locations were asked to describe the type of girls who have been victims
of early pregnancies in the respective communities, these are some of the
statements made:
"Some
parents are at fault. They do not give adequate parental care. They deny
their children the money for food, books and other necessary materials in
school".
"Girls
seek financial assistance from these boys and pay for it in premarital sex.
These boys are not to be blamed".
"Most
of the girls who engage in premarital sex lack food and clothing. Such girls
look up to boys for money and they pay back in kind (sexual intercourse)".
"Many
girls from broken homes go into prostitution because they lack adequate care".
Proposition
3 is thereby confirmed.
Proposition
4.
"That
the unmarried adolescent mothers would tend not to receive any form of support
from any sector - extended family/community /government".
Data
on sources of assistance given to the UAMs showed that parents bore the brunt
of sustaining the UAMs and their children. Generally, parents provided such
supports as - feeding, shelter and clothing. FGDs with male opinion leaders
indicated that the community has not been able to help these girls and their
children. The general view of these men could be summed up using a phrase
used during one of the FGD sessions: "eni bimo iya lo npo an" (which literally
means, "who ever gives birth to a child of shame will rear the child herself".
The FGDs with women again stressed that the community could not help such
mothers. Even school children believed the UAMs should not be given any form
of assistance because according to them, "they deserved what they got".
The
school policy according to a principal in Oshogbo is that girls who got pregnant
whilst in school should be sent out of school. Thus, available data tended
to support that the UAMs received assistance only from their parents. Thus,
proposition 4 is again supported.
Proposition
5.
"That
the unmarried mothers would tend to delay seeking competent ante/post natal
care".
The
data from interviews with the UAMs showed that majority (86.6%) started ante-natal
care very late. In Oshogbo, majority (20.0%) started receiving ante-natal
care in the 6th month while in Orile-Owu, about 41% started in the 5th month.
Ante-natal care should begin once an individual discovers that she is pregnant
or misses her monthly flow. But the adolescent mothers tend to delay admitting
being pregnant. This could be attributed to the shame attached to premature
motherhood and the need to hide this from the public. It could also be because
of the lack of finances required to meet the hospital demands. Some of the
UAMs were not even aware of their pregnancies till the 2nd - 4th month. Thus,
they sought ante-natal care late. Above data support Proposition 5.
Proposition
6.
"That
the children raised by unmarried adolescent mothers would tend to be disadvantaged
- fed badly, dressed poorly, and live in poor conditions".
Observational
data on the feeding patterns revealed the hardships facing these UAMs. In
the 2 locations, meals for both UAMs and babies were not too regular. Only
the children on breastmilk were most well fed. Types of food consumed by
UAMs and children (1 year above) were mostly carbohydrate foods. Also observation
data revealed that the children played round the homestead half naked (a
condition which was more pronounced in Orile-Owu). The observation report
further showed that the children were raised in an environment where domestic
animals moved around the homesteads, where open dumping of refuse was the
norm and where (in the case of Orile-Owu), people eased themselves in the
bush. The data, no doubt, support the 6th assumption.
One
could say that such poverty stricken situations are characteristic of many
rural settings in Nigeria, but from information gathered from the UAMs, their
socio-economic situation deteriorated with their first pregnancies. To compound
their problems, UAMs were sent out of school once it was known that they
were pregnant or once the pregnancy was obvious. They were not even allowed
to come back to the same school. This is a form of discrimination.
It
should however be noted that in few cases, the poverty chain could be broken
where the UAMs experienced the following:
-where
the young mother was immediately sent out to learn a vocation;
-where
the young mother was exposed there-after to sex education and family planning
devices;
-where
the sexual partner took responsibility for the mother and the child, and
eventually takes the young mother as a full wife;
-where
the young mother receives supports from the family members and community
as a whole (see Figure 6).
4.CONCLUSIONS
AND POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS
4.1.Conclusions:
Empirical
evidence provided by this study shows that most UAMs studied were from low
socio-economic background. No doubts, the UAMs became victims of early pregnancies
because of poor economic situations, although many of them would rather describe
their premarital sexual relations as "fun". The unwillingness to admit engaging
in premarital sex for money could be attributed to the following: (I) their
not wanting to be tagged "sex workers"; (ii) the general unwillingness to
admit to poverty by the Yorubas. This may be attributed to the derogatory
way in which the poor are perceived within the Yoruba communities. For instance,
in a World Bank study on poor women and children in Osun State, (Odebiyi et al 1994),
it was noted that children and women admitted that they did not have several
things socially desirable, but they still stated that they were not poor.
Poverty is usually associated with "osi"; "aini"; "ise" (literally meaning "destitute", "lack", "poverty")
and these are all derogatory terminologies among the Yorubas.
Also,
noteworthy is the fact that the mothers of the UAMs themselves got married
early and the pattern has been repeated by their children. This implies that
efforts must be made to break the vicious cycle of poverty, early marriage
and more poverty. In fact, the study by Furstenberg et al (1987) found that
the children even got pregnant at earlier ages than did their mothers. The
only support was from parents (who themselves are poor). This means that
the amount of parental support is limited as no help comes from the extended
families, community members or from the government. Other siblings could
hardly help the UAMs because they had to engage in productive activities
outside the home. In fact, some members of the community even felt the UAMs
should be left to suffer for their action.
It
is against this background that the poor and irregular meals, and the poor
living conditions of the UAMs can be understood. It explains also why they
even delay seeking ante/post natal care. This finding corresponds with the
work of Okonofua (1992) in which he observed that pregnant teenagers delayed
seeking ante natal care, and that complications were more pronounced among
this group. Despite all these, majority of the UAMs (67.2%) said they did
not regret their premarital sexual behaviour. Moreover, just below 50% said
that they could not avoid sexual relations completely despite what they had
gone through. The most frequently cited reasons for the present indulgence
in sexual acts were for monetary gains and for satisfaction.
This
raises the need to promote family planning practice among the youths, particularly
as 60% of the UAMs in the two locations were ignorant of family planning
devices before their first pregnancy and few of them were using one form
of family planning method before their first pregnancy. The issue of sex
education in schools should be pursued.
The
phenomenon of the "sugar daddies" syndrome came out strongly. No doubt, this
group of men, generally seen as the "nouveaux riche", used their riches to
take advantage of young girls with poverty backgrounds, or those girls who
are just greedy for material wealth.
4.2.Policy
Recommendations
Considering
the study findings, policy recommendations are made at four levels viz policy
recommendations directed at the government, the schools, the parents and
at the entire community.
4.2.1.Policy
Recommendations Relating to the Government
a.Assistance
to children and unmarried adolescent mothers
Government
should have a plan to assist those who drop out of school as a result of
teenage pregnancy. There should be a programme where such a child could be
catered for by the Social Welfare Department while the mother goes back to
school to complete her education. In this way, her chances of getting a good
job in future will be increased and her ability to better care for her child
in future will be enhanced. This is necessary since as the traditional supportive
safety nets are lacking and with the biting economic crunch, the degree of
assistance from parents are again limited. In order to ensure that such children
are well fed and better cared for, and in order to break the vicious cycle
of poverty, there is a need for a government-sponsored arrangement for caring
for such children.
b.Protection
for young innocent girls
Since
marriages are usually registered, ages of the parties concerned should be
within what the law specifies. Although, there is the possibility that some
can lie about their ages, some documentations should be required to ensure
compliance. These measure could at least help to enforce the law.
Again
government should make a law prohibiting young girls from hawking wares.
In order to ensure that this law is complied with, there is need for the
government to raise peoples' standard of living. For families whose young
girls hawk or sell their sexual favours, may not be thus pushed if they were
able to make ends meet. Families should be able to have their three square
meals daily. With improved standard of living, poor families may be expected
to comply with the law about the age at which to start hawking. This becomes
important considering the fact that over 50% of the girls in this study were
impregnated whilst hawking their wares.
c.Returning
schools to the mission
Government
should also revisit the role of religious bodies in the educational system.
A common trend from the FGD sessions is the opinion that the take-over of
mission schools (especially secondary schools), and subsequently, the less
emphasis placed on moral/religious institutions in schools, have led to the
collapse of the secondary school system.
d.Intensify
the promotion of family planning
With
recorded history of large family sizes, low income, under-nutrition of children
born by the unmarried adolescent mothers, and of low level of family planning
knowledge, family planning promotion should be embarked upon more vigorously.
e.Measure
to curb frequent strikes by school teachers and frequent school closures
With
the background that a lot of the teenage pregnancies occurred, during school
closures and teacher strike actions (as in the case of Orileowu), government
should improve school conditions/working conditions so as to minimize the
occurrence.
4.2.2.Policy Recommendations Relating to the School
a.Teaching
sex-education in the schools
Schools
should make it a policy to teach sex-education.
b.Re-admission
of unmarried adolescent mother after delivery
The
schools should operate a policy which enables the teenagers who drop out
of school to have their babies, to be re-admitted to complete their education
at the point where they initially left off. This will further empower them
in future and prevent re-occurrence.
4.2.3.Recommendations
Relating to the Family
a.Teaching
sex-education in the homes
Parents
should be encouraged to interact more with their children and discuss openly
with them the issue of sexuality.
b.Exposing
parents to the dangers in young girls hawking wares
Parents
should be enlightened about the danger they expose their young girls to,
when they send them out to hawk wares or vend food at such early ages. The
use of jingles, handbills etc aimed at discouraging this practice should
be promoted.
4.2.4. Recommendations
Involving the community at Large
a.Community
Support for UAMs:
The
community should be educated to learn to support these unmarried adolescent
mothers. Even though Nigeria now accepts all children as legitimate, the
community still refuses to give support (moral, social and financial) to
the UAMs. The community should attempt to assist them by organising child
care centres for such children while their mothers either go back to school
or go to work to earn some money.
REFERENCES
- Aina,
O.I. and Ayeni, E.A. (1996), "Adolescent Sexuality: The Experiences of Female
Undergraduates in a Nigerian University". International Journal of Women's
Studies, Nsukka (forthcoming).
- Centre
for Disease Control (1991), "Premarital sexual experiences among adolescent
women, 1970 - 1988". Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, vol. 39,
pp. 929 - 932.
- Centres
for Disease Control (1992), "Sexual behaviour among high school students
- United States, 1990". Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, vol
40, pp. 885 888.
- DiClemente,
R. J. (1992), "Psycho-social determinants of condom use among adolescents".
In R. J. DiClemente (ed.) Adolescents and AIDS: A generation in jeopardy. Newbury
Park, CA: Sage.
- Gayle,
H.; S. Manoff and M. Rogers (1989), "Epidemiology of AIDS in adolescents,
USA" (Abstract # MD07, p. 696). Paper presented at Fifth International
AIDS conference, Montreal, Canada.
- Hall,
Robert (1970), Abortion in a Changing World, Vol. 1. New York, Columbia
University Press.
- Heins,
K. (1989), "AIDS in adolescence: The next wave of the HIV epidemic?. Journal
of Pediatrics, pp. 114 - 149.
- Miller,
N. and R.C. Rockwell (1988), AIDS in Africa: The Social and Policy Impact. Lewiston/Queenston,
Edwin Meller Press.
- Odebiyi,
A.I. (1991), "Conception of AIDS and its Prevention among Students in a Nigerian
University". J. Royal Society Health 112 (2) 59-63.
- Odebiyi
A.I., Aina O.I. and Soetan R.O. (1994), "Women and Children in Poor Households
in Osun State". Report Submitted to the World Bank.
- Okonofua,
Friday (1993), "Clinical Consequences of Unsafe and Induced Abortion and
their Management in Nigeria". Proceedings of a Seminar on Prevention of
Morbidity and Mortality from Unsafe Abortion in Nigeria. Funded by the
Population Council, New York.
- Okonofua,
F.E. et. al. (1992), "Influence of Socio-economic factors on the treatment
and prevention of malaria in pregnant and non-pregnant adolescent girls in
Nigeria". Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 95, 309-315.
- Orubuloye,
I.O., J.C. Caldwell and Pat Caldwell (1992), "Diffusion and focus in sexual
networking: Identifying Partners and Partners". Health Transition Working
Paper No. 11, National Centre for Epidemiology and Population Health,
The Australian National University.
Copyright 1997 - Union for African Population Studies.
|